UNSOLVED

uogecko

updated

20 years ago

Closed

U

uogecko

12 Posts

0

17365

January 10th, 2007 14:00

Sudden display problem with Inspiron 8200

Hi everyone - suddenly my Inspiron 8200 started having a display issue that I can't figure out.

I run Windows XP with a Mobility Radeon 9000 video card.

The symptoms are difficult to describe but appear to be blue horizontal and vertical patterns that criss cross the entire screen. The machine is still usable, but it's pretty annoying.

I updated my video drivers, did virus scans, all to no avail. What's odd is that even on a restart, before windows has loaded, the DOS startup screens display the same problem.

How can I go about troubleshooting this?

Thanks
  • uogecko

    12 Posts

    656

    0

    Posted January 10th, 2007 18:00

    Where did you get a replacement card? How much did it cost? Were you able to install it yourself?

    My laptop is out of warranty...

    Thanks
  • dbramlet

    2187 Posts

    656

    0

    Posted January 10th, 2007 18:00

    Had that same problem with a 8200 with the same card installed and my only option was to replace the card. But I could lower the resolution and get rid of it but was not a good looking option.
  • dbramlet

    2187 Posts

    656

    0

    Posted January 10th, 2007 19:00

    Here are 3 links.
    This is the drivers for the cards your system will run:

    Message Edited by dbramlet on 01-10-200703:12 PM

  • dbramlet

    2187 Posts

    656

    0

    Posted January 10th, 2007 19:00

    Actually off eBay as it was too expensive from Dell. There is another card that came with that laptop also and you can find the name of it in the download section for the 8200. It would be cheaper. I will look for it here soon. But try dropping the resolution first and make sure it is better. Others here may have suggestions also. Could be you can reomove the keyboard and reseat the LCD cable to it and see if that works. Don't think you would have to remove the power strip to get to that cable. Yes, I installed it myself and I will send you the link to get to it.
  • uogecko

    12 Posts

    656

    0

    Posted January 10th, 2007 19:00

    Thanks for the info - I don't think it's a problem with the connection to the LCD because I tried connecting an external monitor and have the same video problem.

    Also, dropping the resolution and color bit didn't help at all...

    It's weird that it even happens when the BIOS is booting up right after I press the power button.
  • dbramlet

    2187 Posts

    656

    0

    Posted January 10th, 2007 19:00

    Well, I would say wait and see if you get others to post before running out and getting a new card right away. But if this happens with an external monitor also good chance it is the video card.

    Message Edited by dbramlet on 01-10-200703:18 PM

  • AndyC_772

    9 Posts

    656

    0

    Posted January 12th, 2007 17:00

    If it's any consolation, my Inspiron 8200 just developed exactly the same fault, entirely without warning. It shows the same fault on an external monitor too, so I think it's the ATI Radeon Mobility 9000 card that's gone bad.

    The display flickers and responds to any flexing of the chassis, so it looks like a dry joint or broken wire somewhere - hopefully I'll be able to find out where without having to just keep replacing bits until it starts working again.
  • AndyC_772

    9 Posts

    656

    0

    Posted January 16th, 2007 17:00

    **UPDATE**: scratch this post - my 'fix' lasted two days before the card started misbehaving again. Looks like the broken connection may actually be inside the GPU package itself, which means it's not repairable at all.

    Time for a new card :(

    Premature euphoria and wishful thinking follows....

