Anyone out here ever try running PowerEdge T110 II with Emulex/QLogic or other brands of HBAs? The system cannot even pass the BIOS. Unplug the QLogic QLE2562 everything works fine. We asked Dell support they said this is entry model not designed to connect to a SAN. Interesting PowerEdge is a server if it is not supposed to connect to a SAN what is the purpose of being PowerEdge. Anyone can offer some help?
I wish support were more technical in their explanations and i don't understand what needs to be designed into a bios or motherboard so as to connect a PCIe x8 HBA and have it work on your system. Maybe it's some licensing issue like those iSCSI offload keys that some Ethernet HBA's require, maybe some Option ROM settings or limitations within the BIOS, i don't know though Dell support should know.
In such situations, and without a technical explanation, maybe Dell support's statement of "an entry level model not designed to connect to SAN" should be paraphrase to something like "if you have money for SAN, you have money to buy a more expensive server".
If a dirt cheap desktop grade Intel motherboard can run the same 'enterprise' grade HBA without problem, we simply don't understand what's the point buying a Dell, oops, not just a Dell, it's a PowerEdge, and it's a server. What a shame we bought a couple and now they sit there at the data center laughing at us and Dell's salesmen are trying to propose us to 'upgrade' to R720. If I am the one to decide, I will never buy from Dell again. We picked 110 not because they're cheap, we simply need that many PCIe slots, E3 Xeon and acoustics. We actually don't mind they charge us more to get it supported.
Now we disassembled everything, throw away their 'PowerEdge' motherboards and switched to Intel's instead. The more we browse this forum about T110 the more we think this is simply a piece of junk we can only stay away.
Anyone wants a T110 II board we are more than happy to give away if you are willing to pay freight.
All vendors have shortcomings and should strive to improve on their products, support and services, but giving them feedback seems to fall on deaf ears.
In my case, i purchased a Dell laptop and upgraded to Win7Ultimate64, specifically to encrypt the boot drive using BitLocker. Dell happily sold me the upgrade knowing why i wanted it. However, i later found out that there was no TPM module on the mobo so i couldn't use the BitLocker feature as intended. Sales and support were useless in resolving this issue for me so i researched and fixed the problem myself via a registry change and a USB flash drive. Dell couldn't understand their contribution to the issue i was faced with and couldn't offer any solution. Not even a small usb flash drive as a gesture of goodwill was offered. I doubt they have updated their sales/support staff's knowledge of BitLocker requirements or workarounds.
However i did keep the laptop as once i resolved the problem myself, it did what i wanted and i liked it. I liked the laptop so much i didn't bother with getting the screen replaced due to the one dead pixel it had from day 1. But due to Dell's poor form on other issues, i question whether my goodwill is warranted. Maybe i should get them to come out and replace the screen as it still has full coverage and i'm starting to feel it's often a one way street with Dell.
In your case, i wouldn't have disassembled the T110 but instead taken a hard line view and demanded consumer law be honored and a full refund provided for this 'not fit for purpose' machine. It also seems Dell's solution is what some may call 'switch and bait' which is specifically targeted as illegal under consumer law in most jurisdictions (IANAL but many jurisdictions make no distinction between consumers and businesses entities). I would have made a point of returning the unit and buying a replacement from another vendor. In essence that's what you did by replacing the mobo though Dell was still rewarded by virtue of being paid for the T110 and your paid for warranty is now questionable.
In instances like this, when a product is purchased for a specific use and is then found to be 'not fit for purpose', i wish the vendors take more responsibility for the disjoint in expectation, especially when they contributed to the issue via design choice, inaccurate documentation, advice or by silence, (and later cry an industry standard interface like PCIe can't accept a card designed to that standard because the system one bought is a 'base model'). This is very poor form indeed.
Still, I like Dell but they need to refocus as they seem to be loosing the plot. I also like these forums which are rather good with a wealth of information contained within and a knowledgeable bunch of people that frequent them.
skylarking
2 Intern
•
548 Posts
252
0
Posted March 7th, 2012 01:00
I wish support were more technical in their explanations and i don't understand what needs to be designed into a bios or motherboard so as to connect a PCIe x8 HBA and have it work on your system. Maybe it's some licensing issue like those iSCSI offload keys that some Ethernet HBA's require, maybe some Option ROM settings or limitations within the BIOS, i don't know though Dell support should know.
In such situations, and without a technical explanation, maybe Dell support's statement of "an entry level model not designed to connect to SAN" should be paraphrase to something like "if you have money for SAN, you have money to buy a more expensive server".