UNSOLVED

gabeh1018

updated

20 years ago

G

gabeh1018

6 Posts

0

19257

June 14th, 2006 13:00

Just received my new 2007fwp A02

I just received my replacement monitor today. BTW thanks chris for handling this very promptly;however, i still am experiencing color banding in desktop mode when i watch DVDs or 720p video files. Is there a setting or something i am supposed to turn off??? I am using the DVI cable into my Nvidia Geforce 6600 GT and at 1680x1050.


Gabe
  • gabeh1018

    6 Posts

    637

    0

    Posted June 14th, 2006 13:00

    so when there is a water or sky scene... its ok to see big blocks of colors jumbled together?!?!
  • Mudcrutch

    44 Posts

    637

    0

    Posted June 14th, 2006 13:00

    on my 2007fwp with banding -- its not noticable (that i can tell) on anything BUT a gradient or that gradient test.

    i am thinking you are seeing the natural pixelation in the blacks and dark colors that is normal with dvd viewing on monitors.

    try sitting back a bit further -- you probably wont notice it.

    i am not trying to imply that you don't have the issue, im just trying to give you some ideas... :)
  • njchris

    4 Posts

    637

    0

    Posted June 14th, 2006 13:00

    I just received mine this morning, but I was on my way to work so I can't test it out.
     
    Are you sure those DVDs don't have the banding in them from the way their compression was done?
     
    Does the gradient test show banding?
     
     
  • gabeh1018

    6 Posts

    637

    0

    Posted June 14th, 2006 13:00

    im not quite sure what to look for when looking at a gradient test jpeg... the DVDs i was watching were store bought DVDs i tried out like 5 different movies and i still see banding....
  • BdoUK

    3 Posts

    637

    0

    Posted June 14th, 2006 14:00

    Even though DVD is now a mature format, many movies still suffer from pretty bad compression problems. I think LCD displays in general show compression problems more than CRT based displays. Also having your brightness set too high will cause the compression to be more apparent. Try calibrating your brightness setting to ISF standards.
  • Maestro2u

    15 Posts

    637

    0

    Posted June 14th, 2006 14:00

    My wife just IM'd me at work to let me know my replacement monitor has arrived also.  Man, now I'll be thinking about it all day.  Good news though for those of us who have been quietly wondering what kind of time frame we're in for receiving these. 
  • lordkosc

    11 Posts

    637

    0

    Posted June 14th, 2006 14:00

    Have you tried any games on the new monitor and or ran a gradient test? Also did your new revision have any dead pixels?
  • technicolor

    36 Posts

    637

    0

    Posted June 14th, 2006 17:00

    How long after sending Chris your pms did you get your monitors?
  • 637

    0

    Posted June 14th, 2006 18:00

    Mine has zero subpixel defects. 
     
     
    I ran the previous gradient test posted in the original thread again - this time in desktop mode, there are very very closely spaced delineations in part of the gradient - in all, among what one should expect with an LCD - as good or better than my other monitors.
     
    I was able to switch to the two other viewing modes, Multimedia and Gaming, and both look like my old monitor - much much worse.  So it definitely looks like turning off the processing is improving things.  It's still not a perfectly smooth gradient, but again - I've never seen one on an LCD with the test I'm using.
     
     
    Most importantly, my images aren't posterized any more.  This was critical for me since I'll be using this monitor for photo editing and was having problems with the first monitor - figuring out whether  or not a manipulation was creating an unnatural gradient.
  • Fiontar

    3 Posts

    231

    0

    Posted June 14th, 2006 20:00

    Got mine today. Vast improvement in gradient. If you put your eyes a few inches from the screen, there is very, very slight banding over the entire gradient, but seems par for the course for LCDs. In any event, from a normal viewing distance no banding! One thing I noticed is that the other two modes, although still having noticable banding, aren't as bad as they were on my first monitor, so maybe there was some other tweaking as well.

    Text is super sharp, no dead or stuck pixels.

    Looks good DVI and VGA.

    NOTE: If you are using VGA, the phase and pixel clock settings were pretty messed up out of the box. Set them to 50 and then do any tweaking you need from there. My phase came set at 100 and I could really see the "dancing colors" effect in the two non desktop modes, adjusting the phase fixed this.

    Tonight I'll retweak my color settings to preference and get a better idea of how things look beyond the fixed banding issue. So far I'm very happy with the new monitor. Only problem now is that I definitely want a second fixed one for a dual monitor setup! :)

    Oh, I find this program extremely helpful in not only testing for banding, but also checking for dead pixels, adjusting phase, etc...

    http://www.ykwong.com/checkemon.html