UNSOLVED

joe53

updated

15 years ago

J

joe53

5 Journeyman

•

5772 Posts

•

17269 Points

0

12792

October 17th, 2011 10:00

FYI: MSU patches for XP .NET Framework 2

This might only be a problem specific to my XP system, but I'll report it here anyways, for the benefit of anyone experiencing the same.

After manually downloading, and apparently successfully installing, all the critical updates on the recent October "Patch Tuesday" using MSU's "Custom" list, my AV, Secunia PSI 2.0, and Belarc Advisor all kept alerting me I was not up to date with MS security patches. Specifically that high-priority updates KB2572073, KB2518864, and KB2539631, all related to .NET Framework 2.0, were not  installed.

Yet my Add/Remove Programs lists all 3 as installed, as does my Update History at MSU. I have no idea what .NET Framework 2 supports, but I continue to have no problems with any XP programs.

When I revisited MSU, it kept offering these 3 updates, and I kept "successfully' re-installing them. To no avail. MSU kept re-offering them, and my security programs continued to say I was not up to date.

I received expert advice elsewhere to "hide" these updates at the MSU website, which I have done. My AV and Secunia PSI no longer throw up any alerts. Belarc Advisor continues to insist they are not installed.

My conclusions?

1) At MSU the right hand no longer knows what the left hand is doing. (And possibly what the right hand is doing). At least as far as XP goes.
2) Support for XP is deteriorating. (Perhaps by intention?)
3) Whether it is patched or not, I seriously doubt that .NET Framework will be a vector for infection of my XP system.

  • ky331

    5 Journeyman

    •

    15642 Posts

    •

    45090 Points

    484

    0

    Posted October 17th, 2011 11:00

    joe,

    for what it's worth, Ron was having problems with two (other) XP updates here:   http://en.community.dell.com/dell-groups/rockstars/f/4418/t/19409916.aspx 

    (Sorry, access to that site is restricted to "members" only...)

  • joe53

    5 Journeyman

    •

    5772 Posts

    •

    17269 Points

    484

    0

    Posted October 17th, 2011 13:00

    ky:

    I think the laws of entropy (the tendancy of systems to become disordered, when left unattended) are in play here.

    For many years now, the patches from MSU for XP worked just fine for me. No longer, starting this summer.

    I have now received independent advice from 2 trusted sources (MS phone support, and an MS MVP) to ignore and hide these MSU updates. Needless to say, this hardly generates trust in the system.

  • RoHe

    12 Elder

    •

    45230 Posts

    •

    172625 Points

    484

    0

    Posted October 17th, 2011 17:00

    Joe,

    I didn't have trouble with those, but I have a problem with KB2564958 and KB2592799 which came out at the same time for XP SP3. 

    Suggest you look at the log files for your problem updates. According to the installation logs for my updates, both failed with various errors messages. And they failed to replace prior versions of the corresponding files in  the C:\windows\system32 folder. One of these 2 updates has a dll that's actually older than the one that was already on my system, so that makes no sense either.

     The free Belarc Advisor says my updates are all installed, and so does Microsoft's QFEcheck so you might want to run those on your system. I don't know what to make of the conflicting log errors vs what QFEcheck says.

    Microsoft does offer FREE email and phone support for any update issues so you may want to contact them. You have to dig for the contact info on the update site!  I've used that service in the past and the techs were quite efficient and knowledgable. I may have to contact them about these issues now.

    Thanks, Mr. Gates... :emotion-12:

  • RoHe

    12 Elder

    •

    45230 Posts

    •

    172625 Points

    484

    0

    Posted October 17th, 2011 17:00

    The ULTIMATE insult! I went to the Microsoft Update site to contact them about my update problems:

    Service Temporarily Unavailable
    We apologize for this inconvenience. Please try again later.

     

  • joe53

    5 Journeyman

    •

    5772 Posts

    •

    17269 Points

    484

    0

    Posted October 17th, 2011 20:00

    Thanks Ron, I had forgotten about qfecheck.

    I ran it, and it "confirmed" those 3 updates were not installed.

    So who are you going to believe? MSU? ADD/Remove Programs? Qfecheck? Belarc Advisor?

     

    A pox on the whole ruddy lot, says I! It's enough to drive one to switch to Linux.

  • redwolfe_98

    2 Intern

    •

    1326 Posts

    484

    0

    Posted October 18th, 2011 04:00

    i would contact microsoft's "support" and get them to try to help you resolve the issue..

  • iroc9555

    2 Intern

    •

    1010 Posts

    484

    0

    Posted October 18th, 2011 14:00

    Joe. Ron.

    I know this is basic but, have you checked your event viewer ? I have a log saying that KB2572073 had to reload some component for NET framework 2 to be properly installed. As always does not say anything else and it is in Spanish so... I had more traffic to install those updates than usual though.  The only one I got in English, and I´ve never got it before, is this:

     

     

    Errors by Net FrameWork when rebooting after update:

     

     

    It says: Error to load MOF....... While it recovered the file from the repository. 

    I have never had those types of errors before and they were gone after a second reboot.

    Also, and this David is awared of, I got about 40 or so alerts by Avast Behavior Shield of C:\WINDOWS\ installer.tmp files that Avast asked if they were allowed or not in the installment processes of NET Framework 2, Outlook filter, and SilverLight.

    Regards.

     

     

  • RoHe

    12 Elder

    •

    45230 Posts

    •

    172625 Points

    484

    0

    Posted October 18th, 2011 14:00

    Log files for my 2 problem updates list multiple errors. I contacted Microsoft and they're already reviewing the files I sent and supposed to respond within 24 hr.

    Go here and scroll all the way to the bottom to find the The Get Help Now link.

  • ky331

    5 Journeyman

    •

    15642 Posts

    •

    45090 Points

    484

    0

    Posted October 18th, 2011 14:00

    Hernan,

    Knowing that avast's behavior shield "sounds off loudly" at DotNet updates, I disabled it for their download/installation...