UNSOLVED

genoxps

updated

18 years ago

G

genoxps

31 Posts

0

23486

October 21st, 2008 13:00

which one is better for XPS 730 9800GX2 or GTX280

Good Morning,

 

In advance I would like to thank everyone for your input. Which card is actually better for gamming the 9800GX2 or the GTX 280. I returned my XPS 630i and I am in the process of getting a 730 but I don't know which card to get. I have looked at several forums regarding both cards. The 9800GX2 was the best on some of the reviews but some mentioned about the drivers on the GTX 280 that they are new and should improve with newer ones. I want to go SLI and have a 40inch LCD TV.

 

 

Thanks,

  • DELL-Chris M

    Community Manager

    •

    56891 Posts

    •

    232143 Points

    682

    0

    Posted October 21st, 2008 14:00

    Gruffly78,

    3DMark 06 and Vanguard results?


    DELL-Chris M (old account)

    #IWork4Dell

  • Gruffly78

    46 Posts

    682

    0

    Posted October 21st, 2008 14:00

    Don't play Vanguard... been staying away from MMO's since the old EQ days (can anyone say addiction!)

     

    I'll download the Basic edition of 3DMark06 (v110) and try it out and re-post.  Don't have a 9800GX2 to compare with my exact setup though.

     

    From the list in the Toms Hardward link, it looks like 3DMark06 doesn't do the GTX280 justice. 

    Message Edited by Gruffly78 on 10-21-2008 10:51 AM
  • Gruffly78

    46 Posts

    682

    0

    Posted October 21st, 2008 14:00

    I did a lot of reading before I purchased my new SLI-GTX280 system:

     

    pros:

    - GTX280 has 1024MB of ram, 9800GX2 has 512MB

    - GTX280 runs much cooler, and uses much less power when not fully used.

    - GTX280 (single card) outperforms the 9800GX2 (dual card) in all tests I reviewed at the time (3 months ago) even on the older drivers.  (Do you have any links to tests showing otherwise, just curious for comparison... a few tests did show slight advantage to 9800GX2 but most showed better results for GTX280.)

    - the 200/300 series is the platform that developers and Nvidia are going to be targetting and optimizing (the GTX 280 is a bit more future proof than the 9800).

     

    cons:

    - $$$ !!!!!!

     

    Current performance IMO is amazing.  In the GTX280 in SLI with the XPS 730 with air-cooling barely gets over 60 degrees C, playing STALKER CS with all settings maxed except for AA (only 2x AA enabled) and absolutely no frame droppage (feels like I'm getting over 30fps at minimum).  It chews through Crysis like butter.  I haven't overclocked anything.

    Message Edited by Gruffly78 on 10-21-2008 10:20 AM
  • PH3N0M

    650 Posts

    682

    0

    Posted October 21st, 2008 14:00

    Here, check these two links on Toms Hardware. This will solve it.

     

     Toms Hardware Benchmark Comparison for GTX 260, GTX 280, and the 9800GX2

     

    Complete Graphics Card Comparison

    Message Edited by PH3N0M on 10-21-2008 10:48 AM
  • PH3N0M

    650 Posts

    682

    0

    Posted October 21st, 2008 14:00

    Go with the GTX 280. While the 9800GX2 quad SLI may very slightly outperform GTX280 SLI at the moment, the 9800GX2 only has 512mb of memory and a 256 bit bus per core, so the GTX solution is likely to out last it. IMO, if you're going to consider a pair of 9800GX2 cards for quad-SLI, don't do it.

     

     

     Remember, in SLI, you only have the total video memory of just ONE video card. So, despite the fact that the GX2 cards have 1GB of RAM per card, you can only utilize 512MB of that RAM because it has internal SLI built into the card. And if you run quad-SLI, you'll have 512MB of usuable video memory out of your 2GB of video memory. If you were to get a pair of GTX260s, then, you'd have 896MB of total video memory. The benefit of this would come especially at the higher resolutions when texture is placing more emphasis on the video memory than on the GPU.

     

    If I were you, I would get a couple of XFX XXX Edition GTX 260's. I run Crysis, COD4, and anything else I want at max settings with all the eye candy cranked up and it's awesome. I'm going to wait until the prices drop on the GTX 280's and then sell my 260's on eBay. 

     

    Here are the specs on the GTX 260 and the GTX 280. As you can see, there's not a whole lot of difference but the difference in price is over $150 per card.

     

     

    XFX XXX Edition GTX 260

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     XFX GTX 280

     

    Message Edited by PH3N0M on 10-21-2008 10:06 AM
  • genoxps

    31 Posts

    682

    0

    Posted October 21st, 2008 17:00

    Thanks again to everyone. I think I am going to go with the GTX 280.

     

     

  • pbryanw

    59 Posts

    682

    0

    Posted October 21st, 2008 22:00


    @Gruffly78 wrote:

    Don't play Vanguard... been staying away from MMO's since the old EQ days (can anyone say addiction!)

     

    I'll download the Basic edition of 3DMark06 (v110) and try it out and re-post.  Don't have a 9800GX2 to compare with my exact setup though.

     

    From the list in the Toms Hardward link, it looks like 3DMark06 doesn't do the GTX280 justice. 


    I think ChrisM Must have meant 3DMark Vantage :) You'll probably get better results testing your GTX280 with Vantage as it's newer and designed to test newer graphics cards.

     

    My AMD 4870 in my XPS 420 gets around 8500 points in vantage, so I'd be interested how your GTX280 does. Of course nVidia cards get around 2000 more points in vantage because of their physX support (at least that's what happened with my old 8800GT). The only problem with 3DMark Vantage is that you have to pay $6.95 to get a licence and view your results.

  • Gruffly78

    46 Posts

    682

    0

    Posted October 21st, 2008 23:00

    LOL yeah I figured that after I posted... DOH (lol).

     

    I think there was something wrong with the default settings in vantage, at one point I think during the physics testing the screen shifted over and went all interlaced and then slowed to a crawl.  It might have been the CPU test, but can't be sure since I can only run the test once in trial mode without purchasing it!! grr. 

     

     

    3D mark vantage score: P18562 (cpu 36899, GPU 15924) @forceware 178.13

     

    3D mark '06 V110 score 14016 @forceware 178.13

    3D mark '06 V110 score 14400 @forceware 178.24 (updated)

     

    The Toms Hardware results (see prev. link) 

    3D mark '06 V110 score 13064 for 9800GX2 and 12951 for GTX280 (both single cards however).  

    Shows that 3D mark '06 is not really that valid for testing SLI rigs.

    Message Edited by Gruffly78 on 10-21-2008 09:29 PM
  • Aurora51

    1 Rookie

    •

    139 Posts

    338

    0

    Posted October 22nd, 2008 11:00


    @Gruffly78 wrote:

    I did a lot of reading before I purchased my new SLI-GTX280 system:

     

    - GTX280 has 1024MB of ram, 9800GX2 has 512MB



    A small point...since it's after the fact that the OP has already decided - but for anyone else reading and contemplating on buying one or the other. The 9800GX2 actually has the same amount of Ram as the GTX280....1024MB. The 9800GX2 is actually two cards in one don't forget.

     

    I'm not debating as whether one is better than the other. Both are great from what I read. 

  • Fitzee

    23 Posts

    682

    0

    Posted October 22nd, 2008 11:00

    Yea, I would have expected you to get a much higher score in 06.

    I'd say its a new card requiring better drivers issue though. People with geforce 8 series in sli are getting much better scores. A recent thread here a guy running dual 8800GT scores over 17000.

    Either way its only a benchmark, actual in-game performance is what really matters.