UNSOLVED

DELL-Chris M

updated

20 years ago

DC

DELL-Chris M

Community Manager

•

56891 Posts

•

232143 Points

0

56070

August 3rd, 2006 11:00

Dimension 4700 Fan orientation

This was released on July 18, 2006:

Several online forums and web logs (blogs) have reported that the system fan on the Dimension 4700 was installed incorrectly (backwards) from the factory. While it is true that the fans are installed "backwards" in the system, it is wrong to say this was done incorrectly or by mistake. The Dimension 4700 system shipped with an aggressive system configuration that required more direct airflow than previously shipped Dimension systems. For this reason, Dell engineering modified the airflow in the Dimension 4700 to support a cooling solution designed with the fan pulling air into the chassis. The air is pulled in through the back of the chassis and is directed straight to the CPU heat sink and CPU voltage regulator before finally passing by the hard drive and out the front of the chassis. It is correct to say the airflow is backward compared to other Dimension systems. However, without this difference in thermal design, the Dimension 4700 system would not perform nearly as well.


DELL-Chris M (old account)

#IWork4Dell

  • ravik521

    2 Intern

    •

    1560 Posts

    856

    0

    Posted August 3rd, 2006 12:00

    Dell-ChrisM I have a question for you about the 4700 cooling, to save time, im going to ask it now, if you do not mind. You say that the fan is supposed to bring the air in, fine. But a lot of people have better experience by reversing the airflow. Fine. Now if the fan is bringing in air, you say its supposed to go through the vent in the front of the case. Here's the problem with that. The green shroud attached to the cpu heatsink and fan, allows mainly for cpu cooling only. so that air would most likely never reach the other parts or the front air vent. EVEN if it did, it would heat up the ram, and hardrive. + the hardrive takes up 90% of the space in the front vent. So how does that work? I modified a 4700s cooling system, 1 intake fan in the front, 1 outake, works perfect now, doesnt even get about 80 degrees Farenheit! , ravi


    DELL DIMENSION 2350 @ 2.60GHZ INTEL CELERON,512MB OF RAM, 30GB HARDRIVE
    -----------------------------------------------------------------------------
    DELL DIMENSION 2400CE "DIMENSION 2400 CUSTOM EDITION" @ 2.80GHZ INTEL PENTIUM 4 NORTHWOOD CORE 533MHZ FSB, 1GB OF RAM (512 PCR2700),(512 PCR 3200), 80GB MAXTOR DIAMONDMAX PLUS 9 HARDDRIVE, NVIDIA GEFORCE FX 5200 PCI @ 256MB, 845GV CHIPSET; MODIFIED COOLING SYSTEM @ 2 80MM FANS, 1 PCI SLOT COOLING FAN(FOR FX 5200). www.geocities.com/ravipcplanet/

  • aripie

    10 Posts

    856

    0

    Posted August 5th, 2006 10:00

    I would really love a response to this as well - seeing as how there
    seems to be two types of 4700 shroud types and fans for this system. I
    realize they are both supposed to take in air - but my system is
    immensely cooler and more functional with the fan reversed - I also purchased
    a fan for my vid card - a Antec Vcool fan - and its working great to
    flow air through my entire machine, as well as, my vid card - my question
    is - does reversing the fan harm our systems in any way? We already
    purchased this product from your company and I was even walked through
    this morning by a Dell tech hardware "expert" on how to reverse this fan -
    when apparently wasn't he supposed to tell me what you just stated?
    That it was in fact - correctly placed?
    Thanks,

    Ari

  • ravik521

    2 Intern

    •

    1560 Posts

    856

    0

    Posted August 5th, 2006 16:00

    gus82570  i love it when we ask hard questions to dell, in reality which is very simple if you think about it, the design of the cooling system of the 4700 is basically bad, because it will overheat by factory configuration..... "....." excuse me dell...speechless... you are...  , ravi
    DELL DIMENSION 2350 @ 2.60GHZ INTEL CELERON,512MB OF RAM, 30GB HARDRIVE
    -----------------------------------------------------------------------------
    DELL DIMENSION 2400CE "DIMENSION 2400 CUSTOM EDITION" @ 2.80GHZ INTEL PENTIUM 4 NORTHWOOD CORE 533MHZ FSB, 1GB OF RAM (512 PCR2700),(512 PCR 3200), 80GB MAXTOR DIAMONDMAX PLUS 9 HARDDRIVE, NVIDIA GEFORCE FX 5200 PCI @ 256MB, 845GV CHIPSET; MODIFIED COOLING SYSTEM @ 2 80MM FANS, 1 PCI SLOT COOLING FAN(FOR FX 5200). www.geocities.com/ravipcplanet/
  • jbold

