UNSOLVED

wbarnum

updated

6 years ago

W

wbarnum

1 Rookie

•

7 Posts

1

3134

December 1st, 2020 17:00

XPS 8940, memory upgrade, OEM vs Crucial

So I was looking at memory upgrades for my XPS 8940. A 16GB stick from Dell is $181.00. What appears to be a comparable stick from 16GB stick from Crucial is $57.99. Am I missing something here? Is there a major difference that I'm not aware of? I realize that you expect a markup from an OEM label, but more than 3x the price seems ridiculous.

  • redxps630

    11 Legend

    •

    16431 Posts

    •

    83176 Points

    2352

    1

    Posted December 1st, 2020 18:00

    Dell OEM ram is always at premium price.  Dell has validated its ram at the spec 3200 MHz for this PC.  Crucial ram is not validated by Dell and may or may not perform at spec freq in this PC.  The latency of ram is factory preset and is different across vendor.  Dell BIOS also does not give you as much freedom to tweak memory compared to aftermarket motherboard BIOS such as ASUS.

  • Vic384

    6 Operator

    •

    3161 Posts

    2335

    1

    Posted December 2nd, 2020 05:00

    @wbarnum You may wish to read this post regarding a RAM upgrade for the XPS 8940.

     

  • CTG_8273

    2 Intern

    •

    514 Posts

    2324

    1

    Posted December 2nd, 2020 07:00

    I do not mean to argue, but Crucial memory is guaranteed to work.

    Dell marks the price up because they can. Just like a 1TB SSD is 3 times higher from Dell. I guess they think they are making money but I have a word for someone who pays 3 times the price when you can get it cheaper from a company who guarantees to be compatible. 

  • BigShuntz

    1 Message

    2116

    1

    Posted January 3rd, 2021 07:00

    From hours of research the only reason they can mark up the price is the product warranty that dell provides, that does not cover 3rd party brands, other than that their brand has no better a reputation than other brands.. I can buy 2x the ram for half the price of 1 stick of ram from dell, its unbelievably expensive

  • RoHe

    12 Elder

    •

    45230 Posts

    •

    172625 Points

    2094

    1

    Posted January 3rd, 2021 12:00

    So if there's ever an issue with the PC, aside from any extra RAM you installed, you can always remove that RAM and Dell will still warranty their OEM parts. Besides, IIRC, Crucial has a limited lifetime warranty on their own RAM.

    Lots of users around here buy RAM for Dell PCs from Crucial because they guarantee it works if they recommended it for a specific Dell PC model, and they have decent prices.