helpstars

updated

19 days ago

H

helpstars

1 Rookie

•

14 Posts

•

43 Points

0

163

October 22nd, 2026 01:19

Raid 1 (Mirrored) hard drive failure in both drives. Recovery plans ... please comment.

I have a RAID 1 (mirrored) array with 2 failed drives (in drive bays 0 and 1) and am planning on recovering the array using a former functioning and cloned drive that was previously part of the array.  Please read on and comment on the approach that I am planning.

 

FWIW: the server is on an old Dell Poweredge 1800 server with a PERC 4/DC Raid controller (if that matters).

 

The other four drive bays have two separate other RAID 1 arrays which are properly working (ie all the other four drives in the server are “on line”) and where my data is stored.  But alas the two failed drives on that first logical drive (aka virtual drive) has only my Windows operating system so the machine won’t boot.

 

I have a “poor man’s” backup where I pulled one of the mirrored (then functioning) drives from the currently failed array/logical drive a few months ago to hopefully be able to use as a backup.

 

If I pull out the two failed drives from the failed RAID 1 array and insert the backup drive that I pulled a few months ago (in a properly executed hot swap) into one of the now open drive bays (leaving the other drive bay empty), should I expect the machine to boot up to the Windows server operating system?

 

I was told that I might get a “import foreign configuration?” prompt at initial server boot up (after doing the above swap and leaving the second bay empty) and should emphatically answer “yes” by pressing the F key.  Is that correct that I should expect that prompt?

 

Fingers crossed that the answer is that everything will be ok with this approach.

 

I would appreciate this forum’s guidance and commentary on my approach.  Is there anything that I might be missing or should know???

 

David

  • Dell-Martin S

    Moderator

    •

    3883 Posts

    •

    25810 Points

    1

    0

    Posted October 28th, 2026 12:32

    Exact Next Steps inside the PERC Utility (Ctrl+M)
    Since you are currently looking at the PERC utility screen, follow these exact menu actions to complete the process:
     
    Action Number Menu Navigation What to Press / Select What this does
    Step 1 Main Menu Arrow down to Configure and press Enter. Opens the configuration sub-menu.
    Step 2 Sub-Menu Arrow down to View/Add Configuration and press Enter. Triggers the controller to look for drive layout mismatches.
    Step 3 The Pop-Up Choice A prompt will appear offering NVRAM or DISK.

    Arrow to DISK and press Enter.
    This is the core direction. It forces the controller to import the layout from your backup drive, ignoring its old memory of the failed drives.
    Step 4 Review the Map A text map of your drives will appear. Press the Esc key. Exits the preview screen so you can commit the change.
    Step 5 Save & Confirm A prompt will ask: "Save Configuration?"
    Select Yes and press Enter.
    Permanently saves your backup drive into the system's memory alongside your data arrays.
    Step 6 Reboot Press Esc until you reach the exit prompt, confirm exit, and restart the server. The server will now pass the RAID check and boot into the Windows Operating System.

     

     

    Once you have successfully executed the steps in the Ctrl+M utility and saved the configuration by selecting DISK, follow this exact operational procedure:
     
    Immediate Next Steps
    1. Reboot the Server: Exit the Ctrl+M utility and allow the server to restart completely.
    2. Confirm OS Booting: Let the server pass the POST sequence. It should bypass the previous boot errors and begin loading your Windows Server Operating System from the drive in Bay 0.
    3. Log In and Verify: Log into Windows. Open Windows Explorer to verify that your operating system partition and your other four data drives (Bays 2-3 and 4-5) are all visible, accessible, and showing your files.
     
     

    with kind regards Martin/ Liebe Grüße Martin

    Did I answer your query? Please click on ‘Mark as Accepted Answer’. ‘Thumbs up’ the posts you like!

    DELL-Martin S

    Social Media and Communities Professional

    Dell Technologies | Enterprise Support Services

    #IWork4Dell


    Is Good Troubleshooting
  • Dell-Ravi C

    Moderator

    •

    22 Posts

    •

    68 Points

    5

    0

    Posted October 22nd, 2026 08:21

    Hi David,

    Before proceeding, could you please confirm whether the four drives currently reported as online are configured as data volumes and whether an operating system is installed on any of them?

    If feasible, please verify this by attempting to boot the server from these drives and confirm whether an operating system is detected.

    Please share your findings before we proceed to suggest the next steps.

