
UNSOLVED
Tweaked Cooling for Area 51 R2
As I posted here, I recently bought a ZOTAC Geforce ® GTX 1080 Ti AMP Extreme and installed it in my Area 51 R2.
While this is a great card and I can recommend it without any doubt, it generates a lot of heat. And even though the Area 51 handled it, there was allot of noise from the fans and I didn't liked it.
So here is my solution:
(Special thanks to @Carbon Based Lifeform, he identified the problems before I even bought the card, as you can see here, and that was a crucial help by solving them!)
To understand where the noise problems are coming from you have to bring the cooling concept of the Area 51 R2 to your mind:
In the upper floor, the Top Fan pulls in fresh air from the outside and pushes it over the RAM and the voltage regulators (VREG). The CPU Fan pulls this air through the radiator of the CPU liquid cooling and pushes it back out of the case.
In the lower floor, the PCI Fan pulls in fresh air from the outside and pushes it through the PCI slots and over whatever there is installed (in the most cases only a graphics card). The graphics card (if it is a reference design card that Dell uses, a so called "Blower"), will pull in this air in and push it over its coolers and out of the back of the case.
In the basement there is also the power supply. It pulls fresh air in and pushes hot air out at back out of the case. But because the air is running exclusively through the power supply, it has no direct impact on the temperatures in the case.
All this runs very fine, and the fans (expect of the one on the graphic card) will mostly be in idle.
But here is the problem: while a Blower style cooling of your graphics card is great for your case, it is actually suboptimal for your graphics card. Don't get me wrong, I'm not saying that Blower cards a bad. For the temperatures of your whole system they are actually pretty good. But for the graphic card themselves the other cooling variant, the so called "Open Air Cooler" is better. You don't have to believe me, just look at the clock speeds of the cards: almost all factory overclocked models are Open Air cards. It is just a matter of physics: an Open Air card has more heat exchanging surface, and there is more space on top of it for up to three axial fans. The only negative thing is: the heat is not going out of the case!
So I installed my ZOTAC Geforce ® GTX 1080 Ti AMP Extreme, played a game, and suddenly, there was a jet taking of in my room. The reason for this:
1. The Open Air style of cooling does not get the hot air out of your case.
2. The hot air in the case is not very effective in cooling the CPU.
3. The "Alien Control" mode of heat regulation wants to counter the high temperatures inside the case and on the CPU by cranking up the fan speeds of booth the case and the CPU cooler.
4. Dell installed some pretty serious fans in the case. Don't know exactly what the purpose is, maybe supercruise, or they shoot for the popular "Death Valley approved" label.
What to do? Make a plan and follow through!
That's what Brian Boitano'd do. (Maybe my wife is right and I'm a little nerdy sometimes.)
1. To get more hot air out of the case
I replaced the original slot covers with some SilverStone AEROSLOTS. Best thing about them: you can get them in black, so the back of my baby looks now so much better!
I also got the GPU power cord a little more out of the way by fixing it to the GPU holder with a pair of cable ties.
As you can see here, the GPU holder is still in the way, but overall there is a free path for the air from the PCI Fan over the graphics card and out of the case.
2. To get more fresh air into the case in order to help out the CPU cooler
I installed the middle fan. The fan bracket was already installed in my case, just had to get rid of the cover plate. I first connected it to the MID_FAN1 connector on the motherboard. But a fan on this connector (although a 4 pin connector, and a PWM connector, as I think) is not listed in Alienware Control Center, so you have no chance to manually control its rpm. That's why I used an Y-cable to connect booth the Top Fan and the Middle Fan to the TOP_FAN1 connector.
Didn't found any specs for the fan connectors on the motherboard, but in the depth of the internet rumor has it that 1 ampere is the cap for a 4 pin fan connector. As my fans have a maximum current of 0.3 ampere, there should be no problem with two of them on the same connector. Remember that although you can connect more than one fan to a single PWM connector and have them all controlled at the same time, you can only read the rmp of one of the connected fans at the same time. More on the fans under point 4.
