
UNSOLVED
XPS 700 opower button breaks
I was amazed after receiving our XPS 700 that the power button broke only 36 days after purchase. We use a Dell XPS Gen 1 & 3 alongside this new beast, so you can imagine our surprise that such a simple item could basically shutdown our newest machine so easily.
Today the Dell certified tech showed up, opened the case of the XPS 700, opened the box with the replacement part, when to both our chagrin, the replacement part had been shipped broken as well. I don't know folks, here we have a steel cased XPS 700 and the power button is made of plastic.
I called my brother who just ordered and received his new XPS 700 on this last Saturday, based upon my recommendation to do so. I hope I have not made a big mistake.
dave
Responses (11)
Solutions (0)
DELL-Chris M
Community Manager
•
56891 Posts
•
232143 Points
430
0
Posted December 13th, 2006 16:00
mubacca,
Please provide me with the following information in a private message, not on the board -
Name:
Shipping address:
Phone:
Service tag number:
Order number:
Customer number:
Reason: XPS 700 power button breaks
DELL-Chris M (old account)
#IWork4Dell
schmiddlapp
1 Message
430
0
Posted December 18th, 2006 15:00
Mine broke an hour out of the box. Had to jerry rig it and rough it back into place. I've had to do that three times now. And the stabalizing thing that attaches to the bottom had a screww hole that was impossible to line up.I can't believe they made such a trong case, but cruddy front panel nad other box componants.But then Dell doesn't seem to make a whole lot of sense since I purchased my 700- It is funny how things come around a bite you. I wonder what will the final bill be for the power switch?
tphillips63
4 Apprentice
•
2629 Posts
•
7922 Points
430
0
Posted December 18th, 2006 21:00
@fc7202 wrote:
It is funny how things come around a bite you. I wonder what will the final bill be for the power switch?
That is nothing compared to what they are wasting in service calls to replace, CPU's, video cards, motherboards because they have a faulty diagnostic that shipped with the XPS 700 and support does not know about it.
Still they did fix it in the XPS 710, its a plastic button with the switch right behind it now.- So, as some of you have said the power button needs to be pushed in a certain way, even though the manual has no mention of this. Let me be blunt.Today marks the second day a certified Dell technician has come to my home to replace the power button. Both times the Dell technician used factory boxed parts sent by Dell. Each time they sent the entire switching assembly. Trouble is it is not the same assembly that came in the XPS 700.The switch assembly Dell sent would not engage the power on. To replace this assembly required the Dell technician to remove the card reader, floppy drive, video card and the huge I believe heat sink, and in short it was down to almost the motherboard. The Dell technician installed the replacement assembly and concluded after it was installed that there is nothing to stop or prevent the button so it could contact the power. The only way to get it to work is to hold your finger, thumb, shoe, whatever on the end of it in place while you press the button from the front of the machine. Frankly I am flabbergasted this has happened a second time on a brand new XPS machine.This time the Dell technician took digital photos of the orginal (broken) power button and assemby, and the new replacement power button assembly. The pictures clearly show the assembly are not the same. I noticed the new power button post (leg) is shorter by about 3 quarters of and inch. Trouble is it has nothing to secure it in this new assembly.So where does this leave me. Still waiting on the Dell technician to receive a third replacement assembly and hope to God this next one will install and work. If I had known from the beginning that I needed to be so darn gentle with this button I would have been. I am still irritated as heck, that this early christmas present is giving me so much grief.Until I have this resolved satisfactorily I will be back.david
Message Edited by mubacca on 12-18-200607:10 PM
I'm really concerned by the ignorance of Dell. They let out a substandard design and quietly servicing it. To make things even worse the Dell technician is also either a high school dropout or has not been given proper instruction for replacement and obviously does not have a concept of how the actuator supposed to work. What a shame, what used to be one of the words best computer companies, is trying short cut the customers with such a cheap design.
The problem is that the design basically bad. Because of that, the dimensions of the actual assemblies different from each other making some worse than others,. Looks like you got a winner.
I studied this stupid thing long enough that I know that the replacement part will be a hit and miss. Your best bet is to learn how to push the switch with a controlled force approx. 45 degrees up.
