UNSOLVED

Uber Schwarz

updated

19 years ago

0

8812

June 9th, 2007 02:00

Question about Dell Ubuntu Desktops

If I wipe my HDD on the XPS model and install Ubuntu with my CD, would the dialup modem work right after installation or would I have to go through the process of making it work by doing all those steps and stuff?
  • 270

    0

    Posted June 9th, 2007 19:00

    Dial up modems are a pain in Linux to set up. It's best to do a lot of research on the make/model of the modem (is it a hardware modem, a Winmodem, etc) before wiping the drive and installing Ubuntu. I'd suggest doing a dual boot with Windows and Ubuntu for the time being, getting everything working as you want before removing Windows for good.
  • hotshotDJ

    136 Posts

    270

    0

    Posted June 9th, 2007 20:00

    Ok... WHICH XPS model? All WHAT steps? The XPS that Dell sells preinstalled with Linux doesn't HAVE a modem. Did you purchase one separately (if so, what type?). Did you purchase an XPS with Windows preinstalled and with one of Dell's modems (which most likely won't work in Linux -- but some DO!).

    Modems are not a pain in Linux. Software-based modems are NOT real modems. A proper, controller-based modem (all external serial modems, some external usb-modems, and a very few internal modems) will work "out of the box" in Linux. Most soft-modems (most internal modems, some external usb modems) will not work in Linux because the manufacturers have chosen not to make drivers or permit others to make drivers. There are a few that will work with the proper software installed. Conexant based modems will only work in Linux with a proprietary third-party driver available from Linuxant for $20. Others work using the SLModem driver (freely available -- somewhat of a pain to get working in Ubuntu). You'll need to Google your particular modem for Linux drivers. However, in general, if your modem doesn't work "out of the box" in Linux, it won't work at all.
  • 270

    0

    Posted June 10th, 2007 01:00

    I spoke with someone from Dell and they said the XPS 410 N does come with a modem and works right away. But I was wondering if I wiped out the entire HDD along with Ubuntu pre-installed on the system and installed my Ubuntu CD if the modem would work right after installation or would I need to download the drivers.

    So you say USB modems and external modems will work straight-out-of-the-box for Linux? SO I could just plug it in and connect to the Internet right away?
  • hotshotDJ

    136 Posts

    270

    0

    Posted June 10th, 2007 06:00

    I'm very sure that the XPS 410n does NOT come with a modem. I'm looking at the configuration page right now and it clearly states "No Modem." The person you spoke with had incorrect information (not surprising as this is a new product line for Dell, it will take some time before all their representatives know what is going on). So you'll have to purchase a modem separately. Even if it did come with a modem, it is likely that it would be a software modem (WinModem) which is unlikely to work "out of the box" if you wipe your hard drive and reinstall Ubuntu.

    Just about ALL external modems that connect via a standard serial port (DB9 connector) will work "out of the box" with Linux (including Ubuntu). SOME USB modems will work, but many will NOT. While some internal, software-based (WinModems) will work with the proper drivers in Linux, most will NOT. If you can find a true controller based internal modem, it will work "out of the box" as well, but they are expensive.

    In my opinion, your best bet is to purchase an external serial port (DB9) modem. I have never had trouble with them. They do not require any special drivers and should be pretty much "plug & play." If you decide to go with a USB modem, you'll need to be careful and google the exact brand and model before buying it to determine if it will be supported in Linux.