In looking at past postings on this topic, I find two conflicting recommendations. The first is to calibrate the U2410 in Custom Color mode, as recommended by several contributors here:
I am wondering what the latest on this is. I have been using the Eye-One Match 3, calibrating in Standard mode. It looks OK, but I can't get the white point to 6500. It seems to want to say at 5700 or 5800, with no way to adjust.
Is there any definitive guide to calibrating this monitor?
I've been using Custom mode since I got my U2410 last October, but your post made me rethink my decision. Back then I used the i1 DisplayLT, and must admit that I didn't consider dE values til I started reading your links. Not only did the calibration program not give me dE values (IIRC) but they were a bit too much for me to digest at the time as well. Since then I've upgraded to Display 2 which allows me to run a profile validation that generates dE values.
Your post interested me it two ways. First, I was curious about how you couldn't get to the 6500k white point using Standard mode, as I recall running into the same thing back in October. Second, was the dE thingy I read about in your links.
First thing I did was run a profile validation on my most recent profile dated 7/18/2010, which was created using the monitor's Custom mode and RGB sliders (in the i1 software this required selecting the RGB "Controls" option in the white point dialog). Then I created a new profile using Standard mode, which doesn't offer RGB sliders (in the i1 software this required selecting the RGB "Presets" option). Then I ran a profile validation for the new profile and compared the two. Sure enough, there was a difference....
dE2000 values Avg_Max_MonitorMode 0.46 1.36 Standard 4.44 11.3 Custom
While creating the new profile, I noted the steps taken and the results (both shown below). I was especially interested in seeing if I still had trouble meeting my 6500k white point target, as Standard mode no longer gives me RGB controls to adjust it. Long story short, back in October either I didn't use the LT version of the software correctly, or didn't wait to complete an entire calibration and read the final report. From this recent run, it seems the software reports in the White Point dialog a current white point that cannot be adjusted and must be accepted as-is, I may have cancelled the whole calibration process at that point back in October. However, this time I let the program complete the measuring process and finish regardless of the seemingly unadjustable white point. Once the program finished, the white point had been adjusted automatically to meet my target.
Here's the step-by-step (starting from a previous calibration using Custom mode):
-Change monitor from Custom to Standard mode (screen got brighter) -Start i1 Display2 Eye-Match3 software :-) -Choose Advanced profiling mode -Choose monitor type -Set Calibration Targets (mine were, white point 6500k, gamma 2.2, luminance 100. Same targets were also used in Custom mode.) -Place calibration device on monitor -Set the contrast (mine had not changed, monitor is still set to 98) -Set your white point - choose RGB Presets (this is where you have no way to adjust the current white point and must accept it. Mine was 6200k.) -Set your luminance - because my screen got brighter when I switched to Standard mode, I needed to adjust the monitor's brightness down from 10 to 3. -Measuring.... -Save Profile - final report (those same figures also appeared in the report when I finished calibrating using the Custom mode, though the dE values are much different)
Target/Current 6500k 6500k Color Temperature 2.2 2.2 Gamma 100.0 100.7 Luminance (min 0.2 cd/m2)
I noted the following differences on the graphs found in the final report.
-In Custom mode the RGB lines are closer to linear, they want to hug the straight diagonal line (avg dE 4.44).
-In Standard mode the lines tend to stray farther from the diagonal the closer they get to the top of the scale (avg dE 0.46).
It appears the trade-off for getting a low dE is the manner in which the RGB curve is profiled. Frankly, I don't see any visible difference in the few images I've looked over. Though I want to think they look better with a lower dE, despite the nonlinear RGB curves, I really couldn't tell the difference without being able to toggle between the two (as with Photoshop layers). However, in Standard mode the calibration is easier because the white point setting is performed automatically, no RGB sliders to adjust on the monitor.
This seems to me to be a situation where the lower dE numbers may technically be better, but one may be hard pressed to actually see the difference visually. Without a side-by-side to choose from, I'd have to go with the Standard mode calibration simply because it's easier.
In108, could you please try those steps and let me know if they get you to your white point target?
Chris, given the above info can you offer any suggestions on what specifically to look for in an image, or a certain type of image in which the difference may be clearly visible? I'm at a loss without before & after versions to view at the same time:-)
i'm a Mac user, i've Spyder 3 Elite, but i'm still not clear on the process. seems the CUSTOM is the prefered way. however:
even before i start calibrating, the system already has a color profile showing: usually that says DELL U2410
so is that ok to calibrate with that profile ? let's say i calibrate the monitor and the system has assigned the latest profile, although it doesn't look right.
Can i just calibrate again without regard to the profile that the system is using ?
ps: if you would not mind, i would like to try your calibrated profiles, please email:
I'm a Windows XP user and have the Xrite i1 Display2, so I really can't comment on how your Spyder unit & software interacts with your MAC operating system.
On my system it's normal for another profile to be current/active whenever I start a new calibration routine. At the beginning of the calibration process my i1 software temporarily disables the current profile (I can see the screen change when this occurs, and the documentation points that out as well). Having said that, and assuming your Spyder software works in a similar manner, I would say it is OK to disregard any currently active profile the system is using at the time your start your new calibration. IOW The currently active profile shouldn't affect the calibration because it's disabled during the calibration process.
Forgot to mention, the best calibration results that I achieved were with i1 Pro spectrophotometer and dispcalGUI/Argyll free calibration package running i1 in high resolution adaptive mode. Takes an awful long time with large set of measurements but gave me the smoothest gray ramp.
The Custom mode has a non linear response (see here for more details www.prad.de/.../review-dell-u2410-part8.html ) so it cannot be properly calibrated/verified. It looks like the problem in firmware but since Dell does not give any information nor firmware upgrade promise I doubt it will ever be fixed. Their other monitor with similar firmware and control (Dell U2711) does not have this problem and all is working fine.
For now I solved this for myself by calibrating the standard mode with calibration of the white point through service menu. It is still not ideal because in all modes apart from custom U2410 applies different and very weird gamma curves and you cannot change that. Calibration through video card LUTs give you a noticable banding in gray ramp because it has to adapt existing gamma curves. For the monitor that was advertised with intended use for photographers and such this seems a bit strange and you would have hoped that firmware should be a bit better designed (either custom mode working or ability to pick/adjust the gamma in other modes).
DELL-Chris M
Community Manager
•
56891 Posts
•
232143 Points
3315
0
Posted July 29th, 2010 07:00
This shows that calibration is subjective to the veiwer. Try them all and see what yields the best result.
DELL-Chris M (old account)
#IWork4Dell