    Dell-Ravi C

    Social Media and Communities Professional

    Dell Technologies | Enterprise Support Services

    #IWork4Dell

    Did I answer your query? Please click on ‘Mark as Accepted Answer’. ‘Thumbs up’ the posts you like!

  • helpstars

    1 Rookie

    •

    14 Posts

    •

    43 Points

    1

    0

    Posted October 22nd, 2026 11:34

    @Dell-Ravi C​ 

     

    Hello Ravi:

    Let me provide some more context in addition to answering your two questions.  As you undoubtedly already know, the Poweredge 1800 came with six drive bays (0-5).

     

    In my Dell PowerEdge 1800 server …

    -- Drive Bays 0 and 1. A RAID 1 array with two failed drives which ONLY contains the operating system (o/s) and application files.  My “poor man’s” cloned drive is virtually the same as the two failed drives in this array (ie NO changes to the O/S like system updates etc and NO added applications), but presumably the RAID metadata or configuration on the cloned drive is OUT-OF-DATE, thus presumably necessitating the "import foreign configuration."
    -- Drive Bays 2 and 3. A RAID 1 array that has two ONLINE hard drives that ONLY contains data files.
    -- Drive Bays 4 and 5.  A RAID 1 array that has two ONLINE hard drives that also ONLY contains data files.

     

    So to confirm, the only operating system (and associated o/s and application files) are on the first RAID array (in drive bays 0 and 1) with the FAILED hard drives, which is why the server won’t boot to the O/S.

     

    And yes, the other two RAID 1 functioning arrays ONLY have data files (ie are “data volumes”).

     

    David

  • helpstars

    1 Rookie

    •

    14 Posts

    •

    43 Points

    1

    0

    Posted October 22nd, 2026 11:39

    @Dell-Ravi C​ 

     

    I read that AFTER (in this order) shutting down the server, removing the two failed hard drives in Bays 0 and 1, adding the “poor man’s cloned drive to Bay 0, leaving Bay 1 empty, booting up the server, AND checking in the BIOS to see that the drive in Bay 0 is "on-line," that “import foreign configuration” does NOT pop up on its own.  

     

    In other words, I need to proactively enter the BIOS and do the below (and hopefully this old PowerEdge 1800 has the "import foreign configurations" option in the BIOS!):

     

    Step-by-Step Instructions (System Setup / F2)
    1.    Enter System Setup: Reboot the Dell server and press F2 during the startup sequence.
    2.    Open Device Settings: Select Device Settings from the main menu.
    3.    Select RAID Controller: Choose the PERC RAID controller connected to your drives.
    4.    Manage Foreign Configuration:
    o    Navigate to Configuration Management -> Manage Foreign Configuration.
    o    Select Preview Foreign Configuration to inspect which physical disks and virtual disks will be imported. Ensure these disks do not conflict with any existing local arrays.
    5.    Import the Array:
    o    Select Import Foreign Configuration.
    o    Read the warning prompt, check the Confirm box, and select Yes.
    o    Wait for the "Operation has been performed successfully" message.
    6.    Verify Virtual Disk Status:
    o    Return to the main menu and select Virtual Disk Management.
    o    Confirm that your imported virtual disk shows a status of Ready or Degraded

     

    David

  • Dell-Martin S

    Moderator

    •

    3883 Posts

    •

    25810 Points

    2

    0

    Posted October 22nd, 2026 12:06

    Hi,

    No, do not use those F2 steps. Those are for newer Dell servers. Your old PowerEdge 1800 (PERC 4/DC) is a legacy system that uses a text-based utility, not the modern UEFI menu.
    Follow these exact steps instead:
    1. Boot and Watch: Turn on the server. Watch the screen after the Dell logo.
    2. Enter Utility: Press Ctrl + M when prompted by the PERC 4 controller.
    3. Navigate: Go to Configure ➔ View/Add Configuration.
    4. CRITICAL STEP: The screen will ask you to choose between NVRAM or DISK.
      • Select DISK and press Enter. (This imports the layout from your backup drive).
    5. Save and Exit: Press Esc, select Yes to "Save Configuration?", then reboot.
    Choosing DISK forces the controller to accept your backup drive's layout. Choosing NVRAM will wipe it.
     
    Once you boot into Windows, do you have the Dell OpenManage (OMSA) utility installed on that server to safely trigger the rebuild for the empty bay?
     
     
     
     

    with kind regards Martin/ Liebe Grüße Martin

    Did I answer your query? Please click on ‘Mark as Accepted Answer’. ‘Thumbs up’ the posts you like!

