UNSOLVED

TomC57

updated

20 years ago

Closed

T

TomC57

1 Rookie

•

73 Posts

0

14904

November 17th, 2006 13:00

Should I extend warranty on 5150?

My almost 3 year old inspiron 5150 is almost out of warranty.  This has been a problematic laptop which has had the following issues repaired under warranty: motherboard replaced twice, replaced LCD display, replaced ram, hard drive, and keyboard.  The cost of extending the in home warranty for 2 more years is around $300.  I'm inclined to purchase it, what do you think?
  • Mary G

    6 Operator

    •

    20095 Posts

    431

    0

    Posted November 17th, 2006 13:00

    Absolutely not!!! This has been a troublesome model from the start and is the subject of a  legal settlement. You could be entitled to a refund if you had to pay for repairs. Put the $300 towards a new computer. Search this forum for more info about the 5150.

    Message Edited by Mary G on 11-17-200610:55 AM

  • ejn63

    11 Legend

    •

    87469 Posts

    •

    321256 Points

    431

    0

    Posted November 17th, 2006 14:00

    Unfortunately for owners, it also prohibits any extensions beyond that date, so if you get the system repaired under this warranty, sell it ASAP and replace it - there is absolutely no indication that the repair is any better than the previous ones have been, and on that date the extended warranty ends.
  • bweed6

    806 Posts

    431

    0

    Posted November 17th, 2006 14:00

    the lundell settlement included an extension of warranty for all 5150 owners to 9-30-07.
  • greenpants8

    14 Posts

    431

    0

    Posted December 1st, 2006 18:00

    Hey, at least it will give everyone (including me) time to back everything up to put on a new machine!  That's the way I'm looking at it, anyway.  It's going to be hard for me to trust it after this fiasco.  It amazes me how much I relied on that thing until it crashed!  I will definitely invest in a new computer, after I get all my data off of it!
  • Hai80

    12 Posts

    431

    0

    Posted December 3rd, 2006 18:00

    Hi, I'm Inspiron 5150 owner. I had this system for 2 years. Warranty was expired a year ago.
    I only had "Rapid Response Depot" warranty from 04/30/2004 - 4/30/2005 
    And i have used this system with external monitor for 1 year because LCD came blank. I searched this forum many people have this problem. By the time, i heard about Lundell
    What i concern is how can i extend warranty by Lundell? I dont see any info on the settlement website saying how to ? Or do i have to call Dell Service ?
  • bweed6

    806 Posts

    431

    0

    Posted December 6th, 2006 12:00

    cool link greenpants - i was wondering when someone was going to come up with an external charger. all those folks with out of warranty motherboard failures will be scooping them up.
    as a side note, you should remove your hard drive before sending your portable in for repairs. usually the dell tech you speak to will suggest this for security reasons.

    Message Edited by bweed6 on 12-06-200608:02 AM

  • TomC57

    1 Rookie

    •

    73 Posts

    431

    0

    Posted December 22nd, 2006 09:00

    An update.  I tried to extend my warranty a couple of days prior to it running out, but was unable to do so, because of the Lundell settlement. As stated here already, the settlement extends the warranty on 5150s to a date in 2007. 
     
    Here is where it gets good.  2 or 3 days prior to the warranty expiring, the system board went, for the 4th time!  I call dell, and they send a tech over to replace it.  Upon arriving home from the office, I tried to boot up the computer, but it would not boot.  Turns out the primary hard drive was not being recognized.  So I install a secondary hard drive , same thing.  When I ran the diagnostics, both hard drives failed the DST short test.
     
    So I figured this must be a problem with the motherboard.  I called Dell, and the techs diagnosed a failed hard drive!  Ridiculous, I know.  I told the tech it had to be that the system board just installed  was faulty, and that I'm concerned because my at home warranty is about to expire.  But they sent a new hard drive anyway, which did not, of course, solve my problem.
     
    So I called tech support again and they insisted on sending me another hard drive!  Of course this one did not work, since it is the system board which is defective.
     
    So I called back.  Now my system is out of warranty, and the tech told me I had to send the unit to the depot.  They are currently experiencing a 5-6 week turnaround time for this repair!  I spoke with a supervisor ( in Utah, by the way) and asked if he could send the tech to my house, since this is what my original warranty called for.  I also explained that had the techs diagnosed the problem correctly when I first called, it would have been repaired under warranty, AT my home.
     
    He commiserated with me but told me he had no discretion in this matter, due to the Lundell settlement.  When I mentioned that this computer has been very problematic for me , he looked up its repair history, and told me he could send me a replacement computer!  I was shocked, and asked how he was unable to send a tech to my house, yet order a replacement computer for one that is no longer under warranty?  He just told me that THIS was within his discretion to do.
     
    So yesterday I got my replacement computer.  6400, 2gb ram, 160 gb hard drive, 256 mb video card, T7400 cpu, True Life screen, 5 in one card reader, DVD burner.  All of these are huge upgrades to my original 5150. 
     
    So, for me, this story has a very happy ending.  Thanks Dell!
     
    Tom

    Message Edited by TomC57 on 12-22-200606:23 AM

  • bweed6

    806 Posts

    431

    0

    Posted December 22nd, 2006 11:00

    sweeet. good for you. presumably he was limited in his actions by the settlement.