UNSOLVED

Mike Curtis

updated

22 years ago

0

28888

March 11th, 2004 13:00

Teac DV-W58E burns slowly-solutions?

I have a Dimension XPS with the Teac DV-W58E DVD/CD combo drive.  I could not get the drive and Sonic Record Now to burn a DVD+R.  The DVD was either unreadable or the computer would crash.  I finally uninstalled the Sonic software and installed Easy CD Creator 6.0 Platinum.  I was able to burn a DVD+R using Verbatim 4X media but only at 2X speed.  Shouldn't 2.4X and 4X be options?  The drive should burn faster.  I have a Sony 510 external USB that hooked up and it will at least burn at 2.4X using the Verbatim DVD+R 4X media.  I think the Teac drive is not performing as advertised.  I have emailed Dell and asked for a replacement that will perform and not necessarily another Teac.  If a firmware upgrade will solve the problem I would go for that. 
  • 1015

    0

    Posted March 11th, 2004 17:00

    I am in EXACTLY the same situation.  Device burns (on various media) at 2.4x --- this is unacceptable.  We paid for an 8x device.  Can you please post the contact information (email, phone number, etc) for those of us in the same situation.  Maybe if enough people gripe something will actually get done about this.
  • 1015

    0

    Posted March 11th, 2004 19:00

    I just contacted Dell Technical Support by email.  This is the address: us_support@dell.com.  I used Dell's Technical Support Form after logging in to the Dell Site.  Another thing that I was going to check was to see if the burner is a master on the IDE controller or a slave.  In the past all of my burners have been a master.  I don't know if that would slow things down but I will check to see how Dell has it configured.

     

    Mike

  • shayky

    3 Posts

    1015

    0

    Posted March 11th, 2004 21:00

    See below for the (comical) response I received after CLEARLY stating that I'd tried all the "usual suspects" to fix the problem.  Why did I bother?  I did write back saying "AS I STATED EARLIER...etc."  I'll let everyone know the response I get.  I used to brag to everyone about Dell's customer service (this is my second purchase.)  I hope I don't change teams.  Again, Dell's response is directly below with my original inquiry following (backward.)

    ---------------------------

    Dear Shay,

    Thank you for contacting Dell Technical Support.

    Shay, as per your mail what I understand that you have a 8x TEAC

    DVD+RW drive but writes only at 2x speed.

    Follow the below steps which I am sure will resolve your issue.

    * Try a different brand of media.

    * Make sure media is clean and free of scratches.

    * Media varies greatly in the market. Media from different manufacturers,

    purchased at different times, will record at different speeds.

    The drive will adjust the available recording speeds to make

    the best possible recording.

    Have a Nice Day!

    Respectfully,

    Robert

    ID : 430842

    My Work Schedule : 1400 - 2330 CST (Monday - Saturday)

    If you need to reply to us, please use the REPLY function of

    your email program. This will keep the SAME SUBJECT of the response,

    ensuring quicker service.

    * * * * * * * * * * *

    Visit the Dell Community Forum where you can find answers to

    questions and exchange information with other Dell users:

    http://forums.us.dell.com/supportforums/

    * * * * * * * * * * * *

    Visit the Dell Knowledge Base to get answers:

    http://support.dell.com/us/en/kb/index.asp

    * * * * * * * * * * * *

    To submit a different question, visit the Communications Center

    at:

    http://support.dell.com/contactus/contactushome.aspx

    * * * * * * * * * * * *

    To provide feedback about this email message

    http://emarketing.us.dell.com/Apps/DCS/mcp?q=ST5m0FTFME6pqO

    > -----Original Message-----

    > From: shay-XXXXXXXXXX.com

    > Sent: 11 Mar 04 14:53

    > To: xEXL_HSBDesktopSupport@dell.com

    >

    > * * * PLEASE DO NOT CHANGE THE SUBJECT WHEN REPLYING * * *

    > *** This is a feedback Message from the Dell Online Communications

    > Problem: Other/Don't Know

    > Operating System: Windows XP

    > Problem Description:

    > My TEAC DVD+RW DV-W58E drive claims to be an 8X drive, but appears to

    > only write at 2X (maybe 2.4X.) I've noticed on the forums this is a

    > common problem with this device and no firmware update is currently

    > available.

    > I've tried different brands of media (all rated at least 4X, some at 8X)

    > with the same results. I've also updated all Microsoft software and

    > checked Dell and TEAC's web-site for a firmware upgrade. I've tried

    > different burning software with the same (slow) results. CD-Rs burn

    > fine.

  • 1015

    0

    Posted March 11th, 2004 21:00

    All the problems I have had with DVD burners have been due to software or firmware issues.  I have never had media be the problem, assuming you are using media that the manufacturer has tested and is compatible.  I wouldn't use an off brand or media that is really inexpensive.  I have used Fuji, Sony, Verbatim, Maxell without any problems.  Sounds like a canned response to me and also sounds like they also don't know want the problem is or do know and haven't come up with a solution yet.  I would bet a firmware update would fix the problem.  Hopefully it will be addressed asap.

    This is also my second purchase.  I own an Inspiron 5100 laptop.  I think Dell products are great but you also need good service and time will tell if we get good service.