    12 Posts

    856

    0

    Posted August 5th, 2006 18:00

    I gotta agree.  My 4700 ran very warm and I eventually had component failures which, of course, tech support assured me was not an issue with the fan configuration.  However, when I reversed my fan to exhaust air out of the cpu the system ran much cooler than before.  Unexplained static on my sound system led me to the post about turning the fan around.  Once I turned the fan the static completely stopped.  I think this is a major design problem and I hope Dell can give some relief to the folks whose computers have been running way too warm with the associated problems.
  • maneu

    13 Posts

    856

    0

    Posted August 6th, 2006 01:00

    Looks like Dell doesn't want to take responsibily for its actions. If a fan is install backwords, the performance is based on the temperature of the room. Just think, if you like to keep your home some what warm in the winter, do you think that fan is going to pull cool air? I don't think so. Just admit it was a mistake by the factory and be done with it.

    maneu
  • Xenova

    35 Posts

    856

    0

    Posted August 15th, 2006 11:00

    I have had my 4700 machine for sometime, and within the first few weeks of use I realized that there was a serious issue with heat displacement in the machine, hot to the touch. I was eager to find the cause of the problem. I noted that the CPU fan had reverse orientation operation, effectively blowing air into the machine, from the back which was already warm from the PSU. Without checking any forums for advice, I repositioned the fan so it was exhausting the air from the machine. Thereby reducing the heat of the machine by an astounding amount.

    Before reversing the fan I had one of the higher end models of the 4700 series, I have since upgraded my machine. But even before the upgrades I was experiencing harddisk temperatures exceeding 120 to 140F.

    I have two 200 GB harddisk, 2 GB RAM, an Intel P4 HT @ 3.0GHz, an Nvidia Gforce 7900 GT graphics card and a 550 Watt PSU at work in my machine, obviously these components are going to cause considerable amounts of heat themselves. But by blowing already warm air in to the machine from the rear of the chassis, through the heatsink of the CPU, its only going to make the other components of the system hotter, especially the harddisks which are the third biggest heat source in my machine other than the CPU and PSU and have no means of cooling. I have had one premature harddisk failure, that what I believe to be down to excessive temperatures.

    If it is the case that the CPU fan has to have reverse orientation operation, by blowing rather than exhausting air, then this is the first ever machine I have seen this design on to do it successfully, which it doesn’t. However i think its highly unlikley that the CPU voltage regulator requires direct cooling, with a cool system these components will be cooler themselves. I have studied the motherboard of the 4700 and the Volt regulator doesn't seem to have any micro heatsinks on the transistors, if it was true that these components required extra heat displacement, I would expect to see heatsinks.

    Another factor is that by blowing rather than exhausting air, your increasing the amount of dust that is entering the machine, especially across the heatsink of the CPU, and voltage regulator. I had to use nitrogen to blow the dust out of the CPU heatsink and around the volt regulator that had been "blown" into the machine by the reversed fan.

    I use my machine consistently, and I also use it for video editing, so it gets a good thrashing, especially through the rendering stages. The Intel P4 3.00 GHz HT at full throttle emits 50 Watts of heat. To think that, that 50 watts of heat is entering the system with nowhere to go, is a major concern.

    It's also an odd statement that "The air is pulled in through the back of the chassis and is directed straight to the CPU heat sink and CPU voltage regulator before finally passing by the hard drive and out the front of the chassis" because the vilocty of air coming in to the machine is not enough to reach the front let alone cool the harddisks, and if it did it would already be too hot to achieve this effectively. With most harddrive manufactures saying that the ideal operating temps are about 85-90F tops I would have though Dell would have considered this in the design.