3. I made a custom profile for the case fans via the Alienware control center.
As you can see, I connected the Top and Middle Fan (see point 2) to the VREG sensor, and the PCI Fan to the PCI sensor.
You could simply go "Alien Control" with the some new fans also, but then it will get loud again: The automatic control uses rpm instead of %, so "Idle" means 800 rpm, this is 50 % for some low noise fans.
By the way, the "Thermal Controls" tool is not very Handy at this point. Why I can only get 100 % speed at 100 °C? Why is the lowest point of the curve at 0 °C? And why ever it has to be a curve? I want to be able to make a profile that has the fans in idle up to a threshold, but then I want to ramp them up quickly to avoid disaster. At the moment, my PCI fan reaches 100 % when the PCI sensor is at 100 °C. The sensor is placed right at the bottom of the PCI slots. The moment I imagined an air temperature of 100 °C at this place, the term nuclear meltdown came to my mind.
4. I got rid of the Jericho Trumpets
(The installed fans are not bad by any means, there are rather some sturdy industrial style fans I would expect in a workstation or server of some kind. But my PC does not stand in a separate room, and these beasts are way overdimensioned.)
I can tolerate that these are two different fans, because there could be a technical reason, but the fan grills have a different style AND slightly different colors! Definitively room for improvement. (I mean, we are talking about obsolete fan grills inside a closed computer case being not of the same kind and color. And no, this is not an OCD, that has simply to be right ... because of reasons!)
I replaced them with Corsair ML120 PRO LED (Red), and in the process changed all three fan grills to black ones of identical design (and I feel much better now).
A little remark on fans and noise:
A good fan (it doesn't has to be a branded one, but don't expect wonders from a 3 fan pack for 5 bucks) makes almost no mechanical sound. They all have good bearings. They all have some rubber parts to disconnect them from the case regarding to vibration. Almost all noise comes from the rotor blades moving through the air and the air moving through obstacles like intakes or radiators. So the lower your rmp, the lower your noise, simple as that. But the lower the rpm, the lower the airflow, and the airflow is what keeps your system cool. That's why bigger fans are better noise wise: same airflow at lower rpm. There are still some tricks to lower the noise level a little bit, like special rotor designs. The bequiet! SILENT WINGS 3 that Carbon Based Lifeform is using are a good example for a well-engineered rotor blade design. But there is a limit how much you can reduce the noise that way, especially at higher rpm. In the end, to get the same air flow and air pressure with a fan of the same size, you will have to use it at a specific rpm and therefore it will make a specific amount of noise. Any fan ...
The results:
Much less noise.
A cool system (CPU around 53 °C and GPU at 70 °C at full load).
A killer look:
P.S.
If you are looking for some great tutorials (outside of the service manual) how to tinker with your Area 51, Dell has some awesome videos on YouTube, like this one.
Responses (48)
Solutions (0)
Carbon Based Lifeform
2 Intern
•
872 Posts
8625
0
Posted June 9th, 2017 12:00
thank you for this thread. i appreciate your detailed Posts. great Pics btw.
doesn't this Forum have a great Censor Filter?
i have the same Setup. i'm also using a Splitter Cable for the Middle Fan. my Fan Grils are the same as yours i think. Heck, even our Fan Curves look the same. there are only two differences. first; my Middle Fan is sharing the same Header as the Lower Fan, because i wanted it to be controlled by the GPU Sensor. and second; i didn't replace the Slot Brackets, because i have a GPU with the Blower Style Cooler.
i noticed the different Dell Fans aswell. not sure why Dell did it. and just like you i also noticed thet the Command Center doesn't show the Middle Fan. i meen the Board itself has four Fan Headers but the Command Center shows only two. WTH right? Lazy Devs came to my Mind first, but it makes sence actuallly. imagin what would happen if they added the two missing Fans to the CC. people would constantly wonder why the two Fans always show 0 RPM.one important detail. when the Middle Fan is connected to the Middle Fan Header, if the Fan Control is switched from Auto to manual the Fan stops working. no Idea why.
i have one Question. does the thermal Control App on your Machine work without Issues?
according to Reliability Report (German: Zuverlässigkeitsverlauf) sometimes i get an Error Message saying Thermal Control exe stopped working. the TC Tray Icon dissapiers and shows up again if i open the Command Center. it started happening after upgrading Windows 10 from Version 1511 to 1607 and updating the BIOS to A10.Carbon Based Lifeform wrote:
... i didn't replace the Slot Brackets, because i have a GPU with the Blower Style Cooler. ...
