hidir

updated

7 years ago

H

hidir

10 Posts

0

8828

March 25th, 2020 22:00

XPS 15 9550, U2720Q, 4K 3840x2160 60Hz?

Via the XPS 15 9550 Thunderbolt 3 USB Type-C port, can I get full 4K 3840x2160 60Hz when using the U2720Q?

  • jphughan

    11 Legend

    •

    13985 Posts

    •

    79931 Points

    6154

    0

    Posted March 31st, 2020 07:00

    You can run 4K 60 Hz using a USB-C to DisplayPort cable, or using a USB-C to HDMI 2.0 cable if your 4K display actually has an HDMI 2.0 input.  The U2720Q has both inputs, but I'd go with DisplayPort simply because a USB-C port sends a native DisplayPort signal anyway, so it's simpler.  USB-C to HDMI cables incorporate an active signal converter chip to switch the DisplayPort signal to HDMI.  Just one more thing to pay for and potentially introduce problems, in my mind.  But some earlier 4K 60 Hz displays with HDMI inputs won't accept 4K 60 Hz over that input because they were created before HDMI 2.0 existed.

    There is a known issue with the XPS 13 9350 and XPS 15 9550 whereby using a regular USB-C cable to connect to certain Dell USB-C displays on their USB-C inputs results in no video.  This is the case even though:

    - Those systems work with those displays just fine using a USB-C to DP cable
    - Those displays work fine when their USB-C input is fed by other sources
    - Those systems work fine with regular USB-C cables when connected to other USB-C displays.

    It's a very specific interoperability problem that has been confirmed multiple times.  It was discussed mostly regarding the XPS 13 9350, where it resulted in this KB article, but it was later found that the XPS 15 9550 is affected as well, since it's from the same generation as the XPS 13 9350.  Unfortunately the article doesn't even explain underlying cause, never mind providing a fix (which Dell actively stated they would not be doing), but that's what Dell decided to share publicly.

    But again, if you use a USB-C to DP cable, you will be fine.  Obviously you lose the benefit of power and USB data being carried over that cable, but power was going to be a problem anyway with an XPS 15 for reasons I'll explain below, and USB only would have given you USB 2.0 speeds when using a regular USB-C cable with the XPS 15 9550, for reasons explained in my next post.  If you want video and USB 3.x data, then use a USB-C to DP cable for video, plus a USB-C to USB-A cable from the display's USB-C port to a USB-A port on the XPS 15.  According to the U2720Q product page, the latter cable is included in the box.

    If you need dual 4K 60 Hz displays, you can use a Thunderbolt 3 to Dual DisplayPort adapter, or a full Thunderbolt dock such as the WD19TB.

    Also be aware that the XPS 15 presents special power considerations that can make using USB-C power sources in general a problem.  The XPS 15 is designed for a 130W power source, which is actually above the official 100W max of the USB PD spec.  Dell did something proprietary to stretch that spec, but as a result, the XPS 15 can only receive 130W over USB-C from certain Dell power sources that are designed to provide it, including the WD19TB and certain other docks.  Many docks and USB-C displays -- including some Dell docks and all Dell displays as of this writing -- will typically only supply 60-90W of power, and the XPS 15 also limits itself to 65W over USB-C when using any non-Dell power source.  If your XPS 15 is underpowered, it will respond with slower battery charging and possible performance throttling.  So while a single cable connection to your new display might be convenient (if it actually worked, which again it doesn't always given the known issue I mentioned earlier), performance throttling is not convenient.

    Be careful about multi-purpose USB-C adapter dongles as well!  If you're trying to run 4K 60 Hz from an XPS 15 9550, you need all four of the USB-C port's high speed lanes dedicated to video, as occurs when you use a USB-C to DP cable.  If on the other hand you connect a multi-purpose dongle like the Dell DA300, it will allocate two lanes to support USB 3.x data, which means your available display bandwidth gets cut in half.  The DA300 can in fact support 4K 60 Hz, but only when connected to a system that supports DisplayPort HBR3 (DP 1.3 or better) over USB-C.  The XPS 15 and most other systems on the market even today still only support DisplayPort HBR2 (DP 1.2) over USB-C.  As such, they would be limited to QHD 60 Hz or 4K 30 Hz when running through a DA300 or similar type of adapter.

