UNSOLVED

WillieB9722

updated

7 years ago

W

WillieB9722

1 Rookie

•

3 Posts

0

8463

September 23rd, 2019 04:00

Inspiron 7591, won't charge from TB16

HI All,

I have an Inspiron 7591. I have it docked to a TB16 and everything works fine but only when the laptop is plugged in to it's own power supply. I have tried it with a few docks now and it doesn't charge from the dock. I have tried 240w, 180w, and 130w a/c supplies none charge the Inspiron 7591. The battery life is fine.

any suggestions?

  • jphughan

    11 Legend

    •

    13985 Posts

    •

    79931 Points

    7130

    0

    Posted September 23rd, 2019 06:00

    @WillieB9722  are you certain that the Inspiron 7591 supports being charged via USB-C? I see the notes on the USB-C port say it supports PD (Power Delivery), but that's ambiguous because Power Delivery can run in both directions, and on some systems that just means it supports providing USB PD to attached peripherals that can use it. Typically it's either 7.5W or 15W, sometimes configurable in the BIOS. If the system supports receiving USB PD to charge itself, then since that system seems to ship with a 130W AC adapter, if you're using a TB16 you'll want to use a 240W adapter because that's required with the TB16 if you want it to be able to pass 130W to the attached system. If you use a 180W adapter, it only passes 90W. 130W adapters aren't supported with the TB16 at all. The WD15 used 130W and 180W adapters for 90W and 130W max USB PD. The TB16 uses 180W and 240W for the same purpose because the TB16 requires more power both for its internal components and because I believe the "upstream" Thunderbolt 3 port supports providing up to 60W to an attached peripheral.

    If you want to test USB PD charging support and you have a "basic" USB PD wall charger, go into the BIOS Setup on that system and click into the Battery Information section. Underneath the battery graphic, the system will show the wattage of a power source when one is detected. With USB-C, the identified wattage will be either the max wattage that's being offered based on the power source and cable you're using or the most the system will draw over USB PD, whichever is lower. If you don't see a power source detected when you have something plugged into the system's USB-C port, then chances are it doesn't support charging over USB-C.

  • WillieB9722

    1 Rookie

    •

    3 Posts

    7073

    0

    Posted September 23rd, 2019 07:00

    @jphughan Hi thanks for your response! I tried the TB16 with a 240w power supply. However the TB16 shut itself off when connected to the laptop. I’ll give your suggestion a go and see what happens. 

  • jphughan

    11 Legend

    •

    13985 Posts

    •

    79931 Points

    6647

    0

    Posted September 23rd, 2019 14:00

    The Precision systems that require the AC adapter to be connected directly to the system in addition to the TB16 connection are designed for power sources of 180W or more, whereas the TB16 can supply at most 130W.  (Those types of systems are now more elegantly supported by the "DC" dock models that can supply up to 210W to systems because they plug into two USB-C/TB3 ports on the system).  The Inspiron 7591 is designed for a 130W power source and therefore in theory could be powered optimally from a TB16 that was itself connected to a 240W power source, but that doesn't mean that Dell actually implemented USB-C charging support on that particular system.

  • DELL-Chris M

    Community Manager

    •

    56891 Posts

    •

    232143 Points

    6672

    0

    Posted September 23rd, 2019 14:00

    Great post by jphughan!

    None of the Inspiron laptops are listed in the "System Compatibility Matrix for the TB16". So even though the Inspiron 7591 has a Thunderbolt 3/USB Type-C port, it was not tested by Dell with the TB16. In the chart we can see that even some of the high end Precision laptops require the usage of their power adapter in addition to the TB16 power adapter. Page 6 of the Inspiron 7591 Setup and Specifications PDF does not mention the Thunderbolt 3/USB Type-C port and charging.


    DELL-Chris M (old account)

    #IWork4Dell

  • RStarVet

    2 Posts

    4777

    0

    Posted October 2nd, 2019 09:00

    HI @WillieB9722 

    Please could you tell me if your 7591 had thunderbolt?

    I have just purchased the same laptop and was looking at the tb16 as a dock when I came across your post.

    Did you manage to resolve the issue or find a suitable dock?

    I wanted the tb16 for the 2x4k display

    Many thanks

     

     

  • jtuta

    9 Posts

    4806

    0

    Posted October 2nd, 2019 12:00

    Hello,

    I think I have similar problem, although I have the 7590 model and different Thunderbolt dock, let me explain:

    Currently I own two Dell laptops – XPS 9560 (i7-7700HQ/32GB/1TB) and Inspiron 7590. (i7-9750H/16GB/512GB) I have a small issue with the newer – the Inspiron 7590. I use these laptops with CalDigit TS3 Plus (https://www.caldigit.com/ts3-plus) Thunderbolt 3 docking station which is quoted to provide 85W via USB-C/Thunderbolt connector.