As I wrote, the Blower Style fits much more better in the cooling concept of the case. I'm thinking about an 80 mm fan with a little less rpm as my PCI fan, mounted directly over the PCI Slots. If I connect it with a splitter on PCI fan header, it will help getting the air through the case, but will always pull a little less than the PCI fan pushes. So I hope to avoid to pull to much secondary air.
Carbon Based Lifeform wrote:
... and just like you i also noticed thet the Command Center doesn't show the Middle Fan. i meen the Board itself has four Fan Headers but the Command Center shows only two. *** right? Lazy Devs came to my Mind first, but it makes sence actuallly. imagin what would happen if they added the two missing Fans to the CC. people would constantly wonder why the two Fans always show 0 RPM. ...
Good comment, didn't thought about that. I have no clue if you could make the Command Center differ between a not connected and a not working fan though. But maybe they could have added an option to choose if you have a fan connected or not. Or you could choose the activ fans in the BIOS.
Carbon Based Lifeform wrote:
... i have one Question. does the thermal Control App on your Machine work without Issues?
according to Reliability Report (German: Zuverlässigkeitsverlauf) sometimes i get an Error Message saying Thermal Control exe stopped working. the TC Tray Icon dissapiers and shows up again if i open the Command Center. it started happening after upgrading Windows 10 from Version 1511 to 1607 and updating the BIOS to A10. ...Based on my Reliability Report there is no problem with the Thermal Controls on my System. BIOS is A11 and Win 10 Version is 1703.
Carbon Based Lifeform
2 Intern
•
872 Posts
8625
0
Posted June 9th, 2017 17:00
good Idea for the Fans. BIOS is usually able to tell if the Fan is connected or not and if not, it shows N/A. are we going back to Lazy Devs now?
regarding my Errors: welb, i guess my Mainboard has a Defect then. LGA 2066.... i'm comming!!!
Carbon Based Lifeform
2 Intern
•
872 Posts
8625
0
Posted June 24th, 2017 02:00
Hi JKTRRT.
i can't tell you for sure if the Mounting Bracket is installed or not. some Models like my A51 are Sold without the Bracket. i ordered the Fan MB from Dell Spare department. the Dell Product Number is VNPD3.
open your Case and see if it's there. it looks exactly the same as the Top Fan Bracket but Upside Down.
yes, the Cover needs to be removed. you can peel it off with your Fingers.
Carbon Based Lifeform
2 Intern
•
872 Posts
8625
0
Posted June 24th, 2017 03:00
if the Bracket is installed then you should see it immediately. there is a Plastic Border around the Cover. the Boarder is the actual Bracket.
there is no other Place to buy the Bracket. only Dell Tech Support is selling them. and yes, most of the Time they are unavailable. i was actually surprised when the Lady from the Dell Support offered me to buy the Bracket. usually they don't sell them. just google and you'll see alot of People who tried to Order one but didn't get it.
Hey JKTRRT,
as mentioned, you should spot the fan bracket easily once you've opened your case. If you're still not sure, watch this video: Alienware Area-51 R2: Upgrade/Replace Top Fan.
The part number is correct, but it seems not to be as easy as I thought to get one. Just realized how lucky I got to had one installed already ...

Alienware - Rodrigo
9 Technologist
•
4398 Posts
8625
1
Posted June 9th, 2017 09:00
Hi,
Thank you for sharing this with the Alienware Community.