If you push it strait in and hard, it will pop out of the metal clips that hold it to the bezel.
Best of luck!
fc7202 wrote:
I'm really concerned by the ignorance of Dell. They let out a substandard design and quietly servicing it. To make things even worse the Dell technician is also either a high school dropout or has not been given proper instruction for replacement and obviously does not have a concept of how the actuator supposed to work. What a shame, what used to be one of the words best computer companies, is trying short cut the customers with such a cheap design.
The problem is that the design basically bad. Because of that, the dimensions of the actual assemblies different from each other making some worse than others,. Looks like you got a winner.
I studied this stupid thing long enough that I know that the replacement part will be a hit and miss. Your best bet is to learn how to push the switch with a controlled force approx. 45 degrees up.
If you push it strait in and hard, it will pop out of the metal clips that hold it to the bezel.
Best of luck!
I would love to have the opportunity to 'learn' how to push the button, trouble is, you have to have an actual replacement installed first to do that. The metal clips you speak of are 'clearly abscent' from the replacement assembly, so there is nothing that the switching assembly can attach itself to in the case.As for the comment on the Dell technician, he appears to be very knowledgeable and knows how parts work and how to install them, the only thing that I can see is having an actual working part to install.I am not impressed with the lack of feedback the Dell technician has had each time he called Dell on the phone in my home (you see he was nice enough to put his cellphone on speaker so that I too could hear the lack of knowhow and knowledge displayed by people taking service calls).
The metal clips are molded into the back of the bezel. The bezel is the plastic grill that covers the front of the computer. The clips each have a small opening, window, where the actuator barbs clicks in.
If you push the button to hard too hard the barbs pop out , in the best case ,they shear off in the worse case . In my case one side popped out.
If Dell positioned the switch right behind the button, no one ever had a problem, however , to do so, they would have had to wire the switch to the printed circuit board or position the printed circuit board behind the button. And that is where the cost comes in. To connect something with a wire as opposed to snap in, costs money: the two 3” wires, plus another two for the LED (backlight for the switch). Connecting wires in between components you need to use connectors or manual solders both are costly and reliability potential. The excuse is my a big problem. This is the flagship of Dell, we paying for the best they can make. It turns out, the design team installed a Blue Light special!
I see this costing Dell more than $100 bucks every time (service call, plus replacement part) to fix a five cent part.
I makes me wonder the direction this company is heading! May be the Japanese will teach them one day how to do it right.
tphillips63
4 Apprentice
•
2629 Posts
•
7922 Points
84
0
Posted December 19th, 2006 13:00
THat is exactly what they did on the 710. When you see the 700 switch it just makes you shake your head. I'm talking about the convoluted way the actual switch operates so if you have not seen the switch assembly you can't imagine but try this. Tape about five pencils together with scotch tape (not a lot either) and use that to turn on or off your light switch all the time. It nearly as bad.THe 710 is what it should be, the switch circuit board is directly behind the front switch and the wires are routed down to it from the top.
fc7202 wrote:
The metal clips are molded into the back of the bezel. The bezel is the plastic grill that covers the front of the computer. The clips each have a small opening, window, where the actuator barbs clicks in.
If you push the button to hard too hard the barbs pop out , in the best case ,they shear off in the worse case . In my case one side popped out.
If Dell positioned the switch right behind the button, no one ever had a problem, however , to do so, they would have had to wire the switch to the printed circuit board or position the printed circuit board behind the button. And that is where the cost comes in. To connect something with a wire as opposed to snap in, costs money: the two 3” wires, plus another two for the LED (backlight for the switch). Connecting wires in between components you need to use connectors or manual solders both are costly and reliability potential. The excuse is my a big problem. This is the flagship of Dell, we paying for the best they can make. It turns out, the design team installed a Blue Light special!
I see this costing Dell more than $100 bucks every time (service call, plus replacement part) to fix a five cent part.
I makes me wonder the direction this company is heading! May be the Japanese will teach them one day how to do it right.

jsrder
903 Posts
430
0
Posted December 12th, 2006 22:00