UNSOLVED

night_2004

updated

19 years ago

N

night_2004

1 Rookie

•

41 Posts

0

18801

May 27th, 2007 03:00

So what's the deal with the 2407 and poor HDCP implementation?

So I'm thinking about getting one of these monitor to double as a HDTV and computer monitor, but I'm hearing there are a lot of problems.  What's going on to fix them?  So far, this is what I gather are the current issues with the A04 monitor...
 
1) 1080i is really bad via component inputs.
2) 1080i is not supported via DVI, so 1080i-HDCP is impossible.
3) 1080p-HDCP is not supported via DVI (downscales to 720p?).
 
I'm also worried that the monitor, even though it says is HDCP compatible, will not have working HDCP with a PC GPU that supports HDCP.  In other words, I think the 2407WFP will not have an HDCP protected display at 1920x1200 even though all parts would support HDCP...
 
It seems like to me that the 2407WFP isn't really HDCP compliant after all, and is the one major thing holding me back from this monitor.  Because if my next computer has an HDCP compliant GPU, comes with a high-definition format drive, and I cannot play movies on my 1920x1200 desktop because HDCP is bad...
 
So, I know/think that the 2407-HC monitor is coming up soon, and I'm wondering if any of the above issues will actually get fixed.  Apparently, BenQ is going to soon release a 24" monitor that is fully-HDCP compatible for 1080p resolutions...which leads me to believe that the next 24" from Dell would also have that capability.  Can anyone comment?
  • hdtv00

    1 Rookie

    •

    56 Posts

    417

    0

    Posted May 27th, 2007 06:00

    Well if you're using it with a pc it'll be a non issue anyway. But I don't believe #3 to be true. Far as I can tell 1080p does work via DVI. But really it's a little hard to tell with the state of the  software for playing such a thing back. The software ANY HDDVD will make it completely meaningless anyway so...
  • night_2004

    1 Rookie

    •

    41 Posts

    417

    0

    Posted May 27th, 2007 07:00

    What do you mean a non-issue?  In that GPUs check for HDCP in a way that doesn't screw up with the 2407?
     
    I was reading on how a few standalone players give the monitor issues with 1080P, so I wanted to be sure...
  • hdtv00

    1 Rookie

    •

    56 Posts

    417

    0

    Posted May 27th, 2007 17:00

    I meant non issue because if you're using a pc for hd-dvd or blu ray whichever the case may be , that using ANY HD DVD program it completely removes hdcp from the signal therefore not requiring any component in the chain to actually be hdcp compliant.
     
    As for non pc devices it's my understanding its on a device by device basis if said device uses the EDID info instead of just letting hdcp pass then there is a chance it'll fail. But the 2407's are hdcp compliant its just some devices do the process in a slightly different way.
     
    But if you use a pc for playback of the formats that anyhdvd program completely removes hdcp making the whole hdcp thing pointless.
     
    Here read this over it probably explains some of it way better than I did.
  • DELL-Chris M

    Community Manager

    •

    56891 Posts

    •

    232143 Points

    417

    0

    Posted May 27th, 2007 18:00

    night_2004,

    hdtv00 is correct. The 2407WFP/HC supports the following modes through DVI -

    DVI = 480p, 576p, 720p, 1080p RGB only, not Y,Pb,Pr (the edoc is incorrect)
    HDMI to DVI = 480p, 720p

    Of course, it all depends on the device sending the signal to the monitor.


    DELL-Chris M (old account)

    #IWork4Dell

  • hdtv00

    1 Rookie

    •

    56 Posts

    417

    0

    Posted May 28th, 2007 00:00

    I see that mentioned before about hdmi to DVI and no 1080p, you sure, on the PS3 I can't detect any downsample going on when I was using my hdmi to dvi cord. Everything looked pretty sweet to me, unless its a HDCP issue and it can't accept 1080p when its hdmi to dvi hdcp'ed but can accpet normal 1080p not hdcp'ed. You follow that...lol.
     
    Picture and everything seemed fine to me , the only real issue I had with the 2407 with PS3 use was the darn stretching it did because it 2407(A03) can't 1:1 pixel map. Other than that issue it was great. I however didn't have a blu ray disc to test. I use the HTPC for that which of course 2407 is hooked to but when connected to a pc it doesn't matter like I mention in my previous post. But having a PS3 now and soon 360 I'll be begging for chrisM to issue me an exchange...hear me chrisM, hehe.
  • night_2004

    1 Rookie

    •

    41 Posts

    417

    0

    Posted May 28th, 2007 01:00

    Chris, You mention the 2407HC in that post...what about the 2407WFP (non-HC)? Are those resolutions that you listed applicable to it as well? If I may ask, what are the differences between the 2407 and the 2407HC? Aside from a better color gamut...? Have they fixed some issues from the original 2407s? What about connecting in to a computer though? The display will be HDCP-ed at 1920x1200 when connected to a PC that is HDCP right? I'm still trying to decide to get the 2407 now, or wait until the 2407HC is available. So this info is really important.

    Message Edited by night_2004 on 05-27-2007 09:14 PM
  • DELL-Chris M

    Community Manager

    •

    56891 Posts

    •

    232143 Points

    417

    0

    Posted May 28th, 2007 02:00

    night_2004,

    what are the differences between the 2407 and the 2407HC? Aside from a better color gamut...?
    * Brightness/Luminence 2407WFP 450, 2407WFP-HC 400
    Color gamut 2407WFP 78, 2407WFP-HC 92
    Everything else is identical.

    Have they fixed some issues from the original 2407s?
    * An A04 2407WFP is like the first 2407WFP-HC, so yes.

    What about connecting in to a computer though? The display will be HDCP-ed at 1920x1200 when connected to a PC that is HDCP right?
    * In theory, yes.

    Message Edited by DELL-ChrisM on 05-27-2007 10:59 PM


    DELL-Chris M (old account)

    #IWork4Dell

  • netjack

    3 Posts

    417

    0

    Posted June 12th, 2007 13:00

    Chris, How much longer do we have to wait before we can order the 2407HC? I've been waiting since March. They keep saying it's coming out. It's been 3.5 months. What's the holdup?
  • DELL-Chris M

    Community Manager

    •

    56891 Posts

    •

    232143 Points

    417

    0

    Posted June 12th, 2007 14:00

    netjack,

    I have no idea.


    DELL-Chris M (old account)

    #IWork4Dell