UNSOLVED

Jon_omni

updated

19 years ago

J

Jon_omni

21 Posts

0

10592

March 4th, 2008 20:00

PowerEdge 2900 Additional Drives

I'm looking to purchase a couple of new HDDs for my system.  The current drive is a 15K 500GB SAS drive.  I do not want to pay the rediculous price Dell wants for a 7.2K 500GB SATA drive ($400 - are they crazy?).  I was wondering if anyone knew where I might be able to procure drive carriers.  And I belive I would need some sort of SATA to SAS converter?

Any help would be appreciated, I called Dell and they said I'd have to purchase the drive and assembly together.  I just cant justify spending $400 on something I can get for $100 on Newegg.

Thanks in advance!
  • warwizard55

    720 Posts

    313

    0

    Posted March 5th, 2008 21:00

    Hi Jon_omni,

     

      If you have a RAID array planned you'll not want to mix the SAS and SATA drives in the array. WWW.dell.com shows in their online customize it for the PE2900 that you cannot mix the types when doing RAID configurations.

     

      Sorry I'm not answering your question, it's one of cost and warranty coverage. I just put together a XPS720 from spare and new parts I bought from DELL, I'll have only 3 months to 1 year of coverage cause the parts were not installed into a system with a warranty. For a in warranty SERVER, buying the drive from dell places the drive under the DELL system warranty for the full remaining time of the system warranty or the parts warranty whichever is longer.

    This includes any warranty extensions you may buy in the future. I'd say that there could be some value to that if the server is to be used in a business critical role, especially if you have a 4 Hr (mission critical) warranty.

     

      For example a drive bought directly from the maker will carry a warranty for a number of years, however it's a send in the drive and when they get it they'll send you a replacement by 3rd day shipping. If you have the Dell 4 Hr warranty coverage, you'll be quite likely to have the replacement in 2-4 hours.

     

    Regards,

    warwizard

  • Jon_omni

    21 Posts

    313

    0

    Posted March 6th, 2008 12:00

    I spoke with a Dell rep yesterday and they said that I could not mix SATA and SAS.  I've read plenty of other places that you could, just not in a RAID environment.  I do not plan to setup any sort of RAID.  Are they just trying to get me to purchase an expensive SAS drive?  Or can you really not mix the two?

  • warwizard55

    720 Posts

    313

    0

    Posted March 6th, 2008 20:00

     Hi Jon_Omni,

     

     Well, your best chance is if you have them on different channel, Dell used to offer a mixed configuration with SATA and SAS drives using the optional 1x2 bay for one type and the main bay for the other. Later they stopped offering that configuration option. I suspect it was due to RAID arrays and hot spare drives rebuilding into an array with the other drive type, but that's just speculation, they could have discovered issues.

     

      Personally, I would not mix the drives on the same bus. I'd assume the bus will slow down to the lowest speed device.

    While that's a far cry from a you CAN'T, it should be considered a you should not. I'd advise reviewing the SATA and SAS specifications, there might indeed be a you can't lurking in there.

     

    Regards,

    warwizard

  • Jon_omni

    21 Posts

    313

    0

    Posted March 6th, 2008 21:00

    Thanks for the info, we're just going to end up going for another SAS drive in about a month or two.

  • Dev Mgr

    6 Operator

    •

    9308 Posts

    •

    3 Points

    313

    0

    Posted March 7th, 2008 13:00

    As a little side note for your opening post, there are no 500GB 15k rpm SAS drives. 10k goes up to 400GB and 15k goes only up to 300GB at this time. So you have either 500GB 7200 SATA drives, or they are not 500GB.

    Seagate did just announce their 6th gen 15k drives which will go up to 450GB (see here).
  • Jon_omni

    21 Posts

    313

    0

    Posted March 7th, 2008 18:00

    Yeah, sorry about that.  I was thinking about the 500GB I wanted to bye when I was talking about my 300GB SAS drive.  :)

  • 313

    0

    Posted March 14th, 2008 05:00

    I have (2) SAS/SATAu carriers that I bought and need to return.  PM me asap.

     

    I also have an unused Flex Bay assy. w/ cables.

    Message Edited by incognito_user on 03-14-2008 02:03 AM