    When I connect CalDigit dock to my XPS everything works as expected (I also get the warning about under-powered power supply which is expected). In the BIOS screen I can see that it gets registered as 65W power supply.

    When I connect CalDigit dock to my Inspiron it constantly connects and disconnects (I can hear windows tune of pluging-in/-out an external device), computer also never charges (not when booted to windows, not in sleep, not when shut down, not when in BIOS,…). When I connect power supply to the laptop (so that dock is used only as Thunderbolt device and power is drawn form the charger) dock finally connects and I can use usb ports/ethernet/display ports of the dock.

    I believe that USB-C charging circuit is working correctly as I can charge Inspiron with friend’s Apple MacBook PRO charger (using 65 W reported by Dell BIOS).

    As we can see in the Inspiron USB-C PD is working correctly (tested with Apple charger), Thunderbolt works (as seen when laptop uses charger and Thunderbolt at the same time), but when I connect my Thunderbolt dock to the Inspiron in order to utilize Thunderbolt and (advertised) 85W of charging capabilities the laptop does not successfully retain connection to the dock (constant connection and disconnections). In the same case my XPS 9560 successfully charges (with 65W reported by BIOS) and is successfully connected to the dock and therefore displays image on the external displays, etc.

    My guess is that this must be some kind of firmware issue when negotiating PD profiles. Do you have any tips/ideas how can I utilize my dock on the Inspiron?

    Also:

    • Yes, all drivers and utilities as suggested by SupportAssitant are installed
    • Yes, windows is updated
    • I will try to boot into live Linux (Ubuntu) and see if there maybe things work (to see if there is some windows driver related problem)
  • jtuta

    9 Posts

    4793

    0

    Posted October 2nd, 2019 13:00

    I tested Live boot of Ubuntu on both - same result. XPS 9560 works as expected, on Inspiron result is the same as on windows - connecting/disconnecting while charger is not plugged in, and thunderbolt wokrs when charger is connected. 

    Therefore the problem is not OS depened, I kinda hope that it is not depened of the BIOS, as i know that odds of BIOS update are not in my favor.....

  • jtuta

    9 Posts

    4728

    0

    Posted October 6th, 2019 12:00

    @DELL-Chris M can I get someone compitent to talk to - in the private messages one of a support person tried to convince me that (i qoute): "Your Inspiron 7590 does have a Thunderbolt 3 (USB Type-C) port. However, it doesn't have an option for 2-way power delivery (Thunderbolt charging). This won't allow the unit to charge via a docking station using the Thunderbolt 3 USB Type-C port".

    On dell product page it says: "Thunderbolt™ 3: A USB Type-C™ port supporting Thunderbolt™ 3 allows you to charge your laptop, connect to multiple devices, and enjoy data transfers of up to 40Gbps, 8 times that of a USB 3.1 Gen 1."

    I have also chared the laprop via Apples 87W USB-C charger in the past.

    Here are also 2 videos I sent in PMs with "DELL-cares", but as every message comes from different support membere I dont know if he or she sees the messages exchanged with previous preson....

     

    EDIT: It seems somebody has a 7590 which charges over TB: https://youtu.be/ZTD5EQqK25c?t=42

  • 4721

    0

    Posted October 6th, 2019 13:00

    Hello,

    Thanks for your message. 

     

    Please refer to page 6 on this manual https://dell.to/2APQqIZ You will see the Inspiron 7590's port specifications. 

    The Thunderbolt 3 (USB Type-C) port supports USB 3.1 Gen 2, DisplayPort 1.2, Thunderbolt 3 and also enables you to connect to an external display using a display adapter. Provides data transfer rates up to 10 Gbps for USB 3.1 Gen 2 and up to 40 Gbps for Thunderbolt 3.

     

    And on Page 10, you'll see that dock stations aren't supported.

     

    DELL-SimranC

  • jtuta

    9 Posts

    1841

    0

    Posted October 6th, 2019 23:00

    @Dell-SimranC Sorry, nothing personal, but I am inclined to think that your answer is not correct. Why?

    Firstly, I think that you have opend the manual and searched it for keywords "USB-C", "Type-C", "dock" and "Thunderbolt" and because you have not found anything you have written as you have. (I'd do so if I had your job)

    Seconldy, as you have seen there is a video ( https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZTD5EQqK25c&feature=youtu.be&t=42 ) showing a inspiron 7590 which is connected to the Lenovo thunderbolt dock and it connects succesfully without attached charger - this is problem that I and @WillieB9722 have (althoug he is on 7591 - but they are virtually the same as 7590 and 7591 ). 

    Thirdly, in the manual you have linked is doesnot say anywhere that it can charge via USB-C, but it does as I have charged mine with Apple USB-C charger - ergo. the pdf you have linked is far from the exact spec-sheet.