  • Popeofsteel

    14 Posts

    1015

    0

    Posted March 12th, 2004 02:00

    There are many of us with this problem.  Check out the thread on the next page titled 'Burning with 8x on TEAC DV W58E' This will really blow your mind once you start trying to use 8x media and expect it to work! My next step is to write to Dells Board of Directors as well as their Senior Managers.I also plan on filing a complaint with the Attorney Generals Office

  • 1013

    0

    Posted March 12th, 2004 23:00

    Below you will find my response to the Dell support team's pathetic attempt at brushing me aside with a redirection to some lame help page:
    How friggin' lame is it that after THREE email volleys Dell cannot directly address the issue at hand. I am appalled.





    This canned response to a very specific complaint is unacceptable. I have provided extremely specific detail in attempting to explain to you my problem, and have cited specific forum threads indicative of the same problem, to which you have failed to acknowledge or address.

    This matter will not simply go away with redirecting "ignorant" users to a generic help page. I am a software engineer and have been dealing with computer problems, both hardware and software, for more than TWENTY YEARS. I was using computers before most people knew what a computer was. As such, I take somewhat offense to being redirected to a catch-all help page. I can troubleshoot far beyond this, rest assured, thank you very much.

    I will be posting this and any further correspondence in related threads on the Dell support site and others, until this matter is addressed to the satisfaction of myself and others with this particular device and associated issues.

    Please read my original message more thoroughly and address the issue at hand. Once again, I implore Dell to respond to this issue publicly, in a given thread or forum visible to those with this hardware. The spin this issue is generating is not flattering, and will likely not subside or be reversed until and unless Dell directly acknowledges this issue.

    Thank you for your understanding in this matter, and I hope to see this issue addressed visibly, soon.

    Respectfully,

    xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx




    -----Original Message-----
    From: support@dell.com [mailto:support@dell.com]
    Sent: Friday, March 12, 2004 1:36 PM
    To: xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx@hotmail.com
    Subject: RE: AT20040312_0000002252 ~xEX~ TEAC DV-58E ---- SERVICE TAG xxxxxxxxxxxxx


    Please include the following line in all replies.
    Tracking number: AT20040312_0000002252


    Dear xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx,

    Please accept my apologies for the difficulties you encountered with your technical issues. I assure you that your situation is not indicative of the quality service Dell is capable of providing. I sincerely appreciate your taking the time to share your experience with us. Your comments are very important to us and will assist in making improvements.

    Once again, I thank you for sharing your experience with us. Whether the feedback we receive is positive or negative, it remains a crucial tool for determining how we can best improve our products and services. I truly regret any inconvenience or frustration this matter may have caused. We value you as our customer and your satisfaction is very important to us.

    To resolve this issue I am sending you the web page which contains the steps you have to perform on your system. To open the web page follow below steps.

    The steps are:
    1. Go to http://support.dell.com/
    2. Click Home and Home Office
    3. Copy and paste the below link to your internet browser address bar(eg. internet explorer
    or netscape)

    http://support.dell.com/us/en/kb/document.asp?dn=1020573

    Thank you for choosing Dell. Have a Nice Day!

    Respectfully,
    Ned
    430840
    Dell e-Support and Services

    My schedule are 0430 to 1400 hours CST, Monday to Friday
    Dell Email Support operates 24/7, and if your reply is received while I am not in, to ensure a speedy resolution of your problem, your issue would be handled by one of my colleagues.
    * * * * * * * * * * * *

    Visit the Dell Community Forum where you can find answers to questions and exchange information with other Dell users: http://forums.us.dell.com/supportforums/


    To provide feedback about this email message http://emarketing.us.dell.com/Apps/DCS/mcp?q=ST5m0FTFME6pqO
  • sunrisepmm

    10 Posts

    1013

    0

    Posted March 15th, 2004 05:00

    Take a look in my new post  (Monday 15th March)  in the forum "TEAC DV-W58E - The Truth about 8x burning"
  • 1013

    0

    Posted March 16th, 2004 16:00

    Shocker.  A posted reply describing how an earlier reply in the
    "Teac DV-W58E burns slowly-solutions?" thread was deleted, has itself been deleted.  I suspect THIS post will be deleted as well.

    There's some Orwellian moderating taking place, rather ironic in itself in as much as Dell has refused to answer or even acknowledge multiple emails to Dell Support as well as numerous pointed questions in this and other threads.

    Sunrisepmm's post about the DV-W58E was helpful and informative, far more so than Dell has been regarding this device.

    Dell would do well to take note of their customers' dissatisfaction and the negative spin which has been generated from their failure to respond, either privately or publicly.  I have long been a fan of Dell machines, but the turn of events in the past weeks relating to the poor handling of what should have and easily could have been a trivial issue, has put me off to the point I doubt I would ever make another Dell purchase again.  And that is a shame.

  • Troll_01

    17 Posts

    1013

    0

    Posted March 18th, 2004 10:00

    Hi all,

    I have the same problem with my burner. I got the same standard responses from the Dell support (in Germany). After they kept me busy for some time with trying everything they suggested, I got the burner replaced. The new device is as slow as the first one. Now I was told to wait another couple of weeks until a firmware update was available. All concerned users would then be notified. I wonder, if and when this will happen ...

    In my opinion the firmware is buggy. If you read the drive's capabilities with "DVD-Identifier", a nice freeware tool, you get some incorrect entries. Maybe the W58E is in fact a W58GK (+/-) in which the minus option was supressed and some write speed entries have been mixed up?

    I will wait some time and then try to get a burner of another brand or some money back to buy a really good one.

    Troll

     

  • Popeofsteel

    14 Posts

    506

    0

    Posted April 14th, 2004 17:00

    see Teac DVD+RW DVW58E problem