
UNSOLVED
Faster, newer 8400 with PCIe, or older, slower 4600 with AGP?
I want to buy a new computer, preferably with the faster 533 MHz memory, which means at least a Dimension 8400. But the problem is that the 8400 has two PCIe slots, and no AGP slots. I want to move a Matrox AGP dual monitor card and Matrox PCI quad monitor card (presently in my Dimension 4100) into this new computer, which I can't do if it has no AGP slot.
The 8400 comes with an ATI Radeon X300SE card (the only choice, I think). Supposedly it is dual monitor capable. So I could try putting my Matrox quad PCI card into the 8400 (with the ATI card), to be able to run six monitors. But I've heard of problems trying to run video cards from two different manufacturers together. And as PCIe is new (not very proven) technology, that might make the chance of problems even higher. Does anyone have reason to believe these two cards would or would not work together?
I run about 55 windows in the six monitors (I am a daytrader), and my Dimension 4100 with 512 MB ram is at 100% CPU usage most of the time. I was thinking of 1 GB memory and the 530 processor in the new computer, preferably with the faster memory.
My other option is to go with the Dimension 4600, with only 400MHz ram, but which has an AGP slot. Then both my Matrox cards would fit into it. I'm sure the DDR memory and newer HT processor will be an improvement over my 4100. But the 4600 uses older technology, and is soon to be discontinued, I think? Maybe going with 2GB of ram in the 4600 would offset the slower memory speed.
So, I'm trying to decide between the newer and faster 8400, that may not work, and the slightly dated slower 4600, that should work ok. Any suggestions would be appreciated.
Responses (13)
Solutions (0)
@wconk wrote:
Trader, I did some research into the memory when I was waiting for my 8400, and all accounts agreed that the 533MHz DDR2 RAM was not faster than the 400MHz DDR RAM, and it was much more expensive too. All reviewers agreed that they DDR2 RAM will not shine until it is available in the 667MHz speed. Bottom line; don't use this DDR2 RAM as a buying point right now. The consensus was essentially the same regarding the difference between AGP and PCI-X ports; there is no noticeable performance difference and won't be until game and graphics card manufacturers design their products to take advantage of the increased data throughput available from PCI-X. Everything I read suggested that their opinion was that DDR RAM and AGP products will be around for some time yet.
It sounds like you don't need the computer for gaming, so RAM speed shouldn't be a foremost consideration. I'm no expert on multiple monitor setups, but I am pretty sure that the 300SE does support two monitors, although it has one VGA (standard) output port and one DVI port. I believe adapters are available to connect DVI to VGA components. Also, I'm not sure that the 4600 has an AGP port. I'm pretty sure that it has onboard video. Probably someone more knowledgeable about that specific system will answer that question. Hope this helps.
Wes
The 4600 has an AGP slot even if you order it with integrated video.
Hi Wes,
That sure is useful information (that the 400 and 533 MHz DDR2 ram speed difference is not noticeable). And an article in Tom's Hardware about PCIe agrees with your point on PCIe vs AGP.
So if the memory speed difference is not significant, then maybe I'm not losing much to go with the 6400 instead of 8400. They both have P4, 800FSB, HT processors, with more or less the same speeds, but the Intel 530, 540, 550 designations don't seem to apply to the 4600, so maybe the 4600 uses an older style processor?
You are right - I'm not into gaming. Instead I have all this streaming real-time stock market data coming in to multiple charts and quote lists that is somehow bogging down my present system. I confess that I don't understand the interaction of computer components well enough to know where my present bottleneck is. All I can see is I'm at 100% CPU usage (via XP Task Mgr)
If the 4600 isn't much slower, I won't have to worry about potential ATI / Matrox card conflicts or a 'wasted' 2nd PCIe slot or shortage of PCI slots in the 8400.
The online specs for the 4600 say it has 3 PCI and one AGP slot. There is an integrated video card option, but I think I should get a removeable card, to limit potential video card conflicts (pay extra for a card I can throw out).
So, still some questions, but your answer helped.
Cheers,
Dave Z
I would have to agree with KoolHonda's suggestion that if you get the 4600 with a video card you can put that card into your older machine and use it for other applications. However, I'm pretty certain that if you were only to get onboard video, you would be able to disable that feature in the system BIOS. That is the case for onboard sound.
