UNSOLVED

jcocuzzo

updated

24 years ago

Closed

J

jcocuzzo

14 Posts

0

47155

March 22nd, 2003 20:00

D600 SXGA or SXGA+ Advice wanted

Just ordered a Latitude D600 and I selected the SXGA+ display.

My Inspiron 4000 display (XGA) at 1024 x 768 has suited me fine.

Am I wasting money by purchasing the SXGA+ vs the XGA ?

Will I actually get worse resolution if I run the SXGA+ at 1024 x 768 vs

running the XGA at its native resolution 1024 x 768?

 

 

Message Edited by jdcnpr on 03-22-2003 08:55 PM

  • jcocuzzo

    14 Posts

    590

    0

    Posted March 24th, 2003 16:00

    Thanks for the info.   I emailed and called the sales guy to change my order.

    I tried to get some info from him when I placed it on what would be best to choose, but he implied that the SXGA+ would be just as good as XGA when running in XGA, and would provide higher resolution if I needed it.

    Since my Dell Inspiron has suited me just fine at XGA, and I want to run the LCD at it's native resolution, I'll change to XGA.

     

     

  • Rance485

    2 Intern

    •

    298 Posts

    590

    0

    Posted March 24th, 2003 16:00

    jdcnpr:

    If you intend to use XGA for all applications, then an XGA LCD would be better than an SXGA+ LCD with the same physical dimensions. All industry standard LCD panels are optimized for a specific (maximum) resolution. Using a resolution other than the optimal will result in screen stretching, distortion, or screen shrink. In addition the image and fonts may look slightly "blurry" due to the method of interpolation (a form of antialiasing) being used.

    This is not considered a problem and occurs with all TFT LCDs industry wide. Each display is optimized to a specific resolution and was designed to operate at that resolution.

    For an even better explanation read this post by James P. Wallen:

    "First: Any LCD will look best when running at its native resolution because its pixels are of a fixed size. When you set the desktop at a lower resolution, the display subsystem has to interpolate (use some multiple greater than 1 of actual physical pixels) in order to present the desktop image at that resolution. Best case would be, if your native resolution is 1600 x 1200, then a resolution of 800 x 600 will use four physical LCD pixels (2x2) as a single pixel in the desktop display. Using another resolution requires the display subsystem to use non-integer multiples.

    Second: The 1400 x 1200 and 1280 x 1024 or other such resolutions are not using the standard aspect ratio. You'll note that 640 x 480, 800 x 600, 1024 x 768, 1400 x 1050, and 1600 x 1200 all have desktop width to desktop height ratios of 4:3. When you use a non-standard aspect ratio, your system either has to not use the whole screen (leaving you with a "black bar" effect at the display edges) OR it has to stretch the image (leaving you with a distorted desktop geometry). In the latter case you also have made the job of interpolation that much harder for the display subsystem to accomplish."

     

  • bsd107

    25 Posts

    590

    0

    Posted April 7th, 2003 23:00

    The best way for you to test the effect of running a SXGA+ LCD at XGA resolution is to run you current Inspiron (with XGA) at 800x600.  Make sure the image is full screen.  You will see how the image is not as sharp.
  • HeavyUser

    1 Message

    590

    0

    Posted February 20th, 2004 18:00

    I had the same experience, my first notebook, a d600 is in the mail.  After reading much of the feedback, I have been torn between XGA and SXGA+.  My normal res is 1024x768 on a 17" crt.  I first ordered with SXGA+ and when I called to change it, the salesperson tried to talk me out of it contradicting most of what I've read.  I changed it to XGA, then changed my mind again.  Changing it back a second time involved an intensely beaurocratic process.  Hope I made the right choice.  It's difficult when the sales opinion contradicts the support opinion.  Guess I will know soon one way or the other, probably should have gone with XGA.
  • jld0077

    19 Posts

    595

    0

    Posted February 23rd, 2004 22:00

    I went ahead and ordered the SXGA+ screen, and am generally pleased with it. However, my needs might not be typical, and I've discovered a couple of oddities that might be off-putting for some.

    First, I spend a lot of time writing and doing desktop publishing. Individual letters look really crisp on the higher resolution display. Graphics editing likewise is much closer to working on paper. The higher resolution saves me a lot of time and eye strain.

    Here are the negatives. First, 1400x1050 resolution is not a standard Windows resolution. It's the standard 4:3 aspect ratio, but it's not a more common resolution such as 1024x768 or 1280x1024. As a result, Windows doesn't quite know what to do with icons, title bars and the like. Sometimes they show up fuzzy. Sometimes they show up blocky. Sometimes it's normal.

    The problem seems to be inherent in Microsoft's code. It's much more noticeable in Internet Explorer or Microsoft Office 2003, and really isn't apparent at all in WordPerfect Office or the Mozilla-based browsers (Netscape, Mozilla or Firefox).

    BTW, the IBM Thinkpad units that run at the same resolution seem to have the same issues, but IBM also seems to have rewritten Windows a bit so that things generally look cleaner. However, IBM opted to make the icons pretty small. To see that stuff, you need to spend some time making it usefully large -- a bother. And you probably pay for that tweaked code as part of the premium in price that Big Blue commands over the Dell units.

    Hope this helps. I'd be interested in anyone else's thoughts on the matter.



    Joel
  • jwark

    1 Rookie

    •

    267 Posts

    595

    0

    Posted February 24th, 2004 01:00

    Dell quickset does apply some tweaks to the video drivers that seems to clear up glitches. I don't know what they are but I've seen it fix all kinds of video problems. Worth a try to install it.
  • mbahaas

    4 Posts

    595

    0

    Posted March 29th, 2004 01:00


    I want to swap out my D600 SXGA (1400 x 1050) to XGA (1280 x 1024).  Can I buy a new LCD and just have some techie open up my laptop and make the switch?  When I ordered my laptop, the system came configured using the 1280 x 1024 option and it looked great.  I have since reinstalled Windows on a fresh hard drive and the 1280 x 1024 option is fuzzy.  I need an XGA screen type.  Let me know how I can accomplish this ...
  • Sterlin254

    394 Posts

    595

    0

    Posted March 29th, 2004 02:00

    On my Inspiron 600m I LOVE MY SXGA+ I would never go wtih anything lower. The reason i posted here is because it is VERY SIMILAR TO THE D600.

  • Boris67

    1 Rookie

    •

    5 Posts

    595

    0

    Posted March 29th, 2004 07:00

    Has anyone here tried any s/w solution for blurriness while setting XGA resolution
    for SXGA+ native display?
    Something like playing with graphic properties? Or program like
    Liquid View (http://personalcomputing.portrait.com/us/products/lv_overview.html) or alike?
    Any good results?
  • j1huynh

    7 Posts

    143

    0

    Posted April 2nd, 2004 06:00

    I have the same problem here.. it is blurry/fuzzy when try to change to a different resolution from the native.  Like even when I am at the native resolution, the picture from my screen saver looks horribly..  (I just returned an inspiron 600m w/ graphic card problem..)  does my dell D600 have a prob too?  arg.. getting very frustrated with dell laptop.