UNSOLVED

joetoste

updated

10 years ago

J

joetoste

13 Posts

0

10751

May 14th, 2017 00:00

XPS 8910 - Why can't the onboard Intel Graphics be disabled in the BIOS?

I have a XPS 8910 that came with a RX480 Radeon card installed - it works fine, except Windows 10 release 1703 still displays the Intel 530 Graphics under Device Manager, and complains that I have a Device Driver problem. Why doesn't the BIOS for this machine have a 'auto' setting like the XPS 8900 BIOS that makes the onboard graphics invisible to the Operating System? Having the onboard graphics constantly visible to Windows makes it very difficult to remove the Intel drivers. Considering the cost of these systems, I would expect the BIOS to be at least as good as the previous generation - when will this be fixed?

  • vtoy116

    2 Intern

    •

    307 Posts

    8129

    0

    Posted May 14th, 2017 07:00

    I maybe wrong but I believe the motherboard automatically disables the Intel HD Graphics when a discrete graphics card is detected. Also being disabled does not mean it goes undetected. For example, think about what would happen if you decided to remove the discrete graphics card, I think you would want the onboard graphics to work without having to load device drivers. I would focus on the device driver issue, my XPS 8910 came with a Nvidia GTX-750Ti card and has no issues with the Intel 530 graphics device driver under Windows 10 Pro Version 1703. Hope this helps.

  • RoHe

    12 Elder

    •

    45230 Posts

    •

    172625 Points

    8129

    0

    Posted May 14th, 2017 13:00

    Which video hardware shows the driver error in Device Manager, your RX480 card, or the Intel video?

    Driver for AMD cards are notoriously problematic with Win 10.  You might want to go to the AMD site and look for the latest driver for your specific card that's compatible with 1703.

  • joetoste

    13 Posts

    8129

    0

    Posted May 14th, 2017 16:00

    To briefly recap, I have one of each system, 8900SE and 8910SE. The BIOS on the 8900 is a GUI-type BIOS, and has more capabilities than the AMI Aptio BIOS supplied in the 8910. In the 8900 BIOS, there is a video option of 'auto' which will disable motherboard graphics if a separate video card is installed, and enable motherboard graphics if either a separate card is not installed or if any other option than 'auto' is selected. The 8910 BIOS does not have this function, meaning that both sets of graphics are visible to Windows at all times. The Device Manager error is related to the onboard Intel graphics - even though they are disabled under Device Manager, they are still visible to the OS, and Windows complains about that. The RX480 works fine, and has the latest WHQL version of its drivers installed.

    My original post was meant to be read and replied to by someone from Dell Support, with an answer to my original question - why does the 8910 have a BIOS with fewer capabilities than the 8900, and when will this disparity be corrected? Considering that the XPS 8910SE is a more expensive system to the end user than the XPS 8900SE, I expect the XPS 8910SE to have a BIOS at least as capable as its predecessor, and require Dell to provide a solution, or at least a workaround implemented in the XPS 8910SE BIOS.

  • vtoy116

    2 Intern

    •

    307 Posts

    8129

    0

    Posted May 14th, 2017 18:00

    It seems to me the bigger issue to be concerned about is why there is a Device Manager error related to the onboard Intel graphics and not whether the BIOS has some feature to disable the onboard graphics. If you remove the discrete graphics card you would need clear the Device Manager error.Also I would expect that if Windows detects a CPU with onboard graphics it would load the device drivers whether or not it was disabled.

  • joetoste

    13 Posts

    8129

    0

    Posted May 14th, 2017 21:00

    Sorry, maybe I misspoke - the reported error is a Device Driver error presented by the little Windows Defender Health Monitor in rel 1703 - precisely because I disabled the Intel Graphics in Device Manager on my 8910. OTOH, since my 8900, which is also running rel 1703, has the Intel Graphics disabled by the BIOS, the Intel Graphics doesn't even appear in Device Manager to disable or complain about - which is why I'm able to make the comparison, and the basis for my query.

  • eternalozzie

    254 Posts

    8129

    0

    Posted May 15th, 2017 07:00

    modern chipsets no longer automatically disable onboard graphics when there is a graphic card present.  they can work together to run lots of monitors.

  • joetoste

    13 Posts

    8129

    0

    Posted May 15th, 2017 09:00

    You know, I'm never really sure whose post folks are replying to, or if they read the whole thread before they post - the XPS 8900 and the XPS 8910 use the same Skylake CPU, and the same Z170 chipset - the differences are in the BIOS as I explained above. So, if you have a real solution to my question, please provide it - otherwise...

  • DELL-Chris M

    Community Manager

    •

    56891 Posts

    •

    232143 Points

    8129

    0

    Posted May 15th, 2017 15:00

    Both the XPS 8910 (7/16) and the newest XPS 8920 (1/17) utilize the Aptio bios. The move to the Aptio bios was a platform team decision. There are no plans to move back to the other bios on the XPS 8910 and XPS 8920. On the XPS 8910, the Intel HD driver should be installed and not disabled. Windows will still use the Radeon RX480 as the Primary video card because it is installed the Primary PCIe x16 motherboard slot.


    DELL-Chris M (old account)

    #IWork4Dell

  • vtoy116

    2 Intern

    •

    307 Posts

    8129

    0

    Posted May 15th, 2017 15:00

    Your problem is probably not a Device Driver error but an error due to Windows Defender Health reporting. If you Google Windows Defender Health Report you will see that folks are having issues with the Health Reports since Creators Update.introduced the Windows Defender Security Center. Windows Defender probably doesn't like the fact that the Intel graphics is disabled and I don't really see why it is necessary to disable it.

  • joetoste

    13 Posts

    1294

    0

    Posted May 15th, 2017 17:00

    Chris - I think we both know I'm not suggesting that Dell replace the Aptio BIOS on the 8910/20 with the BIOS used on the 8900, and I think we all know the AMI Aptio BIOS has many more capabilities than are shown to the average commodity PC purchaser / user - by Dell's choice of which options are shown to the user during BIOS setup. My request was not to change the BIOS to a GUI, but to provide a video option of 'auto' which will disable motherboard graphics if a PCI video card is installed, and enable motherboard graphics if either a PCI video card is not installed or if any other option than 'auto' is selected. To be honest, if I had known this option is not available in the 8910 BIOS (currently 1.1.0), I most likely would not have bought another Dell system.