I'm running into a problem that's pretty much putting my production to a stop and it doesn't make sense.
My laptop is getting a power limit throttle that only occurs when plugged into a Dell thunderbolt dock which happens to be a WD19TB. When running on battery or supplied 130 watt power adapter computer runs stable.
I disabled turbo boost in the bios because erratic jumping of clock speeds would cause the ASIO drivers to become unstable and pop. Since then everything was smooth as butter, then the throttling occurs.
What's causing this and what is a viable solution?. I thought one of the problems can be a power limitation of the thunderbolt port itself? So I would plug in the power supply too but still no change.
Is there a bios update that would enable the laptop to favor receiving power from supplied adapter instead of thunderbolt port or perhaps use both?
This particular situation is saddening because as we all may know an XPS 15 with 4K OLED Screen, 64GB of Ram and 2TB NVME is not inexpensive and so thought would handle the task of music production with some ease.
Convinced I will not be receiving any solutions here as it has been some time and no replies. This is exactly the reason why people flock to apple. Will be selling my unit and never again purchasing poorly designed products from this company EVER again!
having same laptop with the same problem. the culprit is the usage of TB3 with external power.
the bios is not wokring correctly and it's recognize in first place charge over TB3 instead of directly connected power.
The only solution, when my CPU is throttled, I found is to unplug the notebook AC adaptor for a while.. then the TB3 is re-connected (using external screen,kebyoard, headset, so I see all going dark for few seconds), then while notebook runs on battery and recognized again the TB3 (which have it's external power) - I will plug in the original Dell AC adaptor into notebook and all is good.
This is a problem when I start notebook with TB3 connected at boot time.. once I do this disconnect / reconnect AC - just once after the boot, all is then fine.. no throttling due to unsufficient power or due to charging the battery.
I do believe this just need small BIOS update which will always look for directly connected power adaptor in first place, and power over TB as secondary option.
anyone reading this if you have any power how to flag this to Dell support to trigger BIOS fix I would be thankful.
I have the exact same problem but this happens to me when on standard UK mains adapter power or indeed just battery power. Main issue seems to be Power Throttling but both Thermal and Current Throttling are then also flagged by the monitoring software - I'm using Intel XTU.
Strange. I hadn't noticed any issues when I first got the laptop and everything was fine. Recently, I have been unable to play games and also noticed the fans are on all the time whereas they never used to be. So, I stuck HWInfo on and saw the CPU was hitting 98 or so degrees - just using Google Chrome! On installing Intel XTU I have bee able to witness the Power, Thermal and Current throttling kicking in and hence killing the CPU speeds.
I am assuming, then, that either a hardware component has failed - can only really be fans and I can certainly hear them working - or one of the many BIOS updates has caused the issue. I have read that you used to be able to underclock the CPU voltage but this feature has been removed in the later BIOSes. I'm wondering if the actual voltage levels have been changed too and this is what's kicked this off. I should have got on the case earlier I guess as it's been ongoing for months now but never really gad the time to investigate properly.
So, Dell, what have you done that's broken my laptop?? It was great - nice and quiet and great for gaming. Now it can't play games without dropping the quality to MS DOS levels and the fans are always on which is bloody annoying.
The only thing I've seen is to downgrade to a really early BIOS where you could undervolt, but I imagine if I try that it will break something else. So, hoping someone's got some good ideas. It's a real shame as it's put me right off buying another Dell when it's upgrade time.
I have a similar issue as well. I have done everything I could within the laptop. Undervolting, removing speed shift and turboboost and using less cores but it didn't work. Undervolting the GPU to 1500 mhz and the CPU by -100mV lowered my temps to 50-60C when idle and 70-80 when gaming. This surprisingly is not enough though... I still get throttling when I'm gaming even at 70C sometimes...
I don't see why we should have to do things like disabling turbo etc. - that is not what he have paid for. It would be good to be able to undervolt again though as I feel this is the only solution. Look at these temps - these are from just idling with Chrome and Outlook running! 104 degrees!! Shocking.
I have exactly the same problem... just suddenly clocking down to 800 MHz when using the machine heavily, connected to the docking station. I have the power settings sett to Optimized, but using Extreme hasn't helped either. Tried contacting support, running their tests multiple times and no help is given. Had the problem for over a year, and no updating the PC or dock has helped.
Update October 27 = A DELL-Cares agent setup service.
I didn't bother buying additional warranty as all the signs were that nothing would get done. I did disable the turbo boost, just to see, and the machine still runs slow, hot and fans pretty much on max all the time. Total garbage. I'm just going to get a different laptop when the prices/supply have stabilised. It will not be a Dell. Probably a Razer, Asus Zephyrus or Lenovo Legion. Wish I hadn't sold my old Macbook.
Once I have a new machine, that works as advertised, I'll get some screwdrivers, thermal pads etc. and take this heap apart and try and re-paste/pad everything and see if that makes a difference. If it does then at least I can then sell this muck. Don't think I can as it stands. Zero ROI.
I have recently bought dell xps 15 9500 (i7-10750H config)
I also get power throttling no matter what I do in Intel XTU and fans are ALWAYS spinning. Even on no load at all. I do nothing, and fans are spinning which really annoys me. Authorized service replaced the motherboard and both fans - still the same.
- Tried various updates. (windows, dell update center, downgrades) - no help - There is no system cooling policy, minimum/maximum cpu state in the "advanced power settings" in windows. Dell seems to remove that by making some other stupid changes as far as I have understood. - I have enabled cpu max state and placed it to lower value by playing in windows registry - no help - Authorized service replaced motherboard, downgraded bios - no help - Temps are like 40C, and still fans are always on. - Why power throttling when I'm using original adapter?
This laptop was not cheap! will definitely never buy dell again.
That's very interesting and good to know. I nearly shelled out and bought a new warranty but after some research, it seemed pointless as others in the same boat never got the issue resolved. So, you had your motherboard and fans replaced? That means there's no point in me even taking it apart to re-paste as it will achieve nothing. Mind you, if your temps are now down to 40C, that's very impressive! I'm just sitting here with a load of Chrome browser windows open and I'm hitting 70C with around a 5% CPU load! Maybe I still will then.....
It does seem to purely be down to the voltage though and the fact that we can no longer undervolt the CPU. I don't know why Dell/Intel have taken this option from us as it seems to be the only way to sort this issue. My Dell Power settings are on 'Quiet' but my fans are on 100% of the time.
But yeah, I've gone from a pretty quiet gaming laptop to a very noisy 'work' laptop. Can't game on it any more because of the throttling killing performance. Totally mis sold. Maybe I should take legal action but I don't know if I need the hassle. But you're right, it was not cheap. Lesson learned. Don't buy Dell laptops!
Im an owner of the same laptop and i might know what causes the power limit throttling.
I have repasted the laptop, underclocked and undervolted it just to keep temps down. While regular use the laptops cpu is about 40-50 degrees after all the tweaking..
The power throttling started after I started using the 'dell power management' app. Once i selected 'cool' under thermal management, the laptop did everything it could to keep it cool to the touch. If you try selecting 'ultra performance', the problem seems to disappear.
Now, i have niether of the problems..
Sorry if i misspelled some words, English is not my native language
LeeRamos
1 Rookie
•
8 Posts
4580
1
Posted January 24th, 2021 16:00