UNSOLVED

Charlie111_c211ef

updated

19 years ago

0

10844

October 1st, 2007 23:00

Please Help! XPS 720H2C PCIe x8 Slot 7--What can it be used for? Will a RAID controller work there?

I just bought my XPS 720, and so far it's great.
 
I had several questions about Slot 7 on the motherboard before I called Tech Support today, but I still have some left.
 
FYI-- Some of you may have noticed that the owner's manual on pages 89-90 state that slot 7 (the PCIe slot all the way at the bottom of the motherboard) is an x16 slot.  According to tech support, that's wrong, because the slot is x8 (which is what the advertising literature says). 
 
I'd like to put an external Raid array (hardware raid) on the 720 for pictures and music.  I'm trying to find out if I can.  Most Raid PCIe cards that I've run across are x4.  Dell's tech support guessed that slot 7 was wired ONLY for x8, and that an x4 card would not work in it.  I talked to AMCC's tech support (AMCC makes and external Raid box called "The Sidecar", which is very, very  fast).  They saw 2 problems with using slot 7 for a Raid controller.  First, IF Dell's guess was correct, then slot 7 would not support an x4 card.  Second, they had a concern that slot 7 could have been primarily designed for graphics and controlled by the Nvidia 680i chip, in which case it might not suppost a raid array at all, or if the motherboard would recognize the card, the controller might work very slowly.
 
Does anyone know if slot 7 will support an x4 Raid controller?
 
Would the Nvidia chip slow the controller down?
 
Does anyone have any good suggestions on how to hook up a fast external raid array to the motheboard of the 720?
 
THANKS!!
  • jsrder

    903 Posts

    665

    0

    Posted October 2nd, 2007 14:00

    Charlie,
     
    Actually, the manual and the tech support folks are both right (technically).
     
    Slot 7 is a physical x16 slot which is wired x8.
     
    In my experience, there hasn't been any problem using a card which uses less PCI lanes (i.e. putting a x1 card in a x4 slot, putting a x4 into a x8 slot).
     
    Based upon it being slot 7, I could see a problem with the IRQ assigned to the RAID controller which could contribute to slowing it down ... but that will also depend on whether you have dual video cards and other PCI cards installed. 
     
    If you are determined to have this RAID card, give it a try and tinker a bit ...
  • 665

    0

    Posted October 2nd, 2007 18:00

    Thanks, jsrder.  I think you're right twice-- first, about the slot, second, about giving it a try.  The thing is not returnable (to the merchants where I found it) unless purchased from the factory at full retail, which is why I hoped to learn whether anyone else had tried a raid card in that slot.  But you're right, I'm just going to give it a shot at full retail.  aargh.
     
    One thing I did not mention yesterday is that Tech Support guessed that the slot would ONLY handle an x8 item (i.e., it will not handle an x4 card, like the one I'm talking about).  That does not sound right to me.  I guess I'll find out.  If TSupp is right about that, it's pretty much a useless slot, unless someone accidentally runs across something that needs exactly 8 channels, and I can't think of anything that does excpet graphics cards  and 12 port raid controllers.
     
    You raised a whole new issue I had not thought of, the IRQ requests.  I have not thought about those since the 90's.  What a pain those were.  I remember setting things to irq 11 when I ran out of other irqs.  If I have a problem with speed, I'll need to look at that.  Is there anywhere I can read about those?  Are they changeable in the bios? 
     
    Thanks for your intelligent answer.


    Message Edited by Charlie111 on 10-02-2007 02:17 PM
  • tphillips63

    4 Apprentice

    •

    2629 Posts

    •

    7922 Points

    665

    0

    Posted October 2nd, 2007 23:00

    With PCIe you can put any card in a x16 slot.
    A x8 will hold x8, x4 and x1, and so on down to x1 but it does not go the other way.
  • 665

    0

    Posted October 3rd, 2007 07:00

    Thanks for the reply, tphillips.  Your answer is what my intuition and limited knowledge of PCIe told me.  What surprised me is that the tech sup people at both Dell and AMCC (3ware) told me that an x16 PCIe slot could be wired to accept only x8, and not lesser included lanes.  In other words, they say that what the slot will accept is dependent on the wiring, and if the designers decided to make an x16 slot (like mine) accept ONLY x8, then they could.  They mentioned something about a power pin. 
     
    I'm gathering you are saying either that they are wrong, or that Dell did not so limit the slot in this case.  Are you fairly confident?
     
    Thanks so much for taking the trouble to reply!
  • 665

    0

    Posted October 9th, 2007 21:00

    After a couple of days, I got an answer in writing from tech support, as follows:
     
    "If you wish to install a second RAID controller, the bottom slot which is
    an 8x will clock down to 4x, 2x or 1x."
     
    I don't think I'm going to get a chance to prove that right or wrong, since in the interim I went shopping for alternative solutions.  I'm going to get an ISCSI drive and run it via gigabit ethernet.  I'm told that in the real world (by WiebeTech) that's about 30% faster than eSata. 
     
    I hope someone else learns something useful from this.  I'd assume I'm not the only person who does not want to clog up his internal drives (which are already Raid 0) with tons of gigs of pictures that then will have to be backed up constantly.        ...or music, or whatever....
     
    Thanks to those who replied!