UNSOLVED

badsanta_00

updated

17 years ago

0

12115

November 18th, 2009 04:00

XPS 1330 8400M GS bug and Dell Support

Hi i got a XPS 1330 with Nvidia 8400M GS bought on July 2008 with one year warranty, so it's off now. Two days ago after a lot video bugs, the screen remained black with vertical lines.I googled all this and found that this is a known bug and that Dell offers a 12 months warranty extension for that issue. So i called Dell, but they were VERY unfriendly. They told me there was nothing concerning that in my file ...???, told me to listen and not to talk and that they only could extend my warranty for 200 euros, after i paid 30 euros to make the diagnosis. I refused, of course.

This is not a method. If i want to take the extension, i take it, but i don't want to be forced. Is Dell really offering assistance for that issue or not ?

Thank you for your help.

Regards.

PS : here's the link to warranty extension :

http://en.community.dell.com/blogs/direct2dell/archive/2008/08/18/nvidia-gpu-update-dell-to-offer-warranty-enhancement-to-all-affected-customers-worldwide.aspx

  • mmendels

    1 Message

    718

    0

    Posted November 18th, 2009 08:00

    I am facing the same issue.  My XPS 1330 shows nothing but green vertical lines.  I called tech support but they told me that the warranty applies only to a "certain batch."  He stated that I can continue to talk to a support agent, but that a fee would be involved.  Funny, Dell's own statement regarding the extended warranty says nothing about any "batches."  It simply lists the affected models and the specific issue that is covered.  My sysem meets both of those criteria. 

    When I said as much, the 'support' agent said that he was not interested in arguing and he transferred me to customer care.  After waiting on hold for a while, a customer care agent picked up but, after listening to my issue, he said he would transfer me to "someone who can help."  After hearing a few beeps and clicks, I received a message that the office was closed because it was "outside normal business hours" (which is odd, since I was calling at ~10:15 am Central time)   The call was then disconnected.  

    This story seems to be a common one.  I hope that Dell does the right thing and abides by its own extended warranty.  I also hope that this is not a cynical attempt to keep us in limbo until the extended warranty expires as well. 

     

     

  • 718

    0

    Posted November 19th, 2009 06:00

    I am having the same problem, too

     I bought my laptop 2 uears ago, and now when turn on my laptop ( XPS m1330 ) it shows nothing but white screen, then when I wait for some time, it shows those line you have talked about.

    sometimes, very few times , the laptop turns on correctly, so  I checked the sittings of my vidoe card and I found that it is Unavailable !!!

    like you guys, my garranty is over and I am very upset, because this laptop is supposed to be much more better, Dell must do something about it

    this laptop cost's me 520 B.D ( 1379 $ ) so how much are we supposed to pay in order to have a good woking laptop ?

     

  • ejn63

    11 Legend

    •

    87469 Posts

    •

    321256 Points

    718

    0

    Posted November 19th, 2009 07:00

    If the system is two years old, even the extended warranty is gone unless you had a longer than one year warranty up front.

    This is a global problem with nVidia chips - they are faulty in every system that used them.

  • 718

    0

    Posted November 19th, 2009 14:00

    If Dell (and NVidia) were honest they should change the motherboard affected by the bug even if the video card is still working. This is how it should work. 

    But indeed they don't do that : they offer one year of extended warranty and you when ask for it they just find a way to make you pay again.

    I payed my laptop 1000 euros (1500 dollars), and if i'm forced to, i'll pay again 200 euros for extended warranty. But i swear i'll not give another penny to Dell.

     

     

  • ejn63

    11 Legend

    •

    87469 Posts

    •

    321256 Points

    718

    0

    Posted November 19th, 2009 15:00

    If nVidia had to pay for that it'd go bankrupt, leaving everyone stranded -- the situation is a no-win.  nVidia produced millions of defective chips that were integrated into notebooks from every major manufacturer.

    If you've plans to keep the system, then yes - extend the warranty.  Since nVidia has likely ended production of these, you might wind up with a new system in the end -- there's no way for a manufacturer to go back and design a new mainboard for an existing system.

    Though nVidia has now switched to ATI's die design with its newer chips, which may improve its future, I'd still stay away for at least a generation to see if they've solved their problems.

     

  • nvrnoy

    3 Posts

    718

    0

    Posted December 16th, 2009 09:00

    HI, THIS IS MY FIRST FORUM INVOLVMENT AND I'M OVERWHELMED BY THE EXTENT OF THE VIDEO PROBLEM. MY XPS 1330 ALSO SHOWS ONLY VERTICAL LINES AND MY EFFORTS TO USE ONLINE DIAGNOSTICS, FIXES AND/OR TECH SUPPORT HAS BEEN NO HELP AND CONFOUNDING, WITH A LARGE SPRINKLING OF DUBIOUS IF NOT MISLEADING INFO, AND ALOT OF PRESSURE TO BUY WARRANTEES. WOULD YOU PEASE SHARE WITH ME WHAT YOU HAVE LEARNED ABOUT THIS PROBLEM?

  • 718

    0

    Posted December 16th, 2009 23:00

    Hi. I got now an XPS working. But it costs me 200 Euros, the 3 years warranty extension. Then only "postive" point is that my one year warranty was off on july, and the new warranty runs from december 9 up to december 12. I "win" 5 Months. I must just say i had to fight for this, and to talk about the lengedary one year extension Dell is offering for that bug. Then the guy had to talk with a supervisor and came back to say it's ok, you can pay 200 euros. 

    Bye bye and good luck.

     

     

  • smjohns

    137 Posts

    718

    0

    Posted December 17th, 2009 01:00

    Unfortunately this is a big issue as many of you have now noticed. Dell will only help if your laptop is within the warranty period. The 12month extension applies AFTER any existing warranty has run out and ONLY applies to this specific GPU problem. As such, your GPU will be covered from 2 to 4years. Even if your GPU dies and your motherboard replaced by Dell, the new motherboard will have the same problem and in this respect, it will fail again in the future.

    To help minimise the problem you can replace the heat pad with a copper shim as per the following link. I did this to mine after my motherboard was replaced (luckily it failed just within the 2yr period) and my GPU / CPU temps are much lower as a result. This will greatly reduce the regularity of the GPU failures (although it may not eliminate this completely) and is highly recommended outside of Dell.....of course. It will also reduce the fan noise of your laptop too as the temps are lower and it is not needed as often. 

    http://forum.notebookreview.com/showthread.php?t=268081

    If your laptop is out of warranty and your GPU has died then you could try an revive it using the heat method. Instructions on this can be found on this thread:

    http://forum.notebookreview.com/showthread.php?t=204772&page=134

    I have not given this a try but if it saves you buying a new motherboard / latop then may be worth a try as a last ditch attempt.

    One additional think I would advise, is if you regularly use your laptop on your lap, you will notice it gets warm quite quickly. This is because the heat vents get blocked by your legs / clothing and cannot dissipate heat. After doing the above, I purchased a Logitech Portable Lapdesk N315 (or they have the Comfort Lapdesk or Cooling Pad) and the laptop sits on this. I no longer have burnt legs and the laptop runs at optimum temperature at all times and well worth the £25....especially as it has a pop-out mouse pad.

    http://www.logitech.com/index.cfm/notebook_products/stands/&cl=gb,en

  • smjohns

    137 Posts

    152

    0

    Posted December 17th, 2009 04:00

    Apparently all 8400 / 8600m chips are all affected by the inherant weakness, which is down to the design / manufacturing issue relating to these chips. I am not aware that this has ever been resolved as the chipset is now obsolete and manufacturing has moved focus to their newer chips, which do not suffer this same issues. If there was a batch of these chips manufactured differently and without the problem then this has not been advertised and there is certainly no list of id numbers to look out for.

    I think the reason this did not happen is that the problem only affects laptops that are not efficient at keeping their GPU's cool. The Dells struggles as they were fitted in very tight spaces and the cooling mechanism with the blue thermal pads were just not good enough to control the high temperatures. The interim BIOS fix (A14 & A15) only looked at firing up the heat sink fan more often but even this was not sufficient. In view of this, regardless of what nVidia say, if you have a new motherboard fitted by Dell (assuming it is a new board and not a reconditioned one, considering the M1330 laptop is now end of life) you will experience a failure again in the future assuming you do not better manage the temperature of your laptop. If your heat sink fan is pretty much always on maximum then really need to start thinking about doing something soon.

    As confirmed above before mine failed I always used the laptop on my lap and even when I did not, the heatsink fan would be at maximum pretty much all the time. After removing the heat sink pad and replacing with proper thermal past and a copper shim, my fan is barely audible. The only time it ever gets warm is if I forget to use the Logitech Portable Lapdesk but as soon as I do, it returns to normal operating temperatures.

     

  • ejn63

    11 Legend

    •

    87469 Posts

    •

    321256 Points

    718

    0

    Posted December 17th, 2009 04:00

    Even if your GPU dies and your motherboard replaced by Dell, the new motherboard will have the same problem and in this respect, it will fail again in the future.

     

    That's not what nVidia claims - they claim the problem was fixed with later production models.

     

    One additional think I would advise, is if you regularly use your laptop on your lap, you will notice it gets warm quite quickly

     

    That is a sure way to shorten the life of ANY notebook - it's abuse.