UNSOLVED

mwitters

updated

18 years ago

Closed

M

mwitters

37 Posts

0

47371

August 14th, 2008 16:00

For those with E1705/9400 laptops with 7900gs Video cards - READ THIS!

do NOT buy a 7900gs for your E1705/9400! they die like crazy they are a single heat pipe design that is inadequate for cooling them. If you have a 17 inch laptop you can get a dual heatpipe card. There are 4 options. all these cards are the exact same care but simply with different model numbers, different BIOS's, and different factory set clock speeds. The card they used for these models is very good, it has 2 heat pipes and 2 sets of fins for double the cooling of the 7900gs. Thus, they last a long time and got out must less often. The 7900gs just cooks inside the e1705/9400. There simply is not enough cooling for the card and they cook slowly which lowers their life span by years.

 

here's the 4 models of dual heat pipe cards that all use the exact same card.

 

Quadro cards:

 

Quadro fx2500 512mb - $125-$300 on ebay, I persoanlly bought one of these after my 7900gs went out 2 weeks out of warranty and dell refused to fix it. (unreal how they have gotten away with taking us to the cleaners)

 

The FX2500 is the exact same card hardware wise as a 7900GTX 512mb, they simply have different bios that makes them better for CAD and such. You can get all the latest driver updates for this card and any other laptop card from laptopvideo2go.com. they have modified inf files that make it so they will install on your laptop. Dell doesn't put out drivers but once or twice a year, they can't be bothered with taking care of their customers they're too busy counting their money. There is also a 256mb fx2500 from what i hear but don't bother, the extra 256mb of memory makes newer games like cod run much faster. COD4 was barely playable on my 7900gs 256, with the fx2500 it runs smooth as silk.

 

FX3500 512mb - same as the FX2500 except the default clock speed is set higher to make this card roughly 10% faster. This is the same as a 7950 gtx 512mb, again, different bios, up to date drivers available at laptopvideo2go.com.

 

geforce cards:

 

Geforce 7900 GTX 512mb - same as the fx2500, very fast cards both of them. this card will perform about 3-5% better than the fx2500 because of the bios being more optimized for gaming, however they ussualy run more expoensive than the fx2500. they ussually got from $200 to $350 on ebay, remember you will find people selling "untested" sold as-is card on ebay NEVER BUY THESE! They are all bad cards that these people simply sell for half normal price knowing they are bad but since they imply that they might work because they are untested you might get a working one. Trust me, they NEVER work.

 

Geforce 7950 GTX 512mb - same as the fx3500, different bios, 3-5% faster than the fx3500. best card available for the e1705/9400. runs about $250-$400 on ebay. again, make sure they are tested.

 

-

 

These cards are only able to be installed on the 17" versions of these laptops.

 

Installation. These fit into the cases perfectly you need to only make one tiny adjustment, there is an internal plastic notch that act as a guide for the second heat pipes copper fins to be placed into. most of these dual pipe cards the pipe sticks out a bit too far and a little notch needs to be cut out of the guide for the card to fit properly. These second heat pipes provide DOUBLE the cooling that the 7900gs has, it shows big time, where the 7900gs back rear would get so hot it would nearly burn you, these cards are much cooler and the heat is more disapated throughout the laptop.

 

There is a fabulous installation guide for these dual pipe cards into a e1705/9400 here is the link, it has great pics, just follow the instructions carefully, it makes it so simple they walk you through everything. Seriosuly, this guide is fabulous.

 

http://www.notebookcheck.net/Case-Study-Replacing-the-Video-Card-of-a-Dell-Inspiron-E1705-9400.4187.0.html

 

I would replace my 7900gs even if it hadn't died now that i know the performance increase and the cooling problems of the 7900gs. I REALLY like my FX2500, I got it for only $150 on ebay and it is fast as heck. your 7900gs will most likely fail. they fail at an astounding rate and Dell cares nothing for it's customers. They will charge you $408 for another 7900gs for you to have to instal yourself! It will just die in a few months anyways! You could get a 7950 gtx 512mb for less than that!

