UNSOLVED

AnimeMan1999

updated

20 years ago

0

15791

December 31st, 2006 15:00

SIIG eSATA Epresscard and Inspiron e1750/9400

I purchased a SIIG ESATA II Expresscard from Dell to use with my Inspiron E1750/9400 and now I find out it will not work with it.  Has anyone figures out any work arounds to get it working with the laptop?

 

Thanks Jeff
  • Dev Mgr

    6 Operator

    •

    9308 Posts

    •

    3 Points

    668

    0

    Posted January 1st, 2007 13:00

    A little more information wouldn't hurt.

    What "doesn't work"? Do the drivers not install, does it prevent the system from finishing POST, does it prevent the system from booting (before or after the drivers are installed), does it just not fit, or maybe something else?
  • 668

    0

    Posted January 1st, 2007 14:00

      The card fits in fine in the expresscard slot on the laptop. The drivers load up (downloaded the latest drivers from SIIG) and Device Manager shows it is installed and working fine.  The problem occurs when I plug the hard drive into it.

       When the drive is first plugged into esata expresscard (it is hot plug-able) the Laptop will lock up for around two minutes with 100% CPU usage. In about 1 in 10 times the disk will show up.  Than as soon as you do something to the hard drive it will lock up for a few minutes again and then the laptop does not show it.  This happens in my computer, Device Manager, and Disk Management.  I tried to redo the partitions in Disk Management and would lock up than disappear.   The computer will boot with the expresscard in like normal, but if the Harddrive is turned on it acts like it is going to hang but eventually boots ups.  Same results with hard drive that way.

       The disk drive works fine with a USB cable.  It is a Western Digital SATA 250gb hard drive in a case that uses USB or ESAT cables.  I hooked up the hard drive directly via esata to the expresscard outside of the case and had the same results(checking to see if the case interface was defective). I have used two different esata cables same results.

        When I contacted Dell, I was told that the card was not compatible with the laptop.  A prevous problem I had was resolved by people on this forum when Dell told me there was nothing they could do to fix it. So I was hoping someone had been able to get the SIIG eSATA II expresscard to work with their laptop and could tell me how they did it.

     

    Thanks

    Jeff.
  • noipospf

    15 Posts

    668

    0

    Posted January 11th, 2007 13:00

    Jeff, I have the same card and the same laptop and it works extremely well for me, however one thing you can try as a possible workaround is to boot normally without the eSATA drive/enclosure connected; with the power for the external drive off, connect the eSATA cable to the SIIG card. Then power up the external drive and you should not have any problems; however if the issue persists, I would suggest it is far more likely that whatever external drive enclosure you are using has a poorly implemented eSATA bridge chip, and should likely be replaced.
     
    For reference, I use a Vantec Nexstar 3 (eSATA and USB 2.0) with a Seagate 250GB SATA-II drive in it and have yet to have an issue with it on either my older Dim 8300 or my 6 month old Insp 9400 (e1705).
     
    I hope this is of some use, let me know if I can be of further assistance.
     
     
  • 3sleeper

    89 Posts

    667

    0

    Posted January 22nd, 2007 15:00

    FYI - I have the same issue but with an XPS400 desktop.. Used in homebrew rig and decided to buy a new one from Newegg... Got in Friday and tried everything under the sun to make it work... I couldn't figure it out because the SIIG Bios is starting, showing up every where but once you plus the drive in it locks up for a short time... Then it clears up but doesn't show the drive... If you find anything out = LMK!! Thanx!
     
    BRY
  • 3sleeper

    89 Posts

    667

    0

    Posted February 15th, 2007 21:00

    My suggestion is sending it back for a credit / refund! I threw away like $10 X3 shipping this thing back thinking it was a bad card = and never worked!!! I tried calling Dell XPS Tech guys but they know nothing! It's either 1) Dell doesn't allow internal storage controllers 2) The SIIG Controller card is junk (110% sure this not true) or 3) Driver Issue!! I called SIIG and they advised to try both drivers - one online and one on the CD thinking it was a driver issue but neither worked... They also advised that no issues have ever been brought to SIIG's attention not working in DELL. I know my buddy is running a whole other type of card and works in his laptop but 1) it's a laptop and 2) is not a eSATA Mass Storage Controller Card!!! I'm lost and running 3 external drived via USB... Really wished Dell opened SATA 2 & 3 so we can buy the insert and run the SATA cable through the case....
     
    We only have 3 options: 1) buying another brand and seeing if that worked.... 2) Forgetting the whole idea and sticking with what we got... OR PRAYING THIS HAPPENS - running into someone at Dell who knows if you can add eSATA Storage Controller Cards / Raid Cards....
     
    I was thinking about getting a refund and trying the same model (SIIG eSATA II PCIe Pro SC-SAE412-S1) but adds a RAID Option within the card... But I decided not too because then we might just have conflicts with the already RAID option (Intel Matrix) within our rig!
     
     
    Anybody have any ideas.... I ran it on every PCIe slot except X16 because I need my 8800!!! Can't throw away anymore $$$ so I wish someone else is trying or has done what I'm doing... AKA adding more then 2 HDD via SATA on a DELL XPS.... Thanx in advance if someone can help...
     
     
    BRY
  • 667

    0

    Posted February 15th, 2007 21:00

    I have the Inspiron E1705, Vantec Nexstar 3 enclosure and a Seagate 7200.10 250GB drive along with the SIIG eSata II expresscard.  All the same components. I have the same problems.  SIIG controller shows up.  Hard drive has been initilized and formatted using the USB connection.  When I plug the drive into the expresscard my machine locks ups and I never see the drives.  Acts like a driver conflict to me.  Any suggestions
  • 667

    0

    Posted February 15th, 2007 23:00

    Thanks for the response.  I think I will send it back to NewEgg and try a Belkin Express Card which Dell sells.  I would think it would be compatible.  I also want to have external sata drives for my laptop for photo work.
  • 667

    0

    Posted February 16th, 2007 11:00

    I think the problem is between the firmware on the Seagate drive and the Silicon Image controller on the express card.  Almost all of the esata express cards use this controller and it seems that everyone that is having problems has a Seagate hard drive.  I have a 7200.10 the newest version.  Anyone else have a Seagate and having problems?
  • 667

    0

    Posted February 16th, 2007 12:00

    I am using a Western Digital Drive and having the problem.
  • 198

    0

    Posted February 16th, 2007 12:00

    What mode? 1.5 or 3.0?  I am using a Vantec case and I have the hard drive on 3.0 setting but I read a post where Vantec suggested using 1.5 setting.  What enclosure?  Thanks.
     
    Mike