    DELL-Martin S

    Social Media and Communities Professional

    Dell Technologies | Enterprise Support Services

    #IWork4Dell


  • helpstars

    1 Rookie

    •

    14 Posts

    •

    43 Points

    4

    0

    Posted October 22nd, 2026 12:46

    @Dell-Martin S​ 

     

    Hi Martin:

     

    Thank you so much for your wisdom and prompt reply.

     

    First, per your instructions, I will make absolutely sure that I choose DISK in the View/Add Configuration screen of the Dell Perc 4/DC utility (NOT NVRAM!).

     

    Question:
    How do I choose that I want to import the foreign configuration for the drive in Bay 0 (not in the other 4 other bays with hard drives)?
    Does the View/Add Configuration screen (in your directions) provide the option to choose that specific drive only (or does the PERC utility know on its own)?  I am not in front of the PERC 4/DC utility screen right now to answer my own question.

     

    Regards,
    David

  • Dell-Martin S

    Moderator

    •

    3883 Posts

    •

    25810 Points

    3

    0

    Posted October 22nd, 2026 14:08

    Hi,

     

    It should see that Bays 2-3 and Bays 4-5 already perfectly match its own internal memory. It will only apply the "import" logic to Bay 0, bringing that single missing virtual disk back online without touching your other data arrays.

    with kind regards Martin/ Liebe Grüße Martin

    Did I answer your query? Please click on ‘Mark as Accepted Answer’. ‘Thumbs up’ the posts you like!

    DELL-Martin S

    Social Media and Communities Professional

    Dell Technologies | Enterprise Support Services

    #IWork4Dell


  • helpstars

    1 Rookie

    •

    14 Posts

    •

    43 Points

    4

    0

    Posted October 22nd, 2026 21:52

    Hi Martin:

     

    To answer your other question, yes I do have the Dell Openmange software on that server and intend to run the software (in order) to check on the health of the drive in Bay 0 (once the o/s loads) if that drive is ok, I then plan to insert a new drive (same model) into Bay 1, and then watch the rebuild in OpenManage. If this is not the correct process, please let me know.

     

    Also, I trust that the option to select DISK or NVRAM should pop up immediately after I chose to View/Add Configuration in the PERC utility (with no action on my part)?

     

    David 

  • helpstars

    1 Rookie

    •

    14 Posts

    •

    43 Points

    0

    0

    Posted October 23rd, 2026 21:47

    @Dell-Ravi C​
    @Dell-Martin S​

     

    Hello Martin (and Ravi):

     

    I need further guidance. These are the steps, in order, that I took and the results!

     

    The failure to see the READ and NVRAM options in STEP #4 deserves your focus.


    (1) With the server powered off, I pulled the "failed" hard drives in Bay 0 and 1
    (2) I put my "poor man's" dated clone of one of those hard drives into Bay 0 and left Bay 1 empty. As the server powered on, I noticed a green light that turned to amber on the Bay 0 hard drive as the posting was occurring (see Image 3). I also was shown that one logical drive (the RAID 1 array in Bays 0 and 1) was "failed" (see image 1)
    (3) I then hit Ctrl-M at the appropriate time in boot-up and went into the Dell PERC 4/DC utility
    (4) I went to Configure-->View/Add Configurations (as shown in Image 2).  Unfortunately, I was NOT given the option to READ or NVRAM (as Martin you suggested would happen)!!!  Instead, after a scan that was presumably being made to identify the hard drives, I was greeted with Image 5 (which STILL shows the two hard drives for the FAILED logical drive, i.e. the hard drives in Bay 0 and the one in Bay 1) as "FAILED" (that information is presumably stale as Bay 1 at least is empty).
    (5) I was able to inspect Drive 0 by pressing F2 which shows that the cloned drive information is being recognized (Seagate, Product ID, etc.) see Image 4
    (6) When I pressed F3 to see the "Logical Drives," I was greeted with Image 6 which still shows Logical Disk 1 (the first RAID array) as OFFLINE.


    NONE OF THE OPTIONS AS SHOWN AT THE BOTTOM OF IMAGE #5 DID ANYTHING.

     

    Hmhm, what do you suggest as next steps?

     

    I will try to post the SIX IMAGES (LABELED IMAGE 1 THROUGH 6) INTO ANOTHER POST.

     

    David

  • helpstars

    1 Rookie

    •

    14 Posts

    •

    43 Points

    1

    0

    Posted October 23rd, 2026 21:49

    IMAGE ONE IS HERE.  IMAGE ONE IS HERE.

     

    IMAGE 1