In November, I posted a message regarding this DVD burner not recognizing DVD+R discs (I've tried Maxell DVD+R and Memorex 8x DVD+R with no success). After having the drive replaced, updating the firmware, and over 8 hours of technical support (with no solution!!!) the technicians are insisting that it's a software issue with Sonic RecordNow!. Well, that would be fine, except that I'm running two other programs as well and still have the same problem. I've given up on tech support for now. After 3 promised call backs, and not receiving a single one, along with an attempt to sell me a $170 + replacement, I'm more than disgusted. Anyway, on a whim, I grabbed some Maxell 4x DVD-R discs, and viola! They work like a charm! My question is: Has anybody with this drive had successful burns with DVD+R, DVD+RW, and DVD+R DL media? Could this problem possibly be fixed with a future firmware release? I'm seriously considering cutting my losses and buying an NEC from NewEgg.com. Also, has anybody found a means to submit a complaint to Dell that actually generates results? Call customer care and they transfer you to technical support, and vice versa. All I really want is a drive that actually accepts the media that Dell claims it is compatible with. Soooooo frustrating.
As always, thanks for any information you can provide. You people are tremendously helpful and very much appreciated.
I don't have answer, just an experience and I bekieve the problem is the Philips brand in itself. Depending on the customer (based on some of the posts I've seen, there's either a problem with the drive seeing either a +r or a -R. And I believe it's across model lines.
You may want to insert the blank -R in the drive and close the drive
before you start whatever software you're using and see if that makes a difference.
If you're interested in an experience with Philips:
I had a Phillips 6831 (if I remember the model correctly) which didn't see -R's which it was supposed to as well as to +R. The firmware update did not help. I did (after a few back and forth emails and telling tech support I did what they suggested to no avail) ) get it replaced but got an 8631 instead of a replacement 6831 about 2 weeks ago. My new 8631 does see and write to both +R and -R (haven't tried double layer -- too expensive and might get a coaster) nor have I tried RW + or -. I have not upgraded the firmware from what it was when it was installed. I have used TDK 8X and FujiFilm 8X +R's with no coasters.
I never used the Sonic software -- only Nero 6.6 and now no problem burning to either - or + with the 8631. However, the finalized -R's don't work in my Toshiba standalone DVD player but do on other DVD player brands. I have to use +R's for my Toshiba. I know it's the 8631 because on a different pc (using Nero 6.6) I had a MicroAdvantage 4x DVDRW+- and finalized -R's worked on the Toshiba.
I had the same problem with my 8631. Contact Dell ASAP and get them to send you a replacement. My 8631 would not read Colin Mcrae Rally 2005 (PC-DVD based game). Ask them to send you a replacement (call cusomter care, dont let them transfer you to tech support). If they say no, we dont send replacements, demand a hardware buy-back from them. This is normally for people that have bought their system within the past 21 says, but if you are persistent enough (i was) they will give. Furthermore, Dell knows there is a problem with this drive and is still putting it in their new systems because they get it cheaper than other DVD burners. What they will do is probably credit your original credit card for a reasonable amount. They also send UPS to come pick it up and they pay for the shipping.
They gave me a $135 credit for my DVD-ROM drive (that was also messing up) and the 8631. Order the NEC-3500A instead, one of the best 16X DVD-RW out there. I also ordered a Lite-On DVD-Rom/CD-RW combo because my computer came with 2 drives. Came out to like $115 on Dell's site with free shipping. They also gave me a $50 gift certificate for the hassle.
Main point, don't let them push you around. If you get a CSR that can barely speak English, ask for a transfer to one that speaks English and then email/call DELL to complain after the conversation. I'm not going to repeat everything I say 4X just because Dell is trying to save an extra $/hr on labor.
Good luck and keep us updated. If enough of us send these things back, maybe they will stop putting them in computers.
The Philips 8631 has been plagued with problems. Most complaints have involved not being able to burn DVD-R discs. Sort of strange you are having difficulties with DVD+R discs. I agree your best solution would be to get a new drive, preferably a different brand. I have a Philips 8631 myself that had to be replaced because it wouldn't recognize almost every disc put in it. Dell replaced it with the same model number, and so far it has worked okay with all types of discs using the old firmware. I'm using Nero 6.6 and Roxio Creator 6 software for burning. The only problem I am having with the Philips now is that it won't make a DVD-R disc that will load on my Denon 2900 DVD player for some reason, but they work fine on my other three players. But DVD-R discs burned on my Plextor 708A will work on all my DVD players including the Denon.
After reading all the problems on the forum and having many of the same myself with the Phillips burner I have come to a conclusion. Because of the problems with Phillips and they and Dell know this and so far Phillips has not done anything about it I think this will cost them more then replacements or fixing the problems with this drive.
For example: I just saw a great buy on a Phillips product and turned it down. I don't want anything to do with any product with the Phillips name on it from now on. I wonder if Phillips realizes how many sales they are losing on other products just from Happy Dell customers except for the burners.
shaboz
21 Posts
390
0
Posted December 14th, 2004 19:00