UNSOLVED

zmag-2015

updated

15 years ago

0

2066

February 16th, 2012 14:00

Thoughts on 2 hosts in one storage group, no cluster

We are setting up Citrix Provisioning Services and the documentation reccommends building a failover server in the same storage group as the primary server but to set the NTFS volume as read only.

Does anyone have thoughts on the pros and cons of this?

I've attachd the file, I am not sure where it was downloaded from. Pages 214, 215 and 216.

If it's better I can try to find the file online and post the link.

Message was edited by: Dave

1 Attachment

  • dynamox

    11 Legend

    •

    20419 Posts

    •

    87439 Points

    763

    0

    Posted February 16th, 2012 14:00

    do you have the link to this document ?

  • 763

    0

    Posted February 16th, 2012 15:00

    I've updated the ticket and attached the file, Thanks.

  • etaljic81

    1000 Posts

    763

    0

    Posted February 17th, 2012 05:00

    I'm not a Citrix expert by any means but I think the reason why they want you to set it to read-only is to avoid volume corruption. A cluster decides which volumes can be read/written to/from but this particular volume is not being presented to a cluster. Sounds like it's being presented to two hosts that are not clustered together and that's why they want you to set read-only on the volume on one of the hosts.

    Note that you cannot set a LUN to read-only from the storage side, as noted in the document you attached. YOu have to do that within the OS.

  • dynamox

    11 Legend

    •

    20419 Posts

    •

    87439 Points

    763

    0

    Posted February 17th, 2012 08:00

    Ernes Taljic wrote:

    Note that you cannot set a LUN to read-only from the storage side, as noted in the document you attached. YOu have to do that within the OS.

    or fabric (Cisco read-only zones)

  • christopher_ime

    6 Operator

    •

    1962 Posts

    763

    0

    Posted February 21st, 2012 20:00

    > Note that you cannot set a LUN to read-only from the storage side

    I know this is not the proper strategy for this particular scenario, but simply wanted to point out that depending on the array and the FLARE code level, we do support configuring LUNs as read-only from the array.  It can only be done (at least currently) via CLI though.  The NAVISECCLI commands of interest (introduced in VNX OE for Block R31.5.5xx):

    storagegroup -addhlu -readonly

    Then to verify the flag is set (or unset), run the following command

    storagegroup -list -readonly

    A "Read Only" column will be displayed with the current value.  Also, in the GUI, there is no way (currently) to set or view the flag.  Finally, while I'm at it, simply wanted to note that to modify the flag, it requires removing the LUN and then adding back with the proper value.

  • etaljic81

    1000 Posts

    763

    0

    Posted February 22nd, 2012 10:00

    What if the LUN is already added to the SG and you want to make it readonly? The only way to do it is to remove and re-add the LUN to the SG?

    Thanks!

  • Storagesavvy

    474 Posts

    763

    0

    Posted February 22nd, 2012 10:00

    Interesting!

    Since this was added in Naviseccli v.31, does it require VNX with OE.31+ or does it also support CX4 with older versions of FLARE?

    Thanks!

    Richard J Anderson

  • christopher_ime

    6 Operator

    •

    1962 Posts

    763

    0

    Posted February 22nd, 2012 16:00

    Ernes,

    Yes, you are correct that the LUN has to be removed to enable/disable the flag.  I had actually mentioned that already in my original post, but no worries.

  • christopher_ime

    6 Operator

    •

    1962 Posts

    763

    0

    Posted February 22nd, 2012 16:00

    Richard,

    Yes, it requires a supported version of FLARE as noted in the original post above.  Anything unsupported will not even recognize the "-readonly" flag (either to enable the feature itself or even list the status of the flag as noted above).

    No, I am not aware of any initiative to back-port this for anything other than the VNX.

  • etaljic81

    1000 Posts

    78

    0

    Posted February 22nd, 2012 17:00

    You are 100% correct. Sorry. Missed that. Thank you very much!