UNSOLVED

STGCMTED

updated

15 years ago

S

STGCMTED

308 Posts

0

6574

August 26th, 2011 12:00

Looking for Opinions..

I have 2 fairly new Dell computers available to me to install for use in my shop...A Dell Inspiron 531S with an AMD 64 Athlon x2 processor / Vista / 2 GB ram / 320 GB HD in it or a Dell Dimension E521 with an AMD 64x2 Dual Core Processor 3800+ 2.00 GHZ/2 gb Ram / Vista / dvd ROM and DVR +- RW...   all other items are about the same on both computers..  Which one would you use?

  • fireberd

    11 Legend

    •

    33399 Posts

    •

    112848 Points

    367

    0

    Posted August 26th, 2011 12:00

    Although the 531S is newer, I'm partial to the full size towers and would go with the E521.`

    Inspiron 16 5630 Laptop and WD22TB4 Docking Station
    Self-built desktop for recording studio application
  • shesagordie

    12 Elder

    •

    46017 Posts

    367

    0

    Posted August 26th, 2011 13:00

                      
     STGCMTED

    The e521, it's easier to upgrade and like Fireberd, I'm not partial to the so-called SlimLine versions.

    Bev.

  • 367

    0

    Posted August 26th, 2011 15:00

    neither. downgrade to windows xp

  • STGCMTED

    308 Posts

    367

    0

    Posted August 27th, 2011 12:00

    The E521 will restore to Windows XP Media Edition 2005.. It was upgraded to Vista (why I will never know..)  but since it came from the factory with XP Media Edition.. that is what it will restore to.. Might be a good thing...

  • cathaleen

    2 Intern

    •

    135 Posts

    367

    0

    Posted August 27th, 2011 14:00

    The 531s is a faster machine running a newer operating system.  The slim case makes it fit in tighter spaces but means it is a bit less expandable and that it runs a little hotter.  But the space savings can be more important than expansion potential.  Many people like the idea of having the option to install upgrades in a computer but rarely do, particularly in a business setting, and quite often they don't make economic sense to do anyway.  I don't think you should invest your time in a windows xp machine today.  updates for xp are coming to an end and the latest internet explorer 9 is not available for xp.  if you are about ti invest your time in setting up a new machine  why wouldn't you choose the fastest one?  and that one would be the 531s.

  • RoxRanger

    24 Posts

    367

    0

    Posted August 27th, 2011 18:00

    In my opinion - and FWIW - that would not be a good thing.

    I can't for the life of me understand why people are enamored of an operating system designed in 2002. I have to use XP every day on my work PC (because they won't upgrade to Windows 7 until Windows 8 is almost out - don't get me started! :emotion-4:), and curse every time it freezes my very modern i5-equipped ThinkPad requiring a reboot (at least once a day).

    Contrary to very wrong information, Vista is a much superior operating system to XP (as is Windows 7) and if it's installed and working properly I would leave it alone.