ddm2

updated

9 years ago

D

ddm2

9 Posts

0

21412

February 19th, 2018 13:00

Latitude 7490, 7470 and WD15

I’m considering purchasing a new laptop for home, but I need a docking station that’s compatible with both the 7490 and 7470.  https://www.dell.com/support/article/us/en/04/sln286158/a-guide-to-docking-stations-and-port-replicators-on-dell-latitude-and-precision-notebooks?lang=en appears to state that this will work, but I’d like further confirmation before my purchase.  Assuming this will work, what cable do I need to connect to the 7470 since the included USB Type-C cable that comes with the WD15 will, obviously, not connect to the 7470.  I understand the 7470 will not be able to receive power from the dock.

Thank you.

  • jphughan

    11 Legend

    •

    13985 Posts

    •

    79931 Points

    20726

    1

    Posted February 19th, 2018 13:00

    There may be some late examples of the E7470s that shipped with USB-C or Thunderbolt ports (I know that the E5570 got such an option late in its product lifecycle), but if your unit does not have that, you should NOT expect the WD15 to work with it.  There are adapters to allow connecting USB-A peripherals ("regular USB") to USB-C ports, and certain USB-C peripherals come with adapters that allow them to be connected to USB-A ports.  However, adapters that go in the latter direction are not officially recognized by the USB Implementers Forum precisely because not all USB-C devices are guaranteed to work when connected to a USB-A port.  The WD15's video outputs for example rely on tapping into the DisplayPort Alt Mode functionality of a USB-C port.  USB-A ports don't offer that, so even if you found one of those unofficial adapters I just mentioned and other aspects of the WD15 worked, the display outputs would not.

    The only dock I know of that would work with both systems is the D6000, which can be connected via USB-C or USB-A and can provide power when connected via the former mechanism, but the drawbacks with that dock are that it only supplies 60W of power max (may not be an issue with those systems, but the WD15 can supply 130W to Dell systems if the WD15 itself has a 180W adapter connected) and more importantly, the D6000's display outputs use DisplayLink rather than tapping into the GPU's native outputs.  That's why it can work over USB-A, but DisplayLink has some serious drawbacks compared to native GPU outputs.  It may not be an issue if you plan to have productivity-related content on the displays, but don't expect things like full screen video or games to work well through DisplayLink. I can go into more detail about that if you're curious, or you can probably find more information by Googling around.  You might even find some posts of mine that I've already written in other threads here.

    If DisplayLink's tradeoffs aren't acceptable to you, then unfortunately you'd need to get an E-Dock for the 7470 and a WD15 for the 7490.  The desk real estate penalty is unavoidable, but you can mitigate the need to swap cables back and forth between docks somewhat if you get a suitable KVM switch, for example, although that's of course another piece of hardware.

  • jphughan

    11 Legend

    •

    13985 Posts

    •

    79931 Points

    20723

    1

    Posted February 19th, 2018 14:00

    I just looked at the table under Section 4 of that link you provided.  If you were looking at the lines that said "[Latitude E Series / Precision] systems with USB 3.0 and a docking port on the base" and saw the checkmark for the WD15, those definitely should not be there.  I've submitted feedback to that effect on that page, including recommending adding the D6000 since the D3000 dock listed on that table is ancient.

  • ddm2

    9 Posts

    20715

    0

    Posted February 19th, 2018 22:00

    Thank you for the prompt reply!  Sorry I was unable to do the same.  I seriously appreciate the detail you wrote and, yes, I saw exactly what you noted in that matrix, but it wasn’t adding up for me and that was the reason for my post.  Looks like I’ll have to scrap my plan for docking the 7470 as it’s more trouble than it’s worth.

    Cheers.

  • ribo8

    14 Posts

    20684

    0

    Posted February 21st, 2018 02:00

    Hi @jphughan,

    Did you finally get any laptop?

    I'm also interested in the 7490 with a FullHD (1920x1080) resolution. But I don't know if the panel is TN or IPS.

    Any idea or review?


    Thanks!

  • jphughan

    11 Legend

    •

    13985 Posts

    •

    79931 Points

    20676

    0

    Posted February 21st, 2018 07:00

    I currently have a 7480, right between the two models under discussion in this thread.  Its Full HD panel is definitely IPS, which is confirmed by the review of it on Notebookcheck.  If you've never looked at Notebookcheck's reviews, they are extremely thorough.  Dell has been using Full HD IPS panels in its high-end Latitude models for a while now, so I would imagine that both the E7470 and 7490 use IPS panels as well, at least the Full HD version. I don't know about the 1366x768 panel, but I would avoid that one anyway.