 

www.Laptopvideo2go.com is a fabulous site that modifies the simple .inf file to make the latest drivers run on laptop video cards. You see for some rediculous reason Dell (and other laptop manufacturers to be fair) have asked nvidia to NOT include laptop versions of their cards in their regularly released drivers. Basically there is a tiny file that nvidia puts the name of each card that the drivers will install on, if your card is not on this list (in the .inf file) when you try to install the drivers it will tell you sorry, not for this computer. But the fact is the drivers will work just fine, and even better than your old drivers. so laptopvideo2go.com simply adds the mobile cards names to the .inf files and lets you download the drivers from their site with the modified .inf file already in the installer. (sometimes you need to download the .inf yourself and place it in the c:\nvidia folder after running the installer once and having it kick you out.)

 

The reason you want to do this is because even though Dell has asked nvidia not to release updates to their cards, their reasoning being that they want to test drivers before releasing them themselves for each individual laptop. and for phone support issues. Well the problem is Dell hardly ever releases new drivers! New drivers come out nearly ever month, if Dell releases one driver every 6 months your lucky. Sometimes you need the newest drivers for certain games to even work!

 

So in conclusion, you want to replace your 7900gs, period. they are terrible cards in this particular system. Dell made a bad design flaw and refuses to take respoonsibility for it because it will cost them money. the customer matters nothing to them, they make so much money they don't care. If they think they will save more money by not fixing these cards and loosing future customers they will simply save the money. Who cares that they took advantage of many people. They saved a few bucks and thats all this mega corp cares about. Customer satisfaction is a afterthought... a very distant afterthought.

 

The dual heat pipe cards are so much better. They run cooler, have twice the memory, have much higher clock speeds and have more pixel and vertex shaders. They are ussualy about half the price that dell charges for the slower, hotter 7900gs when you buy them at the right price. they are very easy to install with a single phillips screwdriver. You need one with a very small tip, you might want 2 types, one with a very pointy tip and one not so pointy. at the installation guide above you can see what type of screws I'm talking about.

 

Compare the 7900gs to the fx2500 (the FX2500 is about $200 average on ebay.)

 

These cards is in a whole higher category than the GS. I chose the FX2500 because it's the low end of the dual heat pipe cards, so the FX3500 and the gefore cards are even better, they have even higher core speeds and memory speeds.)

 

Video memory:

7900GS - 256mb

FX2500 - 512mb

 

Pixel shaders:

7900gs - 20

fx2500 - 24

 

Vertex shaders:

7900GS - 7

FX2500 - 8

 

Core Speed:

7900GS - 375mhz

FX2500 - 500mhz

 

shader speed:

7900GS - 500mhz

FX2500 - 600mhz

 

3DMark06 Score:

7900GS - 3745

FX2500 - 4695

 

You can even flash the bios on these quadro cards to give them the geforce BIOS and increase performance a small amount if you want. there are tutorials online to do it but it's a little complicated.

 

This all boils down to newer games will run MUCH smoother on any of these dual pipe cards. They have twice the memory, the extra pixel and vertex shaders and much higher clock frequencies do wonders (they are able to run these cards at much higher clock speeds than the GS with less heat because of the fact that they have double the cooling of the GS).

 

I hope this helps you guys make a good decision... Please trust me, it's worth it. you have to do this to protect yourself against a faulty design from Dell, all they will do is charge you rediculous prices for a new card with planned obsolescence. You will love your new card.

 

In the future do not buy Dell laptops, Dell cares nothing for their customers. They tell us that we should have bought an extended warranty to protect ourselves from their faulty designs. Well extended warranties are NOT for factory defects!

 

If Ford finds a faulty gas tank in one of their cars they don't tell the people whos warranties are expired "too bad, should have got the extended warranty, now you have to pay for us making a bad product." The issue a recall and fix everyones reguardless of warranty status because it was THEIR fault! But dell does the same exact thing and takes zero responsibility. I will never buy a dell again, ever.

 

This post was simply to try and help those of you who like me were taken advantage of by Dell.

*** NOTE - the Quadro FX1600 and FX3600 will NOT work in the E1705/9400. I'd be willing to bet if someone smart enough could re-write a BIOS to make it compatible with them it would but simply plugging them into a E1705/9400 will not work. These cards are the quadro version of the 8700m and the 8800m graphics cards.
Perhaps someone will make a BIOS flash for them but i don't know how it would be flashed except on a M6300 or the new XPS cards... but as of now don't bother I know somone who has tested them and they don't work.
Message Edited by mwitters on 08-14-2008 02:23 PM
  • DJKeebler

    32 Posts

    719

    0

    Posted August 14th, 2008 17:00

    Thanks for the post man. I am suffering from a dead 7900 gs right now and I will definitely follow this advice.
  • eskymi

    1061 Posts

    719

    0

    Posted August 14th, 2008 17:00

    mwitters,

     

    I must admit this post was good.  I will say that in a couple other posts I disagreed with your assesment as it sounded just like a disgruntled person slamming Dell because they had a computer failure and decided that Dell should fix it even though it's out of warranty, etc.  So I disagreed with you!

