UNSOLVED

gordonl78

updated

3 years ago

G

gordonl78

1 Rookie

•

10 Posts

0

3769

March 29th, 2021 12:00

Brand new WD19TB + Dell Lattitude 5511causes Ethernet broadcast storm

Re: WD19 dock kills local network when laptop is turned off?

I too have replicated this issue on (both brand new) WD19TB with Dell 5511 combination.

- This occurs when laptop is completely shut down (through proper shutdown process)

- WD19TB is powered with included Dell power adapter

- Seems as though this creates a packet storm which takes down the attached wired network (1G Ethernet).   All nearby wired Ethernet devices loose connectivity (Ping, UDP, and TCP transactions).

- When I checked my BIOS:  Thunderbolt is ALREADY set to no security.  WOL is already disabled (suggestion to correct this from another forum thread) -- but this issue is still present.

As soon as I remove the Ethernet cable from WD19TB, the entire network comes back to life.  This behavior is repeatable and reliable.  Need a solution as I do not want to rely upon Wifi for all my large data transfers.

  • DELL-Cares

    Moderator

    •

    27844 Posts

    •

    748 Points

    1756

    0

    Posted March 31st, 2021 03:00

    Hi. I was going through the case and see that you have reported an issue with network broadcast storm while connecting to WD19TB dock. Please private message us the service tag of the system and dock for us to assist you further.


    #IWork4Dell

    For all non-technical issues that require your private data, we must communicate via a private Direct Message
    Dell Partner GEM Program, Out of Warranty Support options, No free goodwill repair, Get a copy of your Dell invoice

  • sfortin

    2 Intern

    •

    199 Posts

    1741

    1

    Posted March 31st, 2021 04:00

    When you run the Dell Detect program on your system, does it find a updated driver for the dock? Make sure if one is available, that it is loaded for the dock.

  • DELL-Cares

    Moderator

    •

    27844 Posts

    •

    748 Points

    1719

    0

    Posted April 1st, 2021 01:00

    Hi. I am waiting for you revert. Do write to us in private message at your convenience for us to assist you further.


    #IWork4Dell

    For all non-technical issues that require your private data, we must communicate via a private Direct Message
    Dell Partner GEM Program, Out of Warranty Support options, No free goodwill repair, Get a copy of your Dell invoice

  • gordonl78

    1 Rookie

    •

    10 Posts

    1652

    1

    Posted April 6th, 2021 16:00

    Indeed after checking Dell Command Update -- there was a PCIe Ethernet Controller update that was pending (Version 25.5.0.1)  After updating this I can confirm that the broadcast storm behavior (when laptop is shutdown, but connected to dock) now no longer occurs.

    gordonl78_0-1617753435988.png

     

  • gordonl78

    1 Rookie

    •

    10 Posts

    1589

    0

    Posted April 14th, 2021 07:00

    Update 4/14/2021:  Unfortunately this issue is once again occuring, even after the update mentioned.

    My system appears to have worked well for the past week+, although I can confirm that this issue only exists when the new 5511 is fully shut down.  And since I don't always shut down my laptop I'm not sure exactly when this issue has re-occured.  But it definitely still an issue. 

    Last night I started loosing connectivity on all my LAN devices only (1Gbps LAN, with all 1Gbps devices).  And immediately after disconnecting my WD19TB connectivity returned back to normal.  All devices are addressed via centralized DHCP.

    Please re-open this case.

  • gordonl78

    1 Rookie

    •

    10 Posts

    1544

    0

    Posted April 20th, 2021 08:00

    There is no reason to revert.

    The latest PCIe Ethernet controller driver was installed 4/1/2021. The only other install was the "firmware update utility" which isn't a driver (if the Dell descriptions are accurate) and should not affect actual operation of hardware (because that is what drivers are).

    gordonl78_0-1618931248206.png

     

    I do not see any options to "remove firmware update utility" via the Dell Command | Update menus.   Can you please send instructions on how to to remove this firmware from WB19TB?

    So this issue is still outstanding with no real troubleshooting or debug. There is clearly an issue with this WD19TB. The question is if Dell is seeing widespread issue of this? If not, then is it an issue with this particular unit?

    Do you have any other real debug steps to approach the issue of why the docking station is behaving like this while the Laptop is shutdown?

    If no other steps -- can you please arrange for an RMA as I need the LAN working normally without me manually plugging and unplugging this cable every time I shut down this laptop.

  • gordonl78

    1 Rookie

    •

    10 Posts

    1598

    0

    Posted April 21st, 2021 12:00

    Downgraded the WD19TB Firmware Updater utility back to original as requested by Dell support.

    Once again with the laptop fully powered off (but charging from WD19TB) the LAN went down again last night.  Disconnected the WD19TB and immediately connectivity returned.

    It seems as though this condition does not occur immediately when the Dell 5511 is shut down -- so some condition needs (whether time based, or network based stimulus) to occur for this to happen.  But it happens consistently enough that it will happen within the day and the LAN of my network will cease to function.

  • sfortin

    2 Intern

    •

    199 Posts

    1548

    0

    Posted April 22nd, 2021 03:00

    1). What sort of network topology are you using? Does your laptop and dock take down the LAN when the laptop is shutdown? I think you indicated it did. Maybe you just have a faulty dock.

    2). How is your laptop and the dock getting an IP address? See if changing the laptop to use a static IP changes the situation.

    3). Have you tried a different cable? What is the distance between the dock and the router / switch?

  • gordonl78

    1 Rookie

    •

    10 Posts

    1504

    0

    Posted April 26th, 2021 09:00

    1)  This USB docking station is 3 Gigabit switches away from the Router.  Router is an R7000 running off the shelf Netgear firmware (whatever is recent and mainline)

    2) DHCP - all being provided by the router.    I can try this, but at the same time if this docking station can't handle DHCP, it's clearly a docking station issue.  And my impression is that we should be seeing WAY more customer issues on this.  With the way Dell support has been on this (constantly asking me to just check what Dell firmware/drivers have been applied) it appears it's not a widespread issue.

    3) Cabling is very short - less than 25ft for every distance between switches.

  • gordonl78

    1 Rookie

    •

    10 Posts

    1104

    0

    Posted April 26th, 2021 10:00

    Yes at this point I think there is more merit in this sort of testing than what Dell support has suggested.  I have a long Cat5e cable I can directly connect to the Router, to negate the entire switch topology as well.  So I'll try that tonight.