
UNSOLVED
Memory Upgrade Conundrum
I have an XPS 410 with 2 gb of memory (2 1-gb modules of DDR SDRAM at 667 mhz).
I purchased the Dell memory upgrade kit (2 identical 1-gb, 667 modules).
I'm running Vista Home Premium.
Prior to the upgrade, the system setup (f2) showed two memory modules installed.
Vista's "System Information" showed 2.045 of "total physical memory" and 1.03 of "available memory" (not sure why those aren't the same .... I'm assuming the other 1 gb is being used by Vista and other programs already loaded? ... this is a side question).
I assumed that after the installation, system setup (f2) would show 4 modules installed & Vista "System Information" would show about 4.0 of "total physical memory" and about 3.0 gb of "available memory".
System setup (f2) indeed shows 4 modules installed, so presumably they are installed correctly. Vista's "System Information" however shows only 3.069 "total physical memory" and about 2 gb of "available memory".
I uninstalled and reinstalled the new modules several times, always with the same result .... Vista will not recognize more than 3.069 of "total physical memory".
I removed the module from the 4th slot and left in the one from the 3rd slot. System setup (f2) showed 3 modules installed, Vista still showed 3.069 of "total physical memory". Ditto for when I left the 3rd slot empty and installed a new module in the 4th slot. It didn't matter which of the two new modules I used .... both worked in either the 3rd or 4th slot and Vista showed 3.069 of "total physical memory"
I re-installed the 4th module. System setup (f2) says that 4 memory modules are installed. Vista "System Information" still maintains that "total physical memory" is only 3.069 gb.
I ran the "Windows Memory Diagnostic Tool". It didn't reveal any problem.
My question is: what is the problem? am I doing something wrong? I have the latest BIOS (2.5.3) for this computer.
Any help or suggestions will be greatly appreciated.
Regards,
Bill
Responses (12)
Solutions (0)
I think you answered the side question, but I'm still left with the main question:
With 3 modules installed Vista "System Information" says I have 3.069 gb of "total physical memory" & about 2 gb of "available physical memory".
With 4 modules installed Vista "System Information" says the exact same thing: 3.069 gb of "total physical memory" and 2 gb of "available physical memory".
My question is, why isn't Vista recognizing the presence of 4 gb of physical memory, regardless of how much of it may be "available"? If a 4th memory module gives you no
more "physical" or "available" memory than 3 modules, what's the point of having a 4th module?
As an addendum to my last post, the description of the Dell 2-gb memory module upgrade includes the following:
"On a system configured with 4 GB of memory (RAM), Microsoft® Windows® will report 3.0 GB to 3.8 GB of available memory. This is normal for 32-bit versions of Windows"
My problem is that I've only got 2 gb of "available" memory, not 3 gb, and only 3 gb of "actual physical memory", not 4 gb, even though 4 modules are installed.
My copy of Vista is up to date. Since Dell knew that I have 32 bit Vista installed on this machine and already had 2 gb of memory installed, why then would it recommend, and what's more actually sell to me a 2-gb memory upgrade kit knowing full well, as you put it, that more than 3 gb of memory on this machine is "pointless"? It would seem to be a pretty open and shut case of fraud on Dell's part, if that's true.
Recommended for Your XPS/Dimension 410/9200
Dell - 2 GB (2 x 1 GB) Memory Module Kit for XPS 410 / Dimension 9200 Desktops
Is there a Dell moderator on this forum who'd care to comment on that?
I guess I sort of understand the situation now, based on your mention of sp1 and further reading inspired by that mention. I assumed, not unreasonably I think, that since I subscribe to "Automatic Windows Update", I would automatically have sp1 or similar functionality installed. Windows Update says that my computer is completely current as far as updates are concerned. I notice however, that my version of Windows Vista is "build 6000", whereas, in reading up about sp1, it is referred to as "build 6001". Apparently then sp1 (or parts of it) is (are) not included in the automatic windows update process.
So, I guess the various programs on my computer that report system memory are pre-sp1 and are therefore defining "total physical memory" not as "installed memory", which I assumed was the case, but merely that part of "installed memory" which is available to the operating system. It appears then I do have 4 gb installed, with about 3.07 gb of it available to Vista. What the pre-sp1 "system information" program (msinfo32.exe version 8) refers to as "available memory" is apparently that part of the 3.07 gb that is not being used by the operating system or whatever other programs are currently running.
Thanks for your help :)
- Still bummed by the fact though that a 4th memory module appears to add absolutely nothing beyond what a 3rd module gives you, and Dell gladly recommended to me and sold to me a 2 gb upgrade based on its analysis of my system. Kind of disappointing. After 12 years of Dell computers and parts, I think I'm definitely ready for a change of vendor.
Dell don't know what operating system you might be using in the future.
In my case, I'm running Vista x64 which uses the full 4GB.
Or you might be dual booting Red Hat Linux x64, which uses the full 4GB.
It's not a machine limitation, it's a limitation of the default OS that ships with the machine.
Some day, x64 operating systems will be the default OS.
dv.
"Dell don't know what operating system you might be using in the future."
True, but they know which one I'm using now, and that's what they based their "recommendation" on. I don't think they should assume that I'm going to a 64 bit operating system in the future on this computer, and make recommendations based on assumptions.

Davet50
6 Operator
•
14442 Posts
592
0
Posted August 17th, 2008 17:00
You are running a 32bit OS. Therefore max memory that can be addressable is 4 gigs. Now the bad part. Out of that 4 gigs, memory is reserved by the system for the Video card(s) and other system devices. This reserving can drop to total available memory from four to anyware between 2.5 and 3.5 gigs. There is nothing that can be done to change this.
The only way to fully utilize all installed system ram is by switching to a 64bit OS.
This topic has been well documented and is nothing new.