     

    This post is very informative as it gives a lot of good information pertaining to different cards to be used, etc.  I like how you also point out how easily the modification is.   This is a post I can use, if necessary (if and when ) my card fails. 

    Thanks.

     

     

  • kirkd

    6 Operator

    •

    5241 Posts

    719

    0

    Posted August 15th, 2008 04:00

    The only problem I see with the E1705/7900GS is that the BIOS fan control program is not too good. It usually allows the temps to get too high before starting either fan. I installed i8kfangui the second week I had mine, modified the fan control, and have had no temp problems whatsoever.

     

    The 7900GS overclocks easily, and I can see problems if pushed to the limit with the stock fan program.

  • mwitters

    37 Posts

    719

    0

    Posted August 15th, 2008 05:00


    @kirkd wrote:

    The only problem I see with the E1705/7900GS is that the BIOS fan control program is not too good. It usually allows the temps to get too high before starting either fan. I installed i8kfangui the second week I had mine, modified the fan control, and have had no temp problems whatsoever.

     

    The 7900GS overclocks easily, and I can see problems if pushed to the limit with the stock fan program.


    Well even if that was the case, the stock program was faulty, Dell never released a fix for it. Those of us who had our cards fail due to the myriad of design flaws and to be blunt stupid mistakes make by dell with these cards and laptops should be reimbursed for the money we had to pay to buy a new card and the time and or money of installing it ourselves or having it installed. They blew it on multiple front, They put a card that gets extremely hot with ti's single heat pipe into a system where only one fan blows on one small set of fins, they put defective BIOS software for running the fans at a fan enough speed to keep the cards cool enough. This bad fan Vios settings is reason enough to justify them extending the warranty to everyone who's cards died. Dell makes me sick...

    Message Edited by mwitters on 08-15-2008 01:31 AM
  • ejn63

    11 Legend

    •

    87469 Posts

    •

    321256 Points

    719

    0

    Posted August 15th, 2008 09:00

    Interesting that Dell should do that to you - since the ravings you post do the same to those of us who are here to use the forums for their intended purpose.
  • DJKeebler

    32 Posts

    719

    0

    Posted August 15th, 2008 14:00


    @mwitters wrote:

    If Ford finds a faulty gas tank in one of their cars they don't tell the people whos warranties are expired "too bad, should have got the extended warranty, now you have to pay for us making a bad product." The issue a recall and fix everyones reguardless of warranty status because it was THEIR fault! But dell does the same exact thing and takes zero responsibility. I will never buy a dell again, ever.


    I agree wholeheartedly with this quote. And I agree with other things that mwitters said. It's quite obvious that very many people are having issues with this card. "Quality" products made by a company that is well known by its "quality" should not fail so fast. These are NOT isolated incidents. Most peoples cards are dying within a year or less if they bought this laptop because cooling is insufficient. Enough said. Take responsibility, dell.
  • mwitters

    37 Posts

    719

    0

    Posted August 15th, 2008 15:00


    @ejn63 wrote:
    Interesting that Dell should do that to you - since the ravings you post do the same to those of us who are here to use the forums for their intended purpose.

    ya god forbid i post about how I have had a terrible experience on the Dell forums. I should be posting about how much i love getting bent over right?

  • ejn63

    11 Legend

    •

    87469 Posts

    •

    321256 Points

    713

    0

    Posted August 15th, 2008 15:00

    I just wonder if you actually read your own posts, to realize just how foolish they look.

     

     

  • mwitters

    37 Posts

    713

    0

    Posted August 15th, 2008 16:00

    I just wonder how fat you must be spending 24/7 in front of your computer replying to every post on the dell forums... you must be a real winner.
  • ejn63

    11 Legend

    •

    87469 Posts

    •

    321256 Points

    518

    0

    Posted August 16th, 2008 09:00

    Excellent insight into your character there - it totally destroys the credibility of anything you post, ever again.  Welcome to my ignore list! 

     

    Do us all a favor and buy an HP system.