It is my understanding that you are NOT fully patched till you get a BIOS update which includes a firmware patch from Intel. The patch may include some new processor instructions or modifications to current ones that the patch may need. I also have a 8700 and a 8500. I do not expect that Dell will fix either but they may, who knows?
It does verify that if you do not get a firmware update (new BIOS) then you are NOT protected from Spectre. Meltdown does not need a firmware update but Spectre does so it's up to Dell whether they want to leave all of us with Haswell and lower CPUs out in the cold. So for XPS boxes it's 8700 and lower who are not protected.
I'm trying to wrap my head around how many facets there are to this, including:
The Dells, Lenovos and other mainstream PC mfrs of the world have a field-day with orders for new PCs because someone's PC is just 2 (or more) years old.
Mainstream home users do not bother to upgrade their PC (which feels like it's working fine) and exploits spread like wildfire.
, but makes out like a bandit, because they have to mfr all those new chips for the uptick in PC sales due to their own bug.
In the meantime, we XPS 8700 owners (amongst many others) are left out in the cold with some otherwise great hardware that is vulnerable to major hacks.
Let's hope the main AntiVirus vendors stay on top of any exploits and we use that as a crutch until a resolution is found (or we save up the money to replace all our machines)!
There are two security issues, Meltdown and Spectre. Meltdown is fixed by updating the OS. Spectre requires microcode updates which means firmware and a BIOS update. If these security issues could be resolved through anti-virus updates I would think that would have happened before resorting to the path that is being taken. The only reason anti-virus programs are being updated as a result of these security issues is because the changes the OS can cause some anti-virus programs to lock up the computer.
No security issues are "resolved" via antivirus updates. The AV simply prevents attack-vectors from executing on your machine and exploiting known security holes.
I am aware of the two point of patching required. The point about keeping your AV up-to-date is to mitigate/prevent those attacks from getting on your PC in the first place (as always).
Your PC won't wake up one day and start side channel attacks on you. You (or someone with access to your PC) will have to download malicious code and execute it in one of the "usual" ways like a phishing link, website download, etc. A decent antivirus program will hopefully go a long way in preventing that from happening (minus true, zero-day exploits).
Having Dell actually update the XPS's BIOS/microcode would be the optimal solution. My point was that a good AV program may help you get by, but is certainly sub-optimal.
Intel, Microsoft, and others have known about and have been working on the solution for Meltdown and Spectre for several months before it became widely known. If an AV program change was effective you would think that would have happened and we would not be taking performance hits and all the other actions to mitigate/prevent this problem which certainly does not seem to be an optimal solution. An AV solution may still be out there, but given what the experts have done to date makes me think that solution is not currently viable. This means there will be millions of computers that are vulnerable because there will be no updates for older systems.
I think we're getting off-topic, but which of the known exploits of "Spectre" has gotten past any of the major AV vendors making you think they're ineffective?
The main reason any AV approach is sub-optimal is that it's almost always "reactive" to an exploit. Patching security holes in source is always preferable, because it removes the opportunity in the first place and prevents zero day effects.
In any event, I think we mostly agree on your last sentence.
I certainly agree that almost always AV programs are reactive to exploits. As far as I have read there are no known (or at least detected) exploits of Meltdown or Spectre in the wild. The only reason I think AV programs are ineffective is because I don't see Intel, Microsoft, or Linux saying let's just like the AV programs block these exploits. I certainly wish it was as simple as updating AV programs.
2-J
84 Posts
5773
0
Posted January 12th, 2018 11:00
Same reason my XPS 8000 ain't getting an update. Too old.