UNSOLVED

baroclin

updated

23 years ago

Closed

B

baroclin

15 Posts

0

29379

August 2nd, 2003 15:00

Auto Air adapter wont charge battery due to Dell proprietary comms. chop

I just purchased a new i8500 along with the 70 watt Targus auto air adapter.  Much to my dismay I discovered that not only will the 70 watt auto air adapter not run the processer at full speed but it will not charge the battery.

My old i8100 had a Lind auto air adapter which ran the processer at full speed and charged the battery.

Lind sells a DC to DC 90 watt adaper which supplies the exact wattage as the Dell AC adapter and should run the processer at full speed and charge the battery.  However (according to the Lind Web site) Dell has installed a proprietary communications chip in the AC adapter that handshakes with the laptop to allow the battery to charge.  Therefore even though the Lind adapter should charge the battery it will not due to the handshaking requirement instituted by Dell.

A Lind representative told me Lind has asked Dell for the handshaking code on several occasions but no code has been provided. 

Does anyone know of a way (patch?) to allow any  90w adapter to charge the Dell 8500 battery without handshaking???? 

I am quite annoyed that Dell is playing such games.

Unless this issue can be resolved I will likely send the whole $2500 laptop and accessories back for a refund (30 day satisfaction guarantee).

I am looking at the Toshiba laptops as they are very reliable and have no such nonsense with charging the battery. 

Thanks much for any suggestions.  (I do not want to use an inverter...heavy and too many wires)

 

 

 

 

  • Rance485

    2 Intern

    •

    298 Posts

    1764

    0

    Posted August 5th, 2003 13:00

    baroclin:

    Dell supplies different AC adapters with the same connectors on our portable systems. We need to identify when one of these is used on the wrong system or in the wrong circumstance (with a docking station or APR for example). The "handshaking" method is used to verify the proper AC adapter is in use.

     

  • 1764

    0

    Posted September 26th, 2003 21:00

    I kind of feel sad that I bought the smaller 75W power brick instead of the 90W brick.  Since the laptop queries the brick and sees it is 75W, the Dell laptop scales down the maxI don't get the full advantage of speed that the 90W brick allows.
  • baroclin

    15 Posts

    1764

    0

    Posted September 28th, 2003 01:00

    When I bought the i8500 I was under the impression that although the 90 watt adapter would run the laptop at full speed it would not charge the battery (due to a lack of handshaking with the i8500). Has anyone tried the 90w adapter? Will the 90W adapter allow battery charge??

    I bought a inverter (175W Vector) that plugs into a 12V outlet to run the i8500 at full power (using the 120v adapter provided with the laptop). The inverter keeps alarming as though 12v battery power is low (which it is not) and the i8500 keeps switching from inverter to its own battery power. A very poor solution to the low processer speed problem!!

    Has anyone found a solution that will allow running the i8500 in a 12v power supply at full processer speed and at the same time charge the laptop battery??

    Thanks for any insight.

    Steve B
  • 1764

    0

    Posted October 1st, 2003 19:00

    Baroclin, I didn't have the same problem that you did with the inverter and the original power brick that came with the 8600.  I also use an inverter and power brick to charge up the 8600 in the car.  If I do not have the car engine running, the battery is usually able to charge up to 100% but not always if I have been running the 8600 for awhile.  If I run the engine for the final part of the charge, the laptop will reach 100% of course.

    The inverter I use is one of the 300W cheapies bought at Sam's Club for $29.  The one now sold at Sam's Club is a 400W model that is more or less the same physical size as mine.  I don't know if buying such a large unit is less efficient due to the larger quiescent operating current such a unit uses.  However, it was certainly cheaper than buying other brands.  If you can, look for the CSA approval on the package.  None of the "Made In China" inverters I've seen at any retail store had UL safety approval marks.  Not that UL label accuracy matters to the "Made In China" group.  For example, I have a wireless card made in China that has the usual FCC certification number, but the card (as produced) is significantly different in specs and physical content than the one sent to the FCC for registration approval....  Someone else who had some sophisticated test/measurement wireless gear checked out the card series and found out that the output power of the card was significantly under what was claimed by the Chinese maker.  Oh well.

