UNSOLVED

MarkStanleyMays

updated

19 years ago

Closed

0

215898

May 16th, 2006 06:00

Latitude D620 "loses" 1Gb of memory

A D620 with 4Gb (2@2Gb chips) shows the following BIOS:
Memory installed: 4096Mb
Memory available: 3063Mb
followed by a note: Due to an amount of memory being assigned for system use, Memory Available is less than Memory Installed.

A D620 with 3Gb (2Gb and 1Gb chip) shows the following BIOS:
Memory installed: 3072Mb
Memory available: 3063Mb
followed by the same note.

Also (but maybe another issue) adding a /3GB switch to the boot.ini with 4Gb installed causes registry corruption and a blue screen.

Has some driver bug caused Dell engineers to not allow memory above 3Gb?
  • SomePCTech

    11 Posts

    2365

    0

    Posted May 17th, 2006 18:00

    This isn't a Dell limitation, it's a limitation in the hardware itself.  Because the motherboard needs to have addresses for everything (including ram) it doesn't have enough to cover everything.  If you were to somehow disable a ton of stuff (keyboard/mouse/monitor/etc) you'd eventually get back the leftovers.
  • SomePCTech

    11 Posts

    2365

    0

    Posted June 16th, 2006 11:00

    I don't think it's a bad idea at all to let people know, but this isn't a random or uncommon occurance.  Anyone trying to address that much ram will have this problem.
  • 2365

    0

    Posted June 16th, 2006 22:00

    That sounds like a defect or false advertising if Dell has produced a motherboard which can't address more than 3Gb but they are selling 4Gb.
  • K1XH

    3 Posts

    2366

    0

    Posted June 26th, 2006 23:00

    Not necessarily a limitation of the hardware, but more of the OS.

    Try adding /PAE in the boot.ini file and see what that does. I needed to do that for a server w/4G, and then it will see the ram.
    PAE=Physical Address Extension. Google it for more info.

    Micky - K1XH
  • CrimZon

    10 Posts

    2366

    0

    Posted July 25th, 2006 12:00

    Yes, this is more of a windows issue. I have never gotten Windows XP to see more than 3GB of ram. I have always had to change to x64 XP, or a server OS.
  • Lester67

    97 Posts

    2366

    0

    Posted July 27th, 2006 14:00

    This is NOT a Windows issue.  If it were, Slackware, Knoppix, Vista, Server 2003, or even Windows 2000 would be able to pass the 3gb barrier, they can't (I've tested all of them).  Also, if it were a Windows issue, the BIOS wouldn't report the limitation, System Properties would.

    It is a limitation of the laptop.  2gb requires 1mb of system overhead, 3gb requires 1mb of system overhead, 4gb requires 1025mb of system overhead?  I think not.  (I'm using the nVidia version, so I actually get 3071 available.)  "Memory Available" is a CYA implemented by Dell to protect them from the same fiasco that occured with the GX280 and the claim that it supported 4gb of RAM. (It doesn't)  Even with XP, and a P4 processor you should be able to get to at least 3.5gb if the chipset and/or motherboard manufacturer has done their homework.  (3.5 is the cap for the GX620).

     

  • DrPend

    6 Posts

    2366

    0

    Posted October 6th, 2006 13:00

    We, just discovered this little tidbit with three D820 systems we are running a virtual network on for demo's. The rep gave me the OS excuse so I've booted up two seprate Enterprise level Linux distros (AS and ES) and even attempted a 64 bit install which refused as the hardware isn't a real 64 bit system. We are running these same OS on HP x86's (not laptops) and they can see up to 64 gigs of Ram but we get the same 3063 limit.  Based on this thread I'm passing this back to corporate Purchasing. This is totally unacceptable. We want a credit for the 1 gigbyte of RAM we purchased but are unable to use.
     
    Thanks
    Guys.
  • 879

    0

    Posted October 18th, 2006 16:00

    Lester67,
    You are right.  I totatally missed the whole BIOS part.  Sorry.
  • 879

    0

    Posted October 18th, 2006 16:00

    I guess that is what I get for not reading the whole post and then jumping to respond.  I will be more careful in the future.  Thanks for correcting me.
     
    Thanks again,
    Clif
  • DELL-Jimmy P

    2 Intern

    •

    1542 Posts

    879

    0

    Posted October 20th, 2006 23:00

    "Also (but maybe another issue) adding a /3GB switch to the boot.ini with 4Gb installed causes registry corruption and a blue screen"
     
    MarkStanleyMays
     
    Try /3gb /USERVA=2850, the 3gb switch applies to virtual memory and has nothing to do with physical ram.
     
    Please read this article from Intel for an explanation of why you only see 3.XX ram available to the OS.