UNSOLVED

Clarey

updated

22 years ago

Closed

C

Clarey

3 Posts

0

1975

May 27th, 2004 17:00

Limited vertical viewing angle of 5150 XGA

Granted I don't have much experience with notebooks but I was expecting a much better display than I got. I ordered one of the 20th Anniversary specials a couple weeks ago, a 5150 Inspiron P2.6 with only XGA. I wanted a better display but the special wouldn't let me configure anything online - to get the SXGA+ would have cost a couple hundred more so I thought I could live with it. But..... I'm not at all happy with the display, it has to be tilted back to at least a 30 degree angle to get the frostiness off, and even then I have to constantly fiddle with it, moving it around so it gets just right so I can see everything form top to bottom of screen. Plus, there seems to be more light at the bottom of the screen, usually it's very hard to make out the icons in the Notification area unless it's tilted WAYYY back.

I can't imagine that this is normal for any notebook. Should I call Tech support and ask if this is normal? Should I return it, bite the bullet and get another 5150 with SXGA+? Resolution doesn't seem to be a problem, when I can see past the frost, stuff looks sharp and OK, and side-to-side viewing angle is reasonable - it's just the vertical that stinks. Wish now I'd bought a notebook off the shelf that I could have looked at in person. Any advice would be appreciated.

Message Edited by Clarey on 05-27-2004 11:24 AM

  • RRules

    306 Posts

    477

    0

    Posted May 28th, 2004 20:00

    I dont think that's normal. I haven't seen the 5150 with the XGA but I would reccommend you call tech support. They may replace it with an XGA that's good, but I'm not 100% sure its messed up, only about 99% sure.
  • 477

    0

    Posted May 29th, 2004 02:00

    Clarey,

    I got the same 5150 20th anniversay deal and have the same display problem.  My notebook is on it's way back to Dell's repair depot to get the display replaced.  The tier 2 tech I spoke to said he had not heard of this problem with these displays.  I'm sure he is not supposed to acknowledge any known issues though.  I will update when mine gets back in 5 to 8 working days.


    See my thread

    http://forums.us.dell.com/supportforums/board/message?board.id=insp_video&message.id=115689

  • Clarey

    3 Posts

    477

    0

    Posted May 29th, 2004 12:00

    Thanks, noob, my screen didn't look nearly as dark as yours in a dark room but I think my problem is more reflection on the screen surface rather than a light leakage. Towards the bottom of the screen is a lot of reflection from somewhere, perhaps off the case of the computer. I just don't know if that is normal or not. I guess I ought to call in and see what they think.

    I know the refund period is 21 days from date of invoice but does anyone know if Dell will extend it out due to being out of town? I'm leaving later this coming week and will have to make my mind up about this pretty quick if they don't allow some working room.

  • 477

    0

    Posted May 31st, 2004 15:00

    I got my 5150 with XGA display last week and I absolutely hate the XGA display.  Just like the original poster said, the vertical viewing angle is very limited.  In fact, I doubt if there IS an angle that you can use to see the entire screen evenly lit.  As soon as you move your head, the brightness of some parts of the screen changes.  If you move your head up a little bit, the entire screen become too bright to see anything.  I am not sure if this is caused by the extra brightness at the bottom of the screen.  I was at the store earlier, and saw all XGA screens have that same problem.  The difference is that their viewing angles seems to be bigger.

    If someone is still not sure whether to get XGA or UXGA, I can now offer my 2 cents.  I put my 5150 along side with my latitude from work which as a UXGA.  I compared them with the same pictures (at the same resolution, different resolution) and the same Windows XP screen savers.  You will be blind if you can't see the difference.  First of all, the viewing angle on UXGA is much bigger horizontally and much much bigger vertically.  Then, when the screen is black, UXGA is evenly pitch black.  Also, the color on the UXGA is more realistic (I am not a graphics professional).  Finally, the details that a UXGA is capable of displaying is unmatchable by the XGA (you would need high resolution pictures for this test).  I didn't have a chance to look at a SXGA.  I would assume it is more closer to UXGA from what I read.

    I regreted getting the 5150 with XGA.  Unfortunately, there is no way to just upgrade it by installing a new display.  I have to return this one and buy a new one.  I didn't want to just replace the display with the same type because I believe the problem will still be there, unless if you prove me wrong when you get yours back from Dell...

     

     

  • Clarey

    3 Posts

    477

    0

    Posted May 31st, 2004 22:00

    Yep, that's just what I thought, you move a bit and then the screen is out of adjustment. The XGA seems to be just a crummy, cheap design. I know you get what you pay for, but really....I'm wondering how this company can even sell these displays. HAH, I know..... sell them by mail order so they can't see what they're getting and just hope people don't return them. Speaking of which, I'm still debating about mine - I didn't really plan to spend any more on a notebook so I'm kinda stuck with it. I do have to say as I'm working with it, I'm getting used to it some. I have to have the screen tilted way back for it to be evenly lit. Bothersome but not the end of the world, I guess.

  • 477

    0

    Posted June 3rd, 2004 22:00

    Got mine back today.   It does seem a little better.   Is it perfect? No.  Is it acceptable? Yes.    Will I keep it?  I think so.