UNSOLVED

and0r

updated

3 years ago

A

and0r

1 Rookie

•

10 Posts

0

3263

October 20th, 2022 08:00

x17 R2, HDMI out not working on monitor

Hello, my new x17 R2 refuses to operate with my external monitor.

My unit has the 3080 Ti/12900HK combo along with the 360Hz 1080p LCD panel.

Judging by what I have observed during all this, It seems the system is sending the wrong parameters to the external monitor. I have tried everything, including disabling Optimus and G-Sync, and nothing seems to work. I have spent a good amount of time on this, on both my system settings and my external monitor settings, really going through everything short of setting my own custom resolution on my system. It seems my display has also sort of black listed this device from connecting. It seems the device is trying to force my 60Hz 4K external display to operate in 360Hz with corresponding h/v frequencies which is why my display is now treating it as something which I assume is  incompatible. 

Am I not allowed to use my new laptop with an external monitor? This x17 R2 laptop is the only device which refuses to cooperate with my monitor. I don't understand how such an issue remains unresolved? I would also assume using an external monitor would be relatively common among x17 owners. Really hoping someone could drop in with useful advice. 

Thanks. 

  • crimsom

    9 Technologist

    •

    6114 Posts

    1036

    0

    Posted October 20th, 2022 09:00

    Hi @and0r welcome to this free user-to-user Alienware laptop discussion forum. 

    Your new Alienware x17 R2 laptop purchase has a minimum of first year Dell warranty. Dell expects users to connect external monitors. Please visit your online Dell account and create Service Request so that Dell Support knows there is a problem to fix. Dell Technical Support should request online session to use their diagnostic tools to fix software interface problems or instigate hardware replacement. 

    How to Daisy Chain Multiple Monitors Using DisplayPort Multi-Stream Transport (MST) | Dell US 


    [This user does not work for Dell and volunteers their free time. Please remember to say thank you by clicking on my thumb up icon.]

  • and0r

    1 Rookie

    •

    10 Posts

    1028

    0

    Posted October 20th, 2022 10:00

    Here are some more details for anyone who is willing to assist.

    Im using certified HDMI 2.0 and 2.1 cables for everything, and they are also known to work. 

    The external display I'm using is a Sony X80J which is also officially designed to be compatible with PC and does indeed work just fine with other PCs connected to it. 

    I'm quite certain my X17 laptop is not correctly handling the display.

    All my X17 system drivers are updated. And I've even gone through the task of reinstalling my entire operating system just to resolve this issue. So I have actually tested this on both versions of Windows 11. Both on 22h1 which was installed by the factory and also on 22 H2 which I installed myself from the ground up using a clean image directly from Microsoft.

    The unit refuses to cooperate with my display no matter what I do. I spend so much time on this already. I am pretty much done and hoping someone just knows what's going on and can offer a simple solution. 

  • and0r

    1 Rookie

    •

    10 Posts

    1029

    0

    Posted October 20th, 2022 10:00

    Yes, Im purposely trying to avoid even mentioning customer support, as I don't wish to seem critical. But I suppose there is no way to avoid even mentioning this.

    My experience with Dell Customer service has been horrendous. It's quite literally the worst I have seen for any reputable company. There is no possible way I would consider using this for anything even remotely technical. And I really don't wish to seem critical, but this is the absolute truth. It's why I'm posting here in hopes someone else may be able to help. 

    I really don't wish to explain my experiences with them further, they really are quite ridiculous. And I'm not here to criticize them. Thank you. 

  • and0r

    1 Rookie

    •

    10 Posts

    1020

    0

    Posted October 20th, 2022 12:00

    Im also using the included power adapter with my system. 

    Really, I have spent so much time with this, I dont believe there is any possible thing which I have missed. 

  • and0r

    1 Rookie

    •

    10 Posts

    971

    0

    Posted October 22nd, 2022 12:00

    It's the Intel Optimus technology. And it's also something to do with how the display manages devices connected to it. It's sort of groups the device inputs into a package... I know this is a very crude explanation of it. Please excuse me...  of course I'm not sure how the internal programming of the display operates, but to me it just seems that way. It also seems to be a problem with the display receiving two different type of parameters coming from the laptop. One from Intel Optimus and the other one from the dedicated Nvidia graphics, at least once again I would assume. 

    This is all really quite ridiculous because it seems that intel is operating a non-standard display architecture which is not compatible with standard display function or protocol. It's really quite ridiculous to release this type of product on the market which would obviously create incompatibilities. But Intel decides to just do it anyway. And it's Dell's responsibility to make sure the technology they include is actually functioning properly. To not be able to connect your device to a display is quite ridiculous. Especially when the display officially supports connