UNSOLVED

GlobalHawk

updated

19 years ago

0

24358

September 26th, 2007 11:00

SLI or not to SLI, Is there really an advantage?

I just bought the XPS 720 and it came with the 8600GTS. In a previous thread it was said that it would be better to buy (1) 640 mb 8800GTS than (2) 320mb 8800GTS in SLI. So I wanted to know what is the advantage of using dual graphic cards? If you have (2) 320 mb 8800 GTS in SLI wouldn't my performance be better than just buying (1) 640mb 8800GTS? I know it will cost more to buy (2) 320's but if it will perform better wouldn't it be worth it?
  • odenwalder

    1 Rookie

    •

    1182 Posts

    839

    0

    Posted September 26th, 2007 12:00

    You are correct about your monitor and the GTX. It really shines best at 1920 x 1200 and higher.


    Message Edited by odenwalder on 09-26-2007 08:58 AM
  • 839

    0

    Posted September 26th, 2007 12:00

    Thanks aadosx. I see what your are saying now. In SLI I would expect to see at least a 40% gain in performance but it would be more cost effective and less of a headache (with Vista issues) to just get (1) high end card.  
     


    odenwalder wrote:
    I have to agree. For double the money you will usually realize at most a 40% gain in performance. Also we see way too many questions and problems regarding SLI on the forums especially with Vista. And to go one better for the price of two 8800GTS 320's you could buy and 8800GTX which will give better performance at higher resolutions and resolutions that are not supported by the 320's. I would go either single GTS 320, Gts 640, or budget permitting GTX 768. I think the 640 is the sweet spot interms of bang for your buck and I own both upper end models.



    I'm leaning towards the 640 as you say it is the sweet spot. I was told that with my 20 " flat panel I really couldn't take advantage of the GTX and I really wouldn't see much of a performance difference according to Tom's Hardware for the extra money.
     
  • aadosx

    111 Posts

    839

    0

    Posted September 26th, 2007 12:00

    You pretty much got it..
     
    Of course the two 8800 GTS 320 mb cards will perform faster in almost every situation, but you would be spending more money so you should expect that.  As I said before though the memory doesn't double with SLI, so in games/programs where GPU RAM is important, the single 640 might be better than even two 320's.
     
    So, if money isn't an issue then yes, two 320's would be better almost always, period.  That being said, I'd still rather have a 640, almost even if they were the same cost.  You'd be using less power too (which I know doesn't matter to most), and your computer would run cooler.  On top of that SLI can cause some issues especially with Vista out.  I had it and it just wasn't worth the trouble IMO.
     
    Other opinions appreciated here..
  • odenwalder

    1 Rookie

    •

    1182 Posts

    839

    0

    Posted September 26th, 2007 12:00

    I have to agree. For double the money you will usually realize at most a 40% gain in performance. Also we see way too many questions and problems regarding SLI on the forums especially with Vista. And to go one better for the price of two 8800GTS 320's you could buy and 8800GTX which will give better performance at higher resolutions and resolutions that are not supported by the 320's. I would go either single GTS 320, Gts 640, or budget permitting GTX 768. I think the 640 is the sweet spot interms of bang for your buck and I own both upper end models.
  • 839

    0

    Posted September 26th, 2007 14:00

    I guess my biggest concern is being "future ready". Especially with the 9800 series comming out soon I want to know that if I get the 640mb 8800GTS I will be satisfied. I just got the thing and I'm already toying with the idea of upgrading the OS to the 64bit Vista. I will be doing some gaming but it's mostly for video and music editing.
  • tphillips63

    4 Apprentice

    •

    2629 Posts

    •

    7922 Points

    839

    0

    Posted September 26th, 2007 14:00

    I have had SLI 7800 GTX, 7900 GTX, and now 8800 GTX.

    In all cases I could benchmark the difference but in play rarely noticed any difference.

    In fact I have used my PC for weeks at a time with SLI off after a drive update and not realized until I just happened to be poking around and noticed it off.

    I will never buy SLI again unless its some type of single card and maybe not even then.

    Costs too much for not enough gain.
  • ZBoater

    473 Posts

    839

    0

    Posted September 26th, 2007 14:00

    Given the size monitor you are using, I wouldnt worry about SLI.   I can drive my 30" LCD at 2560x1600 with a SINGLE 8800GTX with no issues.  SLI makes it go faster, but single is no slouch.
  • Aivas47a

    1227 Posts

    839

    0

    Posted September 26th, 2007 18:00

    I couldn't help jumping in here to promote my personal "Just Say No to SLI" campaign. :smileyhappy:
     
    The bottom line as a number of folks have already pointed is that SLI is a bad deal:  a 100% increase in cost; a 100% increase in power requirements; a 0% - 40% increase in performance.  On top of which, SLI is inherently buggier than a single GPU, a fact which is demonstrated afresh with almost every new game release.
     
    I've played virtually every major new title in the past year on a 30 inch monitor at high IQ settings with a single 8800GTX card without encountering any difficulties.  In fact I recently sold the second 8800GTX card I had once used in an SLI setup.
     
    I'm looking forward to what the new 9000 series has to offer, but will not be falling into the dual card marketing trap again. :smileywink:
  • tphillips63

    4 Apprentice

    •

    2629 Posts

    •

    7922 Points

    839

    0

    Posted September 26th, 2007 19:00

    Aivas47a makes a great point, "0% - 40%" you only get a boost while gaming.

    I wonder how many boards will have good advice and not fanboy rants pro or con about the subject?
  • Davet50

    6 Operator

    •

    14442 Posts

    217

    0

    Posted September 26th, 2007 20:00

    so is crossfire basicly the same not much bang for the buck???