UNSOLVED

McWitech

updated

6 years ago

M

McWitech

1 Rookie

•

2 Posts

2

4305

February 17th, 2021 20:00

XPS 8940, "knocking" noise

Hello,

I recently bought a Dell XPS 8940 desktop in late Dec 2020. I have noticed a noise that sounds like a "click" or a "knock" that occurs roughly every 5-10 minutes. It is comparable to the sound the computer makes when it is shut off. It is a single loud "popping" sound, rather than a succession of beats. The sound happens randomly and is not associated with any application, performance stress or memory spikes. Other than this, the CPU has worked perfectly; no issues. Right now, all it is is an annoying sound - but, I don't want this to turn into a major hardware issue. Anyone else encountered this? Is this related to the hard drive? Power supply? Should I get this checked out? Thanks for the help.

  • DELL-Cares

    Moderator

    •

    27844 Posts

    •

    748 Points

    2954

    0

    Posted February 17th, 2021 20:00

    Hi,I see you’re looking for technical assistance. If you require our help, you could initiate a private/direct message with us, and we’d be glad to assist you.


    #IWork4Dell

    For all non-technical issues that require your private data, we must communicate via a private Direct Message
    Dell Partner GEM Program, Out of Warranty Support options, No free goodwill repair, Get a copy of your Dell invoice

  • Colorado_scott

    1 Rookie

    •

    110 Posts

    2940

    1

    Posted February 18th, 2021 02:00

    A private message??  Don’t keep this private, keep us all informed!! From my thinking there are only a few mechanical devices in a computer; HDD, CD/DVD, fans. Perhaps open the DVD drive drawer to eliminate that as a possible source; then I’d unplug the SATA drive (I assume you have a SSD as drive C). I’m sure others will have more ideas on this. 

  • Colorado_scott

    1 Rookie

    •

    110 Posts

    2906

    0

    Posted February 22nd, 2021 19:00

    Any resolution on this?

  • edd2067

    1 Rookie

    •

    16 Posts

    2903

    0

    Posted February 22nd, 2021 19:00

    sure its not your hdd ? mine does a clicking noise occasionally but its the hdd just moving 

  • VA-Bucky

    6 Posts

    2846

    0

    Posted March 1st, 2021 19:00

  • Deex22

    1 Rookie

    •

    13 Posts

    2671

    0

    Posted April 21st, 2021 16:00

    I got my XPS 8940 SE desktop in March.  It too is making a LOUD clickity, click NONSTOP.  There is nothing on the HDD as I have dual and the noise runs continuously even when the computer is not in use.  It is loud enough that you can hear it across the room, large room too.

    Dell sent out someone to replace the fans, thinking that was the problem and it wasn't .  Then they sent someone out to replace my Seagate Baraccuda 2TB SATA HDD, with another Seagate Baraccuda... and the noise persists.  One of the Technicians that came to my home said that noise is not normal nor good and the second tech said it is normal, plus I've received conflicting info from Dell Techs at Dell.  I am now waiting on a 3, new and different maker.  I am now waiting on a 3rd new and different maker HDD to see if that eliminates the unusual, loud noise.  If the noise persists after this HDD switch I'm going to have to send the computer in to be looked at.  I don't know what they will do differently then what has already been done (because all the various scans, updates... have been done and they pass).  I'm guessing they will just completely switch out my computer.

    I'm posting this on here to see if anybody else is or has been experiencing these issues and to find out what, if anything resolved your noise issue?  I have read numerous posts from people, on different sites, complaining of the same issue so I know I'm not alone.  I haven't quite had this new computer a month yet and it truly has not been a good experience so far.

  • VA-Bucky

    6 Posts

    2632

    0

    Posted April 21st, 2021 18:00

    The sound I get is from the internal Seagate Barracuda HDD. I uninstalled the Seagate Backup software - Both versions that typically come with an external Seagate HDD (Seagate Toolkit is the newer version). Now the "chirping" is only periodic and very infrequent. BTW - I also replaced the Seagate Barracuda HDD through Seagate, but it didn't make a difference until I got rid of Seagate's software. See if this is the same noise you are experiencing - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WM6kUBA03rw

    I did not use his fix because it seems ridiculous to have to install a program to keep the internal Seagate Barracuda HDD busy.

    You should lodge a complaint with Seagate too. Reference my case number

  • 2439

    0

    Posted June 21st, 2021 08:00

    Same noise here, knocking/clicking every 5 minutes or so. It sounds like its coming from the PSU. The 2TB Seagate SATA drive reported bad blocks, so they sent a replacement Seagate. I laughed and installed a spare 1TB Toshiba because Seagate is such a reliable drive vendor. Anyway, clicking is still occurring. I'm waiting on a new WD black 4TB drive from another supplier. However, I'm fairly certain the SATA drive is not the cause of the noise.

  • McWitech

    1 Rookie

    •

    2 Posts

    2397

    1

    Posted June 27th, 2021 19:00

    Thanks for all the comments guys. Sorry for not writing back the past few months - life got in the way! Anyway, I FINALLY opened up my CPU to figure out where the sound was coming from and it is indeed coming from the hard drive (pic posted below). I made a recording of the sound (link below). Again, it happens randomly (every 5 minutes or so), no performance issues, not associated with any apps. Computer works fine. Not sure what it could be. Doesn't sound good though and I'd hate to have it stop working all of the sudden. I might get it looked at. 

    Hard drive clicking sound 

     Computer pic.jpg

  • speedstep

    11 Legend

    •

    46969 Posts

    687

    1

    Posted June 27th, 2021 20:00

    The rumbling noise is mechanical hard drive thermal head randomization.

    The disk arms thrash about the platter during random reads and thermal random movement controlled by the drive itself.

    Screeching or Clunking aka the click of death indicates the drive is dead or has head crash.

    https://blog.seagate.com/craftsman-ship/multi-actuator-technology-a-new-performance-breakthrough/

    If you don't like the noise buy a SSD and clean install windows on that.

    https://www.amazon.com/dp/B078DPCY3T

    Use Silverstone SDP09 to mount it in

    https://www.amazon.com/SilverStone-SDP09-2-5-Inch-3-5-Inch-Hot-Swappable/dp/B0049MPQDG