UNSOLVED

sjryan

updated

22 years ago

S

sjryan

16 Posts

0

2916

April 29th, 2005 13:00

Roxio DirectCD vs Sonic DLA - which is better?

Been thinking of adding functionality with Roxio 7.5. Forum wisdom says DLA should be uninstalled to avoid conflicts. Some comments hint that DirectCD is better or more powerful. Any suggestions on which way to go? Thx.
  • Skybird

    1 Rookie

    •

    10871 Posts

    498

    0

    Posted April 29th, 2005 14:00

    DirectCD is Drag-to-Disk in ROXIO 7.  It is less troublesome that DLA.  DLA
    has proven to be troublesome with some existing programs.  The two are not
    compatible with each other.   
     
    That said, both are packet writing software and packet writing is not the most
    reliable method of storing data.  It will serve well for temporary storage and
    for mobility of data.  However, for long term storage and back-ups, packet
    writing should not be trusted.
  • cougar_ii

    66 Posts

    498

    0

    Posted April 29th, 2005 14:00

    Hi there,

    Father in law uses Roxio DirectCD and has no problems with Nero and other burning software.

    Never used Sonic DLA so I can't comment on it, other than what I have read in forums, and it seems to cause some problems with other software, and turning DLA off seems to have help a lot of people.

    My 2 cents...

  • osprey4

    6 Operator

    •

    34230 Posts

    498

    0

    Posted April 30th, 2005 00:00

    All packet writing programs, while convenient, have inherent hardware gliches and incompatibility issues. I strongly advise not using them. Save your files to a specific folder on your hard drive and maintain regular backups. Even the Windows CD burning wizard can do multi-session burning.

    For portability, use a flash drive rather than a CD.

  • Jim Hardin

    2 Intern

    •

    2053 Posts

    498

    0

    Posted April 30th, 2005 09:00

    Just to keep things confused, I am going to side with DLA…

    My experience with DLA is limited but I find it is compatible with DCD & D2D provided DLA is used to format the media. If DCD or D2D is used to format, the media is not interchangeable.

    I believe that V7.5 will be the last Roxio to use D2D. I expect the next version will drop D2D and use DLA. Remember Sonic bought Roxio and the products are merging.

    Some have had trouble with DLA installed and games, but keep in mind, some games will not run if DVD burning software is installed. The copy protection scheme in the game is the problem, not the burning software!

    That said, I still think the only legitimate use for a packet writer is portability of files between PCs where no other means of transfer exists!
  • sjryan

    16 Posts

    498

    0

    Posted April 30th, 2005 10:00

    Even with different points of view this is a very helpful discussion. I do use flash for high use files needing portability. I have used DLA and DCD (different systems) and have discovered incompatibilities. The Roxio/Sonic merger got me thinking about how to handle archives and I may need to reconsider my archiving strategy and start using HD backup. I do have a USB HD I can use. What software/process do folks use for synching their backups?
  • Jim Hardin

    2 Intern

    •

    2053 Posts

    498

    0

    Posted April 30th, 2005 11:00



    @sjryan wrote:
    Even with different points of view this is a very helpful discussion. I do use flash for high use files needing portability. I have used DLA and DCD (different systems) and have discovered incompatibilities. The Roxio/Sonic merger got me thinking about how to handle archives and I may need to reconsider my archiving strategy and start using HD backup. I do have a USB HD I can use. What software/process do folks use for synching their backups?


    The V7.5 Suite includes Sonic's BackUp MyPC Deluxe program. That is a $100 program (on sale for $70 this month) if bought separately. I have had good results using it with an external HD.

    Some like Norton… I tried it for 1 day and the best result I had was putting the CD in my Microwave, High Power – 1 Second! There were a constant stream of messages, "I can't, I won't, There were errors, etc."

    Sonic worked first time right out of the box and across my network of 4 PCs. Recovery works too.

    I am not concerned with full disaster recovery so that area was never explorered.