
UNSOLVED
H
hrvoje_marin
23 Posts
0
58975
January 23rd, 2010 05:00
Green Pink tint explanation IPS U2410 2209WA ...
Can someone, pls, explain why this green pink tint occurs? Coating?
Cheers,
Marin
Responses (1)
Solutions (0)

hrvoje_marin
23 Posts
0
58975
January 23rd, 2010 05:00
Can someone, pls, explain why this green pink tint occurs? Coating?
Cheers,
Marin
Responses (1)
Solutions (0)
P.A.K
56 Posts
1648
0
Posted January 23rd, 2010 10:00
It's something related to the manufacturing process of the panel itself. Since you can get red (which shows as pink on a white background), green, and blue tint it's a very good indication that it's something related to the actual liquid crystals and/or the polarizing filters.
Also, the uniformity issues are not in completely random patterns on the display.. There are 3 specific patterns, which are diagonally (usually always seems to be bottom left to top right, rather than top left to bottom right), top to bottom, and left to right. It also tends to be either 1 or 2 main colour tints noticeable.. IE it can go from a green tint on one side to pink on the other, or it may only be pink on one side with no tint visible on the other side. Finally, tint can range from not present at all, to barely noticeable, to painfully obvious. This is a further clue that it's something being done to the liquid crystal layer / polarizing filters when the panel is being made, and probably happens due to the way something (perhaps pressure) is applied to the panel whilst being built. If it's applied very evenly the result is a display with no noticeable colour gradation (aka tint). However the process appears to be "hit or miss" which results in some panels being great, and others "not so good".
Why, so-called "premium", panels like IPS should be more prone to this than some cheap TN panels is undoubtedly linked to how they are made. On IPS screens the liquid crystals are parallel to the panel, rather than perpendicular in TN panels, which is what creates the better viewing angles. So the process of construction is slightly different. The thing that makes IPS more expensive is that they have 2 transistors for each pixel, rather than the 1 used on a TN panel. This means they tend to need a stronger backlight which adds to costs (and is why you haven't seen IPS screens much on laptops.. they tended to eat more battery power).
The smarter amongst you might have realized that this also means the U2410 is twice as likely to have dead pixels as a cheap TN panel, because it has double the amount of transistors to go wrong. As these panels also cost more to create it means manufacturers are more reluctant to get rid of any panels with problems, and so many TN panels might have higher standards applied because it costs less to eliminate any problem panels. Who said more expensive is always better? ;)
I also think it's likely that part of the reason why you're seeing more complaints about the current generation of LG panels, used in the U2410, is because of its very wide gamut. It simply means that those variations in the uniformity stick out more because the reds are more red and the greens are more green etc.. so any tint is more red or green too ;)
What can be done about it? Well, on LG's end they need to improve their panel making process. Unfortunately their primary purpose for making panels is TV's. On TV's you have constantly changing images, and are rarely looking at the same static backgrounds for long periods (which is what you tend to do all the time on a computer). So uniformity issues, even pretty bad ones, are much less likely to be noticed on TV's and this means it's probably not a top priority for them. The best we can do is let companies like Dell know we are not happy about this, and hopefully that puts a bit of pressure on LG to fix their manufacturing issues.
On Dells end they need to get Innolux, who are the actual manufacturer of the U2410, to provide more full featured uniformity controls for a price which is reasonable, at least until LG improve their manufacturing process. Although the U2410 only represents the "middle" of the market (IE you can get cheaper screens, but also ones which are much more expensive), adding such controls really shouldn't add that much to the overall price. Evidence for this is that the UK price Dell charges for the U2410 is actually higher than the USA price NEC charges for its 24 inch WUXI screen which contains corrective controls (NEC call the feature Colorcomp). Thus the price rise arguably wouldn't be that bad, and Dell will certainly sell a greater volume of screens than NEC, which should lower the prices of such solutions further. The main problem is convincing Dell to add these features if they think a lot of users will never notice these issues (and they might not - which begs the question what the heck are they doing buying IPS panels in the first place, since they'd probably be equally happy with a TN panel!!)
On the consumer end it's important to know that, as long as the tint is of the very mild variety, it can be corrected by carefully calibrating or turning down the Gain values of the tint colours in Custom Mode, and using Offset to tweak any tint still noticeable on greyscale images in the same way, after you've adjusted the gain. An overall uniform tint (usually the whole screen being too pink.. ie red) can also be very easily fixed by turning down that particular value or by using hardware calibrating devices. So, if someone has the issue, have a go at fixing it before you give up and send the screen back, because it's possible to fix more minor gradation issues, and a single (uniform) tint should always be correctable.
Other than the anti-glare coating being a bit thick (which doesn't bother me, I'd just prefer if it was a bit less so), the tint issue is really the only "real" problem I think the U2410 has. I'm otherwise really happy with mine. So I hope Dell can come up with a solution to these issues. If you're going to even bother with a "premium" label, at least let it mean something more than a better viewing angle and a doubling of your chances of dead pixels :)
Btw - If someone knows the precise technical nature of why the tint issue happens, it'd be interesting to know.