    With the CPU fan speed idleing around 1200 RPM and a supposed top speed of 2600, even with the rotation at full throttle isnt enough to make this design work efficiently. I know for a fact that the fan CAN rotate faster, but the recent BIOS mods, have lowered these speeds, the older A01 BIOS version appeared to allow for a faster fan rotation, than the recent ones.

    My system is running fine with the fan inverted to the supposed way that Dell say it should be orientated, I have a fan at the front of the chassis, blowing in and one on the removable side panel blowing in too, so there is more than adequate air flow through the machine. The system temperature is a comfortable 80F and 100F during hard labor.

    I think the supposed design isn’t the way forward with this machine, I don't accuse Dell for this decision, I just think they didn’t design the air flow system in the machine well. If it was a mistake, that the fan was installed backward, then its better to be honest with the situation. But one more thing, I have a friend who brought the same machine but with a slower processor, his fan exhausted the air, I am curious to why.

    If any techie at Dell would like to enlighten us on this situation and tell us how the reverse orientation operation of the CPU fan works effectively I would love to hear it. Meanwhile my fan will exhaust air until I am convinced that the design actually works cause, in my opinion it doesn’t. Otherwise all 4700 system owners have a major problem that may degrade and even shorten the life of their machine.

    Kind Regards

    Dan

    Advanced computer enthusiast

  • ravik521

    2 Intern

    •

    1560 Posts

    856

    0

    Posted August 15th, 2006 13:00

    Dell-ChrisM:

    A reply to all these messages would be greatly appreciated, and i think we would all like to know dell's stand on this particular, serious cooling problem of the dimension 4700. , ravi


    DELL DIMENSION 2350 @ 2.60GHZ INTEL CELERON,512MB OF RAM, 30GB HARDRIVE
    -----------------------------------------------------------------------------
    DELL DIMENSION 2400CE "DIMENSION 2400 CUSTOM EDITION" @ 2.80GHZ INTEL PENTIUM 4 NORTHWOOD CORE 533MHZ FSB, 1GB OF RAM (512 PCR2700),(512 PCR 3200), 80GB MAXTOR DIAMONDMAX PLUS 9 HARDDRIVE, NVIDIA GEFORCE FX 5200 PCI @ 256MB, 845GV CHIPSET; MODIFIED COOLING SYSTEM @ 2 80MM FANS, 1 PCI SLOT COOLING FAN(FOR FX 5200). www.geocities.com/ravipcplanet/

  • Xenova

    35 Posts

    856

    0

    Posted August 15th, 2006 13:00

    I have to agree, I'd like to hear what anyone from Dell has to say about this particular and what is considerd by some of its customers as very serious problem.
  • DELL-Chris M

    Community Manager

    •

    56891 Posts

    •

    232143 Points

    856

    0

    Posted August 15th, 2006 14:00

    All,

    Did the link in my original post work for everyone?


    DELL-Chris M (old account)

    #IWork4Dell

  • ravik521

    2 Intern

    •

    1560 Posts

    615

    0

    Posted August 15th, 2006 15:00

    Dell-ChrisM:

    I think you are missing the point. Did you  read my last post? What do you have to say that I modified the 4700 cooling system and achieved great results? Numerous people here have had great success by just reversing the fan flow. I can agree that the voltage regulator needs direct airflow, but then that purpose is shot, when the fan is bringing in air, and the hot air has no where to go. Well you say it will come out of the front vent, no it wont, because there is no fan there to bring it out. , ravi


    DELL DIMENSION 2350 @ 2.60GHZ INTEL CELERON,512MB OF RAM, 30GB HARDRIVE
    -----------------------------------------------------------------------------
    DELL DIMENSION 2400CE "DIMENSION 2400 CUSTOM EDITION" @ 2.80GHZ INTEL PENTIUM 4 NORTHWOOD CORE 533MHZ FSB, 1GB OF RAM (512 PCR2700),(512 PCR 3200), 80GB MAXTOR DIAMONDMAX PLUS 9 HARDDRIVE, NVIDIA GEFORCE FX 5200 PCI @ 256MB, 845GV CHIPSET; MODIFIED COOLING SYSTEM @ 2 80MM FANS, 1 PCI SLOT COOLING FAN(FOR FX 5200). www.geocities.com/ravipcplanet/