UNSOLVED

Tomino

updated

23 years ago

Closed

T

Tomino

24 Posts

0

8645

February 9th, 2004 19:00

Pentium 4 3,2GHz vs. Centrino 1,7GHz ???!!!!!!!

This is probably the ethernal question but... can't find the answer! Does anyone knows which processor is faster (for computations, no games) between an Pentium 4 at 3,2 GHz and the Centrino 1,7 GHz... basically the choice is between the 8600 and the 5150.

Any help is much appreciated, thanx

  • 7fold

    30 Posts

    372

    0

    Posted February 10th, 2004 07:00

    if 3.2HT/2x512 ram/7K60/fast ethernet controller on-board compared to 1.7centrino (1st gen)/2x512 ram/7K60/fast ethernet controller on-board  -  the m P4 3.2 is more productive number cruncher

    1.9 dothan (2nd gen centrino) having on-board gigabit lan controller (albeit negotiating at 100mps+) reducing cpu usage/interventionl will nearly equal present m P4 3.2HT cpu

    yes appropriate video card will make a little difference when running ordinary apps  -  but will not help in number crunching

    my post refers to heavy spread sheet / financial analysis / scientific computation programs & heavy photoshop usage  -  not gaming

  • Tombo777

    1 Rookie

    •

    64 Posts

    372

    0

    Posted February 10th, 2004 07:00

    Either one will do anything you need it to. You won't "see" the difference at all. You don't need either one. a 1.4 or a 2.4 will do just fine as well. I cannot imagine what application you will run that you will be able to actually notice the difference between any of the above speeds.
    Don't buy the numbers, buy for the application.he M chip is a much better chip for a notebook. Less heat, way less. and more battery, lighter and you will not notice the performance diffrence. My 1.4 M lappy runs as well as my 2.4 P4 desktop.

    If it takes one hour to render a video on a 1.4 then it will take 42min on a 1.7 . Thats not much of a bang for the buck. Most people do not run that intense of an application and if they did...Well There is a high price to pay for 12 less minutes! You can make that comparison ona 2.8 vs a 3.2 desktop as well. Its not that big if a difference and not notcable at all in most applications. It's only theory and benchmark numbers that will show the difference, but in the real world you really can't see the difference at all. That's why I for one NEVER look at benchmarks when choosing a configuration. I look at what I want to do and buy the minimum spec to do it. especially in a disposable product such as a lappy.

    Get the 8600...It's not tryiny to be adesktop. It's made for the lappy world. You won't be sorry.

    8600 1.4
    15.4 WXGA
    768 333mhz ram (512 Kingmax 2700)
    40 GB (5200 rpm)
    NVidia 5200Go 64mb
    DVD/CDRW
    INtel wireless
    Win XP Home
    1 year mail in.
    $1268 (refurb)

    3D mark 2002 .000052 At avg 1 FPS... But runs da games well...go figure!!

    Message Edited by Tombo777 on 02-10-2004 03:56 AM

  • Tomino

    24 Posts

    372

    0

    Posted February 10th, 2004 08:00

    Thank you very much for the answer and I get your point... I´m always reluctant about buying the latest technology because you pay it more than its real value.

    The point is that I need to run intense calculations on interplanetary trajectory optimization and I always had "desktop replacement"... heavy to carry and short battery lifetime. So I basically need the same (saving even 15 minutes for each simulation equals saving 2 hours/day when I run 8 simulations each day) but I´m trying to evaluate the real difference between them and see if I can finally buy a "real notebook".

    Again, thanx so much for contributing to my decision making...

    Message Edited by Tomino on 02-10-2004 05:22 AM