Okay, here is some data regarding my DVD burning experiences, success rates etc etc....
First off, media. The number is the (number of successes)/(number of tries). All media are DVD+R.
Memorex 12/25
Fuji Film 0/5
Verbatim 0/3
FMI (CompUSA's brand) 0/10
Sony 7/10
Obviously, I'll be sticking with Sony for a while. It is more expensive per disk, but not when you factor in the number of coasters....
I recently switched to doing all burning with the demo version of Stomp's Recordnow Max. All my Sony successes and most of my FMI failures have come with this burning software, so I am going to stick with it. I was using Nero, and my success rates were abysmal. Also, I think that there may be a temperature issue as well. If the internal temp gets much beyond 120F, my success rates drop way off. I now blow air across the machine with a big fan to keep it cool while burning.
Anyhow, I was changing more than one variable at a time (media, burning software, temp...), and so, I am not sure which, if any, of these factors is critical to success. However, here is a clearly good combination: Sony DVD+R media, Recordnow Max, cool temps....
All DVD-Video discs that I burned are detected as such by Windows XP and play just fine within PowerDVD. I have not tried them on a standalone player, so if you are making backups of DVD's, I have not confirmed that this combo is good for that. I don't really care though, as I only ever care about a computer reading what I write.....
Hope this helps.
Message Edited by bobfandango on 07-24-2003 12:19 PM
Okay, here is some data regarding my DVD burning experiences, success rates etc etc....
First off, media. The number is the (number of successes)/(number of tries). All media are DVD+R.
Memorex 12/25
Fuji Film 0/5
Verbatim 0/3
FMI (CompUSA's brand) 0/10
Sony 7/10
Message Edited by bobfandango on 07-24-2003 12:19 PM
The Philips drive is THAT bad???
I've burned over 30 -R discs of mixed brands (Mainly Ritek G04 4x burned at full speed and G03 1x burned at 2x, plus some Memorex aka CMC Magnetics 1x burned at 1x) and have not burned a single coaster with my Pioneer DVR-105. I have also burned Sony RW discs 10+ times without a single coaster. If you're getting a 30% coaster rate with Sony media, the drive is an utter POS.
The only coasters I have had were Optodisc DVD-RWs, not surprised considering that half the batch had visible surface flaws.
So, after getting much feedback from many sources, I determined that my success rate was more indicative of a problem with the drive itself. I worked with Dell Tech support over the last few days and did the following:
Flashed to A03
Uninstalled and re-installed Roxio
Downloaded and patched Roxio to the latest version of ECDC 5. This was required because Roxio did not support the SDVD6004 in the version that was included with the 8500 (interesting, eh?)
Burned a data DVD and then, after booting from the Resource CD, ran the Read Test on the freshly burned DVD (this eliminates the OS as a possible culprit in the read issue. ). This test failed about half way through. I was able to convince them that an underrun was not the culprit as I had killed every extraneous app running on the machine and let it alone completely while burning. This narrows things down to two things: bad media or a bad drive. Since I have many many coasters of many brands (including high quality brands), Dell felt that the drive must be bad and is sending me another.
I'll post again with more results after I get the new drive and we'll see if the SDVD6004 is a "POS" or if I just had a dud.
Okay, well, I don't know if the SDVD6004 is a dud *AS SHIPPED* or not. Let me explain.
I got a new drive sent to me from Dell by overnight express (I got it 2 days ago actually) and I have since burned 10 DVD's without any problems whatsoever. I am very satisfied that my problem is solved.
So, what is the issue? Let me explain: The drive that came with my system had firmware version .99. The refurbished drive that Dell sent as a replacement has version 1.03!! Yes, you read it here, a new firmware exists! I don't know why it isn't released to the general public... Perhaps it is not end-user flashable? Who knows. But, if you have problems with your SDVD6004, I'd make sure you get the new firmware however you can. It *may* be the case that this is why everything works perfectly now and did not before... Good luck all!
P.S. those 10 perfect burns were on Verbatim DVD+R media. I also made 2 "test" burns on Memorex DVD+RW media also without issue.
Message Edited by bobfandango on 08-01-2003 01:08 PM
Yeah - this is great news - but is Dell going to address this problem?
I assume that there are many customers out there who have bought the 8500 with the DVD6004 drive and are having problems with them...How are these people being helped?
I have e-mailed the tech spt with no word for 2 days. I am really really after the upgrade for the drive, or else a replacement drive. Very disappointed so far.
Oh well - if anyone finds out where to get the upgrade from, or if Dell are reading - then could we please please get some support for this drive!
I called Dell on Friday and they had me go through all of these diags on the computer. Then I read Bob's post and I called them back and told them that I needed a drive with the 1.03 firmware on it. They said ok...and my drive is on it's way to me. Total time...12 minutes. Give tech support a call. No one seems to know where to acquire the firmware, so a drive swapout is apparently the only solution at this point.
I would confirm that your firmware is .99 first, by downloading STOMP'S RecordNow MAX. Then call Dell tech support and tell them the deal.
No one on this board from Dell seems to know how to resolve the problem, so once again it takes the consumer (Thanks again Bob) to get to the root of the problem.
I should have my drive by the end of the week and am crossing my fingers that it really has 1.03 on it and works as it should. 3k for a laptop with a non-working DVD RW is a waste. I feel like I have been walking a tight rope without a net for about a month now.
After 2 unsuccessful attempts to contact tech suppot via e-mail, I decided to ring Dell Tech Support.
After explaining how I had tried different discs, different programs (Nero, Roxio and Instantcopy) all unsuccessfully, they happily agreed to replace my drive. I had confirmed that my drive was Firmware version 0.99 using Nero Infotool.
They estimate that my new drive will be delivered tomorrow (fast!) - very impressed with delivery times of replacement parts if it does indeed come tomorrow. Dell tech support was adequate. No real problems there. Took about 15 minutes to get it all sorted out.
You have to return your drive: Either you return it to the guy who drops off your new drive, or you call a number and a guy will come and pick up your old drive. Not bad!
Will let you know how the new drive goes...Thanks for all your help in this forum!
I am curious to know if you actually get your drive today. I called Friday and was told 2-3 business days. Yesterday I got a recorded call from Dell stating that my 'item' was on backorder and would be delayed 3-5 business days.
I can't believe the lack of support on this high-end computer and drive.
I'd be happy to send my drive in for a firmware upgrade. This way I keep MY drive and I don't get some refurb.
I contacted Dell tech support about a new drive last week, They said that they would send me one, instead they sent me a new computer (5100). I checked the firmware using Drive Properties in Windows XP and the firmware was the same as the previous computer (0.99). Now I have (2) computers With the same drive & firmware. I burned (2) DVD's with the new computer from an image file using Roxio CD Creator with no problems so far.
I just got off the phone with tech support and they told me that there was no firmware update for the 6004 drive. I had him look at the post on this thread.
He said that he was going to call engineering and call me back.
I got his call 10 min. later saying that there was indead a 1.03 upgrade but it was in bata testing and if he could get a copy he would send it to me. He didn't Know when the firmware would be released, could be a day or a month from now.
So it appears that those that get the drives with the new firmware are actually Beta Testers
DELL-BobT
3125 Posts
816
0
Posted July 24th, 2003 21:00
Bob,
Thank you for posting this information to the Dell Community Forum.