I noticed that in MR4, there is a new RAID configuration option of RAID 5 (10+1).
I currently have 10 SAS drives in my performance pool set up as RAID 5 (4+1) plus a hot spare and an unused drive for a total of 12 drives. Because I am not a storage specialist, I am wondering if the new RAID configuration would make any appreciable difference in IOP's? I think that by moving to the new RAID configuration, I would gain one drive, but I'm not sure how to figure out the performance difference of moving from two parity drives in my current setup to one in the new configuration.
Providing update here in addition to the Ask The Expert discussion:
I have contacted Engineering directly to provide information in response to your question:
EMC would recommend that, rather than moving more luns and filesystems onto a single 10+1 disk RAID5 group, that two 4+1 RAID5 groups be used. This gives better protection against a dual drive failure without sacrificing performance. I don't have hard performance numbers to post, but we expect the two 4+1 and the 10+1 configurations to deliver about the same performance. The 10+1 (plus one hotspare) will give you a little more available space but exposes more data to dual drive issues.
The performance impact will depend largely on the workload profile. The best way to think about this is simply reducing the sustainable IOPS range to cater for the loss of a data disks. A 10K drive at 4K or 8K will do between 120-150 IOPS a 15K at 4K or 8K between 160-180 (using conservative numbers here).
For the 10 + 1 configuration use 10 data disks, for the (4+1 *2) configuration use 8. Please bear in mind that the 4+1*2 configuration will require some form of aggregation (generally done by pools). The additional parity disk will require an extra parity write, however if cache is performing well and the disks aren't running hot you shouldn't notice this.
Graeme6
66 Posts
1232
0
Posted January 18th, 2013 11:00
Hello pdkilian,
Providing update here in addition to the Ask The Expert discussion:
I have contacted Engineering directly to provide information in response to your question:
EMC would recommend that, rather than moving more luns and filesystems onto a single 10+1 disk RAID5 group, that two 4+1 RAID5 groups be used. This gives better protection against a dual drive failure without sacrificing performance. I don't have hard performance numbers to post, but we expect the two 4+1 and the 10+1 configurations to deliver about the same performance. The 10+1 (plus one hotspare) will give you a little more available space but exposes more data to dual drive issues.
Kind Regards
Graeme