    Hopefully this helps!

  • jphughan

    11 Legend

    •

    13985 Posts

    •

    79931 Points

    7298

    0

    Posted March 31st, 2020 16:00

    @hidir  happy to help, and glad you found my posts informative.  If single cable is a priority and you're using an XPS 15 with a 4K 60 Hz display, then your only real option is a Dell Thunderbolt dock like the WD19TB.  Even if the interoperability problem I described earlier didn't exist, you'd still be limited to USB 2.0 when using a single cable with an HBR2 system like the XPS 15 9550, and even if you were ok with that, the U2720Q display only provides up to 90W of power, whereas the XPS 15 is designed for 130W.  So even in the best case scenario, you'd see slower battery charging and probably some performance throttling.  Not ideal if you'll be using this as your primary setup.

    By comparison, a WD19TB will carry 130W of power, and USB 3.x data, and enough display bandwidth to run dual 4K 60 Hz displays -- all simultaneously.  But obviously it adds cost to the overall setup.

    And if you were wondering, the regular WD19 that only uses USB-C rather than TB3 doesn't have access to enough display bandwidth to run even a single 4K 60 Hz display from an HBR2 system.  It runs into the same problem that occurs with the DA300, namely it cuts display bandwidth in half to support carrying USB 3.x bandwidth.  The fact that the WD19TB uses Thunderbolt 3 means it taps into 4x more display bandwidth than is available when using the WD19.

  • jimbob74

    6 Posts

    6229

    0

    Posted March 28th, 2020 17:00

    Hi and sorry for hijacking your post but I’m kind of interested in this topic too.

    I’ve also an XPS 15-9550 and finally got my new U2720Q today. Unfortunately, I don’t get a connection via USB-C/Thunderbolt!

    So, I’ve tested a bit around with equipment from my office and the USB-C connectivity: ThinkPad 480 and ThinkVision P27h-10.

    ThinkPad 480 + U2720Q is working.
    XPS 15-9550 + ThinkVision P27h-10 is also working!!!
    XPS 15-9550 + U2720Q is NOT working.

    Ironically it seems that both Dell products are not compatible with each other. Maybe someone of the support can assist here or I’ll need to open an extra case…

  • jimbob74

    6 Posts

    6241

    0

    Posted March 29th, 2020 07:00

    I just had a conversation with the DELL technical support regarding this.

    With reference to the manual:

    https://downloads.dell.com/manuals/all-products/esuprt_laptop/esuprt_xps_laptop/xps-15-9550-laptop_reference%20guide_en-us.pdf?dgc=SM&cid=339178&lid=spr3233963769&linkId=85342611

    You need a dongle to achieve that, but they could not suggest me one and asked me to contact sales. If you figure out which dongle can be used please post here.

    However, I’ve also tested with a ThinkVision P27h-10 (not 4K version) from the office and that worked fine with USB-C/Thunderbolt. It’s seems some devices can also be connected without a dongle but the U2720Q requires one.

  • hidir

    10 Posts

    6194

    0

    Posted March 31st, 2020 01:00

    @jimbob74 thanks for sharing.

     

    I have not tested mine, as it will only arrive tomorrow. How was it connected to the 9550? No detection at all? Or you can still display at lower res?

     

  • hidir

    10 Posts

    6191

    0

    Posted March 31st, 2020 01:00

    @jimbob74 i guess the manual says it requires a dongle because at that year no usb-c monitors is out in market as yet.

    If it doesn't work, i might have to return it

  • jimbob74

    6 Posts

    2958

    0

    Posted March 31st, 2020 09:00

    Thanks a lot for this very detailed explanation! To be honest, I would have expected the support to give me that infos instead the link to the manual.

    Nevertheless, this clarifies the things for me.  One question regarding your sentence […, that means you'd be FORCED to send video to the display through another input anyway in order to keep the USB-C port available for pure USB data.].

    Because I really prefer to use the display as USB hub to reduce cables a bit, I would need 1 cable (9550 USB-C -> U2720Q DisplayPort) for video and 1 cable (U2720Q USB-C -> 9550 ‘normal’ USB) for data? Did I get this right?