    The inverter I use only beeps due to low voltage if I have been using the 8600 for quite awhile.  It seems to be more tolerant of sagging battery voltage than the one you use.  It is clear from my i7000 usage of the inverter/brick combo that this combo is quite less efficient than the direct 12v-to-20v switching power supply cable I bought from Port (before it was acquired by Targus).  With the direct 12v power cable, I could probably run the 7000 for eight hours or more without draining the car battery.  I don't have the patience to check that out though.  I assume that a power cable for the 8600 would be similarly more efficient than the inverter/brick combo if only that something like it existed (which it does not thanks to the proprietary code that Dell uses to communicate between the power supply and laptop).

    Although that power cord for the I7000 cost $67, I'd pay it again for a I8600 variant because of its efficiency and because it was completely silent and cool running.  It is notable that the I7000 power cable ran with less heat production than the power brick, so it is clear just from a heat production perspective, the power cable approach was superior.

    Mentioned:

    1.  300W power inverter:  Bought for $29 years ago from Sam's Club.  It was a pretty anodized (not paint) blue case.  The current ones sold at Sam's are 400W for the same price but these come in a green case (painted?). 

    2.  Power cable:  Back in the says of the i7000, Port made power cables for most of the laptops.  This meant that a wide variety of cables had to be made and was less profitable than a single universal power supply approach.  However, it was the nicest prettiest most efficient way I've ever seen.  Basically, the power cable was a cable with a smooth oval nodule in the middle.  One end of the cable plugged into your 12V socket and the other end into your laptop.  Very neat, efficient, and convenient to carry due to its small size and smooth shape.  Alas, all the solutions now are the much larger universal power bricks.

  • baroclin

    15 Posts

    1764

    0

    Posted October 2nd, 2003 06:00

    If the reason for the handshaking is to make sure the correct adapter is being used as you state, why is it that there is no "handshaking" necessary to simply power the I8500? 

    So its OK for any adapter to run the laptop with no handshaking,  but when it comes to charging the battery we must be sure the correct adapter is attached to the laptop?

    What am I missing?

     

  • baroclin

    15 Posts

    1764

    0

    Posted October 2nd, 2003 07:00

    I8600,

    Thanks for your input.  I believe the problem is that a 12V cigarette lighter is a poor way to power an inverter.  A more direct connection would achieve better results.

     

     

     

     

  • 1764

    0

    Posted October 3rd, 2003 21:00

    Since I already have the Port power cable that has an output voltage/current for the i7000, I have been tempted to buy parts at Fry's (or Radio Shack) to make an adapter to use the cable with the i8600.  It wouldn't charge the i8600 battery, but it would at least power it.

    However, the i8600 has an adapter that says 19.5 volts and the i7000 has an adapter that says 20 volts.  So, I am wondering if I can drop the voltage by putting a silicon diode in series with the load.  The voltage drop across a diode is approx 0.7 volts, so that would bring it in line with what the i8600 uses.   Does anyone have comments on the idea? 

  • 1764

    0

    Posted January 14th, 2004 19:00

    Well I have not seen anyone with a solution other than an inverter to get the battery charged - not an option in my case.  If I had know about this problem before I bought over 40 D600's I may well have looked elsewhere.  Dell even recommended the Targus auto/air but never mentioned that it would not charge the battery.  Who would have thought since every other auto/air they recommended, and that I bought through them, charged the battery.

    I have to buy some more laptops to replace old Latitudes.  If I cannot get an auto/air that will charge the battery I may just say bye-bye to Dell.  This is frustrating and aggravating.

    If anyone has a solution, please let me know.

  • Mainframe2

    18 Posts

    1764

    0

    Posted January 25th, 2004 19:00

    I think the decision to "identify when one of these is used on the wrong system or in the wrong circumstance" is a commercial decision which is now back firing very badly. Thousands of returned power supplies, changed mother boards and a large body of unhappy customers.

    I have a fully optioned Inspiron 8600, but unless a resolution is made to the above Dell company policy, this will be my last Dell computer.
  • acoustic

    11 Posts

    1022

    0

    Posted January 25th, 2004 21:00

    If you think dell is bad gateway is worse

    They treat ya worse than ever. I about had it with the desktop  i have that is 1.7

     has had mb replaced once

    hd replaced 2x floppy dont work

     now it freezes,makes a hd racket, smells nice resourced prob as well but has 640 ram

    oh and now the cd rom aint working properly