Just an idea, I don't know anything about dual-processor systems, but if processor power is your limiting factor, perhaps one of these is the answer to your problem. I would imagine that they are expensive though.Wes
If you want the equivalent of the former Dimension 8300 (better than the 4600) also look at the Optiplex GX270, Dell Precision 360, and even the PowerEdge 400SC. These are all basically the same design with AGP + 4PCI slots, SATA or ATA drives (two supported).
@trader123 wrote:
Talmy,
Thanks for the reply. Without actually filling in all the options for a cost comparison, I did have a look at each of the models you mentioned, to see in what way they were better than the Dimension 6400.
More or less, they each had the same processor choices (P4 with HT and 800FSB)
They all had 400MHz dual channel DDR memory (not having 533MHz memory is no loss, per wconk's note).
The 4600 had a SATA hard drive, the smallest SATA was 160 GB (for only $45 more than an 80GB PATA). I use only 1/3 of my present 80GB drive, and would prefer if they had an 80GB SATA drive for this model, but they don't. Given that I use so little hard drive space, would getting the faster SATA drive be offset by slower time to search a larger disk, i.e. is the extra cost worth it? I haven't paid close attention, but while day trading I haven't notice my hard drive working. Streaming data comes in, gets processed, and displayed - CPU and memory intensive, but would it use the hard drive much after the programs are loaded?
The Optiplex GX270 and Dell Precision 360 did have the extra PCI slot. And maybe they'd have been cheaper if I'd input all the options. Otherwise were there any other ways they were better than the 4600?
Thanks again
There is no real impact you're going to see with a SATA drive over an IDE drive with your applications because as you said they aren't disk intensive. Buying the cheapest drive possible and then adding later is always the best way to go.
- They are better than the 4600 in that the case is better (and bigger), probably quieter, better motherboard (better support chip, extra PCI slot), bigger power supply, higher quality with longer warranty (except for server), built-in gigabit Ethernet. No junky software installed (no software at all on the server, others just have bare OS). The cost will be higher than the 4600, but you get what you pay for.
Talmy,
Thanks for the reply. Without actually filling in all the options for a cost comparison, I did have a look at each of the models you mentioned, to see in what way they were better than the Dimension 6400.
More or less, they each had the same processor choices (P4 with HT and 800FSB)
They all had 400MHz dual channel DDR memory (not having 533MHz memory is no loss, per wconk's note).
The 4600 had a SATA hard drive, the smallest SATA was 160 GB (for only $45 more than an 80GB PATA). I use only 1/3 of my present 80GB drive, and would prefer if they had an 80GB SATA drive for this model, but they don't. Given that I use so little hard drive space, would getting the faster SATA drive be offset by slower time to search a larger disk, i.e. is the extra cost worth it? I haven't paid close attention, but while day trading I haven't notice my hard drive working. Streaming data comes in, gets processed, and displayed - CPU and memory intensive, but would it use the hard drive much after the programs are loaded?
The Optiplex GX270 and Dell Precision 360 did have the extra PCI slot. And maybe they'd have been cheaper if I'd input all the options. Otherwise were there any other ways they were better than the 4600?
Thanks again

wconk
20 Posts
702
0
Posted August 2nd, 2004 20:00
Trader, I did some research into the memory when I was waiting for my 8400, and all accounts agreed that the 533MHz DDR2 RAM was not faster than the 400MHz DDR RAM, and it was much more expensive too. All reviewers agreed that they DDR2 RAM will not shine until it is available in the 667MHz speed. Bottom line; don't use this DDR2 RAM as a buying point right now. The consensus was essentially the same regarding the difference between AGP and PCI-X ports; there is no noticeable performance difference and won't be until game and graphics card manufacturers design their products to take advantage of the increased data throughput available from PCI-X. Everything I read suggested that their opinion was that DDR RAM and AGP products will be around for some time yet.
It sounds like you don't need the computer for gaming, so RAM speed shouldn't be a foremost consideration. I'm no expert on multiple monitor setups, but I am pretty sure that the 300SE does support two monitors, although it has one VGA (standard) output port and one DVI port. I believe adapters are available to connect DVI to VGA components. Also, I'm not sure that the 4600 has an AGP port. I'm pretty sure that it has onboard video. Probably someone more knowledgeable about that specific system will answer that question. Hope this helps.
Wes