  • jphughan

    11 Legend

    •

    13985 Posts

    •

    79931 Points

    2983

    0

    Posted March 31st, 2020 09:00

    I wanted to add a note specific to the Dell U2720Q display building on my previous post above.  It pertains to my comment that 4K 60 Hz requires all high speed lanes in the USB-C connection to be dedicated to video, because if you want to carry USB 3.x as well (such as when using a DA300), you'll be limited to QHD 60 Hz or 4K 30 Hz when using a system like the XPS 15 that only supports DisplayPort HBR2 over USB-C.

    Some who read the documentation of the U2720Q might notice that it can in fact run 4K 60 Hz and USB 3.x data simultaneously over its USB-C connector.  The reason it can do this is that the U2720Q supports DisplayPort HBR3 over USB-C.  But that capability is only available when it is paired with a system that supports HBR3 as well.  It also needs to be explicitly enabled by going into the display's on-screen configuration and changing the USB-C Prioritization setting to "High Data Speed", which allows USB 3.x data across the USB-C link.  The display's default mode, and the only way that allows 4K 60 Hz with DisplayPort HBR2 over USB-C systems, is "High Resolution". In this mode, 4K 60 Hz is available even from HBR2 systems because the display only allows USB 2.0 data over the link.  USB-C connectors have dedicated pins for handling USB 2.0, so that traffic does not require any high speed lane allocations.  If you were to set the display to High Data Speed when using an HBR2 system, you'd get USB 3.x data but would also be limited to 4K 30 Hz or QHD 60 Hz.

    The end result is that even though there's an issue that prevents the XPS 15 9550 from being used in "single cable" USB-C mode with this display, you don't actually lose very much as a result.  The reason is that in ideal conditions, a native USB-C connection could provide video, power, and USB 3.x data.  But if you want to keep your XPS 15 adequately powered for optimal performance, you'd still need to connect the system's power supply directly instead of relying on the 90W USB-C power from the display, which isn't enough for the 130W XPS 15.  And if you want USB 3.x speeds from the display's USB ports, you wouldn't have been able to carry that over USB-C while running 4K 60 Hz with this system anyway; you'd need a separate USB connection for that.  And in fact since the USB-C port is the only available data path from the display to the system on this particular display (earlier Dell displays had a dedicated "downstream USB" port separate from the USB-C video input), that means you'd be FORCED to send video to the display through another input anyway in order to keep the USB-C port available for pure USB data.  And of course if you don't care about using the display's built-in USB ports at all, then the fact that you're being forced to use a USB-C to DP cable doesn't require you to run a separate cable for USB data.

    The only scenario where this known issue becomes a practical inconvenience is if you wanted to use the display's USB ports purely for USB 2.0 devices.  In that case, if you'd been able to use a regular USB-C cable, you could have carried video and USB over that single cable, whereas with this known issue you'd have to run separate video and USB cables.

  • jphughan

    11 Legend

    •

    13985 Posts

    •

    79931 Points

    2945

    0

    Posted March 31st, 2020 10:00

    @jimbob74  happy to help!  Yes it would be nice if Dell Support could provide answers like this, but the reality is that they don't always have in-depth technical knowledge like this.  They're expected to cover a broad range of products, and when you have to broad with your knowledge, it's not always feasible to also go deep, especially in situations like this where there are a variety of factors at play, including an interoperability problem that shouldn't really exist but somehow does anyway.

    But to answer your question, yes you'd need to connect separate cables for video and USB data.  And if you wanted USB 3.x speeds from the display's built-in ports, you would've had to do that anyway even if the interoperability problem I mentioned didn't exist, since otherwise you'd only get USB 2.0 over the USB-C link.  The U2720Q should have come with a USB-C to USB-A cable, so you can use that for handling the USB data link -- USB-C side plugged into the display, USB-A side plugged into the XPS, not the other way around!  Then it's just a matter of getting a USB-C to DP cable for video.  Those aren't very difficult to find.

  • jimbob74

    6 Posts

    2938

    0

    Posted March 31st, 2020 13:00

    Thanks again! 
    I was not really aware of HBR and such stuff, just happy to have a notebook and a display with USB-C.

    I guess the most customers don't have the background knowledge, so I think it would be a great move of DELL to have some kind of guide on the related product pages as also future products require knowledge of HBR, data lanes etc.