UNSOLVED

DavidNS92

updated

10 years ago

D

DavidNS92

14 Posts

0

2970

August 3rd, 2016 11:00

What's the best way to partition a laptop with a single 500 GB hard drive and a 32 GB mSATA card?

Hello,

A little backstory first. I had resisted the temptation to upgrade my Dell Inspiron 15z 5523 to Windows 10 for a long time, up until about a week ago, when a banner just showed up in the middle of my screen announcing that the free upgrade period was about to end. I gave in and finally did it. I hadn't done it before because I know that upgrading to a new version of an OS without doing a clean install may cause some problems. And sure enough, problems came along, mostly WiFi related. I thought they would get fixed as Windows Update worked behind the scenes. Nope. Then, boot up started taking more time than usual, so I guessed I might as well back up all relevant files and perform a clean Windows 10 install. But things only got worse, after turning off the laptop and trying to turn it back on to start the clean install, I was greeted with a black screen (it didn't even turn on) and 3 beeps, meaning that during the POST, the BIOS detected a motherboard malfunction. Great, now it's a hardware problem and I'm out of warranty, or that's what I thought. After doing some research, I found that this "Inspiron 15z 5523 Black Screen 3 beeps after Windows 10 upgrade" problem was far from being an isolated case, and that some people had managed to fix it by reflashing the BIOS. I did it, and it's back on again, seemingly unharmed, running on Windows 8.1 after I reverted back to it. But I'd feel better knowing that I'm running my laptop on a cleanly installed OS instead of a downgraded-after-being-upgraded one.

I'm currently downloading all the necessary drivers (my laptop didn't come with a recovery disk and I never made one). But before I install Windows 8.1, I'd like to know what would be the best way to set up the partitions on my hard drive. How many should I create? One for the OS, one for programs, one for the page file and temporary files, one for data and one recovery partition? What about the size of each partition? I don't really know, I'm the opposite of an expert on this subject.

Oh, the relevant specs: my laptop has a 500 GB, SATA II, 5400 rpm Seagate hard drive, and a 32 GB mSATA card that works as a cache for the main drive using Intel Smart Response Technology. It also has 8 GB of DDR3 RAM memory.

Also, is it alright to format just the main drive during the partitioning part of the OS installation? Or should I execute the Diskpart Clean (or Clean All) command both on the main drive and the mSATA card before starting the OS installation?

I'd really appreciate it if you could give me your opinions on the matter.

  • ejn63

    11 Legend

    •

    87469 Posts

    •

    321256 Points

    2039

    0

    Posted August 3rd, 2016 11:00

    First:  make your backup media -- it's the only way you can reload 8.1 in case of a hard drive failure.  Installing 8.1 from any other Windows media won't pick up the embedded license key.

    If you are partitioning and reloading, you'll lose the Intel caching driver and need to set that up again once you've recovered the system or reloaded the OS.  

    You can partition the drive as you would like.  It's really your choice -- there is no single best way.

  • DavidNS92

    14 Posts

    2039

    0

    Posted August 3rd, 2016 17:00

    Thank you for your quick response, I'll definitely make a backup media, and I've already downloaded the IRST driver.

    However, while I'm aware that maybe I chose the wrong phrasing for the question (since partitioning schemes are particular to the needs and resources of each user), I thought there were at least some best practices (?) or guidelines that may hold some value.

    For example, I've read in some forums that, when formatting an OS hard drive, it is advisable to set the first partition so that it only holds the OS and programs, that way the data will be fixed on the outer edge of the hard drive, where the linear speeds are greater, instead of leaving it to Windows defragmentation tool, or any other third-party software decide where they should be allocated. That's just one of the many guidelines I've read, but since I'm no expert, I thought it was better to ask about what would be the optimal (perhaps no the right word) way to format and partition my system. Specially taking into account that my laptop has a 32 GB mSATA card, I haven't seen I case like that being discussed in any of the forums I've visited.

  • ejn63

    11 Legend

    •

    87469 Posts

    •

    321256 Points

    2039

    1

    Posted August 4th, 2016 05:00

    It's true that having a separate data partition will allow you to reload the OS without wiping out that data, but whether that's much of an advantage these days is open to question - you still need to keep backups of your data files somewhere off the hard drive (on an external flash or hard drive, in the cloud, etc.) - and you really can't reload without a current backup.  There's always the chance the install will go wrong - and of course, there are two types of drives:  those that have failed and those that will fail.

    The mSATA card holds no real data other than a rapid start partition and temporary cache files - the data is still stored on the hard drive.

    If you don't need an enormous amount of storage, ditching both the mSATA drive and the hard drive in favor of a native solid state drive will dramatically improve the system's performance - and 512G and under flash drives are quite reasonably priced now (one reason it's becoming harder and harder to find hard drives at or below that capacity level).

  • DavidNS92

    14 Posts

    2039

    0

    Posted August 4th, 2016 14:00

    I agree with you. Addressing the last paragraph of your response: for the time being, I can't afford a SSD. I don't even have an external HDD. So, as you pointed out, I've chosen to keep a backup of my files on the cloud.

    If multi-partitioning the HDD does not translate into a somewhat perceivable performance boost (as suggested by those who favor placing the OS and pagefile partitions on the outer edge of the platter to maximize DTR, prevent partitioning or reallocation of the files on the inner edge), combined with the minor (but unfamiliar to me) tweaks to change the location of the pagefile and temp files, Users directory, etc., that would need to be made, are probably going to sway me into just formatting the HDD with one large partition.