    ---------------------------------------------


    OK, here's an update for the benefit of anyone else in the same predicament.
    *Disclaimer*: I'm a professional electronic engineer by trade, my laptop is out of warranty, I'm prepared to take full responsibility for my actions, and if I break something I'm prepared to pay for a new one without blaming anyone else. If these statements do not apply to you, don't try this!!
    So, with that out of the way...
    The symptoms my card was exhibiting were:
    - machine works fine for about 10 seconds when stone cold
    - garbled characters and/or horizontal stripes in the BIOS start-up screen
    - red or blue chequerboard pattern in both Linux and Windows, which would flicker randomly but especially when the PC chassis is flexed
    - sometimes, a square block of red 'fuzz' which would follow the mouse pointer
    - sometimes, the pattern of distortion would move as a window is dragged around the screen.
    - all faults appear on an external screen as well as the built-in LCD.
    These symptoms point to a broken connection between the GPU and the graphics memory on the ATI card. The GPU (and the PCB it's attached to) gets quite hot in use, and because the chip and PCB expand at different rates, this puts a lot of stress on the solder balls that join them together. Over time, repeated heating and cooling can cause stress cracks to grow in the solder, and one day the joint breaks completely. The problem is especially bad with BGAs (Ball Grid Arrays), because there's no flexibility in the legs to absorb the relative movement, and once a joint cracks, you can't get a soldering iron in to fix it.
    My laptop is about 4 years old and gets switched on and off about 3 times a day on average - so that's about 5000 heating/cooling cycles. From what I've read, this board seems quite prone to failing in this way. The best price I've found for a replacement was £95+VAT here in the UK.
    So, rather than fork out that sort of money to fix an old laptop, I decided first to just buy a cheaper card that fits. I ordered an Nvidia card (p/n 4D597) off Ebay for a much more reasonable £24, but although it seems to work OK in Windows @ 1600x1200, it gives a jumpy picture in the BIOS screen which suggests it may not be fully compatible with my LCD.
    Time to try and fix the original card. The problem with BGAs is (obviously) that you can't get to the pins to examine them or to resolder them with a soldering iron. Nevertheless, I was 99% sure the problem was a cracked joint, and it makes sense that the crack would be under the chip that gets hottest - namely the GPU itself. I can't get a soldering iron to the pins, so...
    Enter the paint stripper!
    (Well, technically it's an industrial heat gun with variable speed and temperature, though I did once use one to remove a layer of old gloss from a door frame... but I digress!)
    Hot air is the only way to melt the solder balls on a BGA, and I regularly frighten the service guys at work by using the heat gun to remove and replace components. They regard it as barbaric. I regard it as quick and effective. Nevertheless it's just the job for locally heating a board and causing all the solder joints to melt.
    So, on my anti-static bench I place an aluminium sheet to protect the bench mat, and first grab a scrap board from the pile in my office - an old PC motherboard would be ideal, provided it has a BGA device on it somewhere that's about the same size as the Radeon 9000. I then set the heat gun to about 350 deg C and minimum airflow, and hold it about 3 inches away from the BGA on the scrap board, gently lifting the chip with a surgical scalpel so I can tell when all the solder joints have melted.
    It's about 90 seconds before the chip lifts up, which is fine. Much longer and the heat is liable to have time to soak through to the more sensitive parts - I'm slightly worried about the plastic AGP connector on the underside of the video board. Conversely, too much heat can de-laminate the PCB and wreck the GPU too. Either way, the procedure is risky with no guarantee of success.
    Nevertheless, it's now time for the real thing. The video card is on the bench and I've removed the thermal pad from the GPU - we'll need a new one. The card is propped up absolutely level and I'm aiming the heat gun straight downwards onto the GPU, to minimise the risk of blowing it off the board sideways.
    Next, pre-heat the board by increasing the distance from the heat gun to the PCB, and switch on. Warming the entire board gently like this means it expands more evenly, reducing the chances of creating more thermal stress cracks than we fix. (Don't aim anywhere near the plastic connectors though, they'll melt!!)
    Then it's back to 3 inches away and start the stopwatch. After 90 seconds nothing visible has happened - this is a good thing! - so I give it two minutes to be sure the solder joints have all melted. Still no sign of anything other than a slight browning of a paper label, which is exactly what I hoped for. Then the heat is slowly withdrawn, giving the board another 30 seconds with the heat source about 8 inches away, so it can cool more slowly.
    Don't touch the board for at least another 5 minutes. It'll be really hot, and you DO NOT want to touch the GPU or risk moving it while it's solder balls are still molten. If the chip moves, even slightly, you're .
    Anyway, once it had cooled, I reinstalled it in my laptop, leaving the keyboard off for now. Switch on, BIOS screen appears, clear and sharp. Looking good! Without a keyboard my PC boots into Linux, switches to 1600x1200 and... still sharp. Wahey! But the GPU is now getting a bit warm, and without the keyboard there to act as a heatsink, I decide to switch off. But what a result!
    So, before, I can finally reassemble and call it a job well done, I need a new thermal pad. Don't try to re-use the one you took off. The pad is made of a thermally conductive material and looks about 1mm thick - a little detective work shows that it's *probably* Chomerics A174 THERM-A-GAP, aluminium oxide filled silicone on an aluminium foil substrate - and even if it's not, that should be close enough. Your favourite PC parts supplier or electronics distributor may be able to supply a suitable alternative.
    Wish me luck finding a thermal pad and for the final assembly :)
    Once again: DON'T TRY THIS UNLESS YOU'VE ALREADY DECIDED YOUR VIDEO CARD IS SCRAP. THIS IS NOT A DELL APPROVED PROCEDURE! I AM NOT RESPONSIBLE FOR ANY DAMAGE YOU MAY CAUSE TO YOUR VIDEO CARD, LAPTOP OR ANYTHING ELSE WHILE ATTEMPTING TO UNDERTAKE THIS PROCEDURE! (But if it goes well, and you feel like buying me a beer to say 'thanks', then please feel free to go ahead)
    Hope that helps someone out there - I'd love to know how you get on if you try this fix, it makes spending all this time typing it up seem worthwhile. Post below and I should get an email.
    Good luck :)
    Andy

    Message Edited by AndyC_772 on 01-21-200701:53 PM

  • Rick_e_White

    1 Message

    656

    0

    Posted March 3rd, 2007 13:00

    When you said your "fix" didn't work ... did you mean the whole soldering / replacing fix? ...or the video card replacement "fix"? End of day - what did you end up doing to solve this problem? and what overall was cost? Thanks so much for your insight and help!
  • AndyC_772

    9 Posts

    134

    0

    Posted March 3rd, 2007 15:00

    The PC worked for a few days afterwards but then the problem recurred. I ended up buying a near-identical s/h laptop off Ebay, swapping over my extra memory, DVD burner and the like, and then breaking my old one for parts. I've been just about able to cover the cost of the replacement machine by selling the bits of my original laptop that worked (eg. screen, motherboard etc) separately. So, effectively I got a new video card for nothing, apart from a load of hassle.