UNSOLVED

rubyxc7

updated

19 years ago

Closed

R

rubyxc7

6 Posts

0

7433

February 14th, 2008 20:00

XPS m1330 Optical Drive Problems

This is more of a compatability issue than a problem but it's still bothersome. If the moderators or anyone has advice on what I should do, I'd very much appreciate it.

 

I bought an XPSm1330 a couple weeks back and it was a pretty sweet little machine until I stress tested it with the Half-Life2 Video Stress test and then with 3DMark03. I found out I had an overheating problem and using some temperature monitor programs surely enough I had my proof. I told Dell and they sent me a new computer. Nice. The replacement computer ran great, stress tested it to no end and it worked fine, no more overheating. However when I placed in my CD's they refused to be read. So, I told Dell, they had a tech replace the drive and then, nothing still didn't read my CD's. Whats so special about my CDs? They are Memorex Black CD-R's. Nothing special, just that they are black. I looked around a little bit and found that my previous machine had the Mash!ta brand optical drive but my new machine had a High Life Data Storage drive. This being the only difference in the two machines and considering my cds worked in one machine and not the other, it must be that the High Life drives cannot read my black CDs.

 

I don't burn CD's that often and I'd rather not buy a new spool just to reburn my cds and load my software onto my computer. (I have a couple CDs that I'd like to use.) So I talked to the Dell technician again and he said that I had to 're-buy' my old Mash!ta drive in order to have it installed in my new machine. Keeping in mind, they have the same capabilities, the Mash!ta drive is much quieter, and that Dell does not differentiate between the two drives on their website.

 

So with all this, I'm a little disappointed that I can't simply have a drive that works with my cds and have a nonoverheating laptop. If I can't get anything out of customer support or tech support, I've realized my options.

A: Since I still have the old machine and I watched the tech take it apart, I could try myself to swap the two drives and end up with a machine that works well and has the ability to read my cds. I've had a fair amount of experience taking apart laptops and repairing them and the m1330 didn't seem as bad as I would have initially thought.

B: Buy new cds or buy a REFURBISHED drive from Dell just to use my cds and be angry about the whole thing.

C: Return the laptop and go with another brand.

 

I really like the machine and I'd love to keep it but I've never had so many issues before. I really just want everything to work properly as it should.

 

Note: The language filter is amusing if anyone is wondering why I spelled Mash!ta with an exclamation mark instead of an i. :P

  • Jdoki

    17 Posts

    169

    0

    Posted February 15th, 2008 09:00

    This certinaly isn't an acceptible solution, but it might be another option to add to your list:

     

    If the old machine (which does read the black CDR's) still works could you get hold of a USB stick (or external HDD) and copy the files to that, then either copy them to the new machine, or install from the USB stick?

     

    Like I said, it's not an ideal solution, but it's probably cheaper and less hassle than reburning all your discs.

     

    I wouldn't recommend the first option you suggest, but only on the grounds that you would invalidate your warranty, and if you get stuck you may end up with two macines that don't work!

     

    Unfortunately, in my experience, black CDR's have the least compatibility with drives.

  • rubyxc7

    6 Posts

    169

    0

    Posted February 15th, 2008 12:00

    Well, a couple of the CD's are bootable. I'm a computer science student so I've made a couple operating system disks (legal, through the school) and I would've liked to install multiple operating systems on my machine to test program compatability. (Necessary since we do most of our programming under Linux/Unix) I don't think I could just take the files off and boot off a flash drive.