UNSOLVED

Bryce Aitken

updated

21 years ago

0

9291

June 4th, 2005 11:00

Samsung SD616E DVD ROm drive problems

Hi I wonder if anyone can help me?
I am having problems with my DVD Rom SD616E Samsung drive. It no longer recognizes DVD either Data or Movie. The drive will play audio CD’s but is skipping etc and only reads data CD’s about 25% of the time.
There is nothing wrong with any of the CD’s/DVD’s I am using to test as they work perfectly in my other drive an NEC3100AD.

When I load a DVD/CD the drive hunts for sometime them reports an error i.e. Error CDR101 not ready Abort retry fail.
Only occasionally does a CD work correctly and DVD's never do now.

This has only happened over the past 7/10 days and I have not loaded any software which could have interacted directly with the drive. I did upgrade the bios to A08 but have gone back to A07 which gave me no problems like this.I have uninstalled the drive and let windows XP find it on re-boot but all to no avail.

This looks like a warranty problem as the PC is only 7 months old but I want to be sure before approaching Dell.

Any help will be greatly appreciated,

Best Regards,

Bryce Aitken
  • Predator

    2 Intern

    •

    15286 Posts

    311

    0

    Posted June 4th, 2005 12:00




    Hi Bryce,

    Dell did release a firmware update for this drive to address some read issues. You should fine it in the same file library as the BIOS update but under Removable Media Storage Devices. If this does not help, verify that the drive has DMA enabled and run these Dell tests; click on the CD/RW link in my post and scroll to Section 15, article 14 & Section 12, article 3.


    Best Regards




    God, grant me the senility to forget the people I never liked anyway,
    the good fortune to run into the ones I do and the eyesight to tell the
    difference.



    CD/RW Link

  • 311

    0

    Posted June 4th, 2005 21:00

    Hi Predator, thanks for your reply. I have already checked that DMA is enabled on both IDE channels (UDMA Mode2 fyi)and have also started the computer using a W98 floppy with CDROM boot, this found 2 drives as expected. Under this setup SD616 read directories of 25% of the CD's tested but would not read either data or Movie type DVD's
    My second drive (NEC3100AD) read everything under this set up with no problems.

    I could fit one of my other DVD drives from one of my other computers but as far as I know this would invalidate my warranty and as the computer is still under warranty till 16/10/2005 it would be counter productive when Dell should replce it if, as I think, it is faulty.

    Do you think based on the above it has "gone west" or is there anything else I can try.

    Thanks again for your invaluable help,

    Best REGARDS<

    Bryce
  • Predator

    2 Intern

    •

    15286 Posts

    311

    0

    Posted June 4th, 2005 22:00




    Hi Bryce,

    You testing the drive in another system or testing a drive in your current system will not void the warranty. Yes, it is possible the drive has failed, how did it fair with Dell`s test?

    Also did you try the Dell firmware, if so and the drive still does not work, then the majority of the time Dell with replace the drive when you mention this (If under warranty ~~ which you are, although 16/10/2005 is a new one on me my friend ;) )

    If you have not tried the firmware and wish to do so, I would recommend you disconnect the IDE cable from the NEC and flash the Samsung as the only drive on the channel.

    Best Regards





    God, grant me the senility to forget the people I never liked anyway,
    the good fortune to run into the ones I do
    and the eyesight to tell the difference.



    CD/RW Link

  • 311

    0

    Posted June 4th, 2005 22:00

    Hi Predator have already flashed the drive with f-502 as far as I am aware this is the latest firmware for the 616.

    I will try the Dell checks tomorrow (its 00:48 here in the UK( sorry about the date by the way!!)

    Thanks again for your help will let you know how I get on tomorrow,

    Best Regards,

    Bryce
  • Predator

    2 Intern

    •

    15286 Posts

    311

    0

    Posted June 5th, 2005 22:00




    Hi Bryce,

    At this point my friend, I would say the drive needs replacing. You have done an excellent job of testing the drives, do mention what you have done to the Tech and I dare he/she will replace it on the spot.

    Best Regards





    God, grant me the senility to forget the people I never liked anyway,
    the good fortune to run into the ones I do and the eyesight to tell the
    difference.



    CD/RW Link

  • 311

    0

    Posted June 5th, 2005 22:00

    Hello again Predator,
    have tried the Dell software (ie Windows 95 start up disk) and found that the SD616e drive would read the directories on data CD's but would not read either DVD Data or Movie disks directories.

    I ran the same tests under the same conditions on my NEC3100AD drive and all CD and DVD disk directories were read OK.

    I then went to the utility partition and tested the SD616E. None of the CD's I tested including Windows 95 CD or the Data/Movie DVD's completed the tests all coming back with an error on the read cycle as follows;

    CD inserted does not contain digital data etc....

    Do you think I have a drive which has gone faulty?

    Finally have loaded A08 bios and F502 firmware to my computer so am fully up to date.

    Look forward to your reply,

    Thanks again,

    Bryce
  • 311

    0

    Posted June 6th, 2005 10:00

    Hello Predator as you predicted Dell have agreed to replace my defective SD616E with only a few questions and the minimum amount of hassle. I guess the old adage still holds true, "the three most important things to a sucessful conclusion are";

    1 Preperation
    2 Preperation
    3 Preperation

    Thanks again for your help,

    Best Regards,

    Bryce