Just on the phone to Dell technical support from Australia regarding banding and dead pixels on my monitor and after telling the tech support person I had an A02 model I was told there was another revision being worked on to fix the banding but he couldn't give me a specific date that it would be released... Has anyone else been told this?
From what I have read recently on these forums there has been no official confirmation yet that there would ever be an A03... Would ChrisM be able to confirm this at all?
Someone on WP forums reported that they got an arrangement that if there was an A03 they would be allowed to replace it (but not actually that one is being worked on).
There are signs here too though, like "I will take it to the product group
who will then chuck my piece of paper out the window
" :smileyhappy:
Well yeah this guy (from Dell technical suport) said that a new revision is being worked on but may not be out for a few months and I could get it replaced then... But i've read all the discussion both here and on whirlpool (yet I still went and bought the monitor, go figure) so I thought it seemed a little doubtful...
The real question is though, with all the well documented issues in this monitor; all the people complaining, replacing and returning them; why is there no A03 being worked on? Surely they could at least fix the most obvious and abundant issue which is the banding...
I know ChrisM has asked for a list of the issues in another thread to present to the product group, but has any progress been made with this?
Even if this was true, the whole "may not be out for a few months" is what really bothers me. This monitor is already rev. A02, but more like Beta .A02.
So when this rev. A03 does come to fruition, and we begrudgingly get our replacements that take another 6 weeks to get to their distribution points, and another 2 weeks to get to our homes is Dell going to graciously pro-rate the price of the monitor?
Why not zip in to the Factory setting menu, and when they process the exchange they can just multiply the number of hours the panel has been run by $0.20 for product testing and quality assurance. ;)
Better idea is to chuck the monitor all together, and find another one that has no issues ( They are out there ). This has been going on far too long for those that want a good Dell monitor, and Dell is doing very little in the way of correcting this issue with revisions that do not work for the most part, having one of three Modes semi fixed, which you paid for all three to work, and the other issues that have been mentioned over and over again. I guess Dell just wished this would all go away, but its their fault for letting it get this far. They are digging themselves into a deeper hole, and don't even realize it and costing customer loyalty
"I know ChrisM has asked for a list of the issues in another thread to present to the product group, but has any progress been made with this?".
Is the DVI-D input on the 2407 a Dual-Link 24 pin, or a Single-Link 18 pin?
* Single-Link 18 pin. Only the 3007 uses a dual-link.
=====
Does this monitor support landscape rotating of the panel (flipping the panel 90 degrees)?
* No. Only the OSD menu.
=====
Is there included software/drivers to automatically rotate your picture when you do this, or do you have to rotate your picture manually via OSD or video drivers?
* The video card performs the rotate functionality. The 2407 has a feature in the OSD that rotates the OSD.
=====
Is there an option for drawing a regular 4:3 picture in a window (up to 1600x1200) to support older apps in their native resolution? Again, if this is possible are there drivers to remember what apps run in 4:3 (or other non-native resolutions) or do you have to manually adjust this via the OSD each time?
* This has to be set via the OSD in “Display settings/wide mode/4:3”.
=====
Can the panel tilt on its stand left/right or up/down any? (Not to be confused with landscape rotate or height extension/compression)
* 3 degrees forward, 21 degrees back, 45 degrees L/R
=====
I just want to verify that there is no D-Sub input.
* It has both DVI and VGA D-sub.
=====
1080, 720 specifications -
2407 1080p-50Hz through DVI = No
2407 1080p-60Hz through DVI = Yes
2407 1080i-50Hz through DVI = No picture out of range
2407 1080i-60Hz through DVI = No picture out of range
2407 720p = Yes
2407 1080p-50Hz through component = No
2407 1080p-60Hz through component = No
2407 1080i-50Hz through component = Yes
2407 1080i-60Hz through component = Yes
=====
Doesn't support 1080i over DVI
* The DVI connection is designed for PC connectivity. Simliar to the 2405FPW, 1080i is not supported in this mode. We support 1080p over DVI for HDCP usage. Progressive video has better performance over interlaced formats.
=====
Incorrectly displays 1080i over component giving an usable image
* We recommend 720p over component for the best image quality. 1080i deinterlacing is enabled but you may experience artifacts in some images.
=====
Video tearing on 720p over both component/DVI when in 1:1 mode
* Researching
When watching a DVD movie, or other media that has a wider aspect than the native 16:10, will the screen adjust automatically and put black bars at the top and bottom to keep the native resolution of the media? If not, can this be adjusted via OSD?
* Researching
=====
Is the 2407 LCD panel a true 8-bit display? (as listed 16.7 million in the tech specs)
* 2407WFP is a true 8bit panel, not 6bit + 2bit dithering. It can display the full 16.7 million colors.
=====
With the advertised PbP and PiP does every input (DVI, S-Video, Component, and Composite) have the capability of being the main picture in these modes? Subsequently, can every input be set as the secondary picture? If not what are the limitations? Also, how many PbP and PiP options are there for each setting respectively (regarding size and position)?
* Researching
=====
Banding still present in A02
* Banding is fixed in desktop mode. For multimedia, gaming and non-prime modes, we have left the complete set of * Faroudja video processing enabled so banding may still be visible in some cases when the color enhancement processing kicks in.
=====
Doesn't support 1600x1200
* 2407WFP supports 1600x1200 in fill mode only. 4:3 aspect ratio is not supported.
=====
Message Edited by DELL-ChrisM on 07-21-200607:03 AM
"Banding still present in A02
* Banding is fixed in desktop mode. For multimedia, gaming and non-prime modes, we have left the complete set of * Faroudja video processing enabled so banding may still be visible in some cases when the color enhancement processing kicks in."
Okay are you saying banding is fixed in A03 or already fixed in A02?? Because unless I, and a lot of others on this forum, have received a faulty A02 then banding is very much still a large issue in DESKTOP mode. Have a look at a vertical oriented gradient and it is very obvious!
Photo of the banding on my 2407WFP in DESKTOP mode for proof!
I will be receiving a replacement next week... I guess it's refund time if it's still going to have banding... :(
>Is the 2407 LCD panel a true 8-bit display? (as listed 16.7 million in the tech specs)* 6 bit panel + 2 bit dithering = 8 bit display
Isn't this then the heart of the problem with the banding and other picture quality issues? I thought this was supposed to be a true 8 bit display...isn't that false advertising?
man, if I had seen it advertised as 6bit + 2 bit dither I would've never gone for 2407 first and just sprung for the Samsung 244t (lag talk made me afraid there so I thought 2407 was a wiser choice). and then when I went for the 244t I still thought that it might just be the same only with more lag so I got it from a place that allowed returns of Samsung monitors for refund (losing $110, the lower price places all said they would accept any samsung return even for a restocking fee).
anyway that explains I lot, I could swear when I looked close I saw a dither pattern, but I thought it must just have been in the source or my imagination. it also explains why banding can vary so much depending upon orientation, with the way the LCD is made, it's easier to dither well horizontally. I guess that guy who claimed it was 6+2 bit on the other site was right.
i still don't see why they didn't even fix the 1600x1200 fill thing in A01 or A02, that would literally, literally take them one line of code to change, take a beginning programmer like 20 seconds.
it's a shame to save like maybe $20 manufacturing they spoiled what could have been a great monitor and increased Dell's reputation for producing fine monitors. and if they just advertised as 6+2bit and no 1080i HDCP to begin with, at least people would not have overly high expectations and they wouldn't be getting all this slag now.
anyway, I guess this means there pretty much can't be an A03 to completely perfect banding (although perhaps it could still get a touch better). i guess 2407 is still better if you are a die hard FPS player since it has so almost no lag (maybe from the 6+2, unless that was purely for cost cutting), but otherwise I would say AVOID, especially with competition having dropped price last week to be so close now, competion whch does not do any of this banding and does 1080i component, perhaps not great, but at least more properly and considerably better.
DELL-Chris M
Community Manager
•
56891 Posts
•
232143 Points
1140
0
Posted July 20th, 2006 02:00
I was told that there is no A03 planned.
DELL-Chris M (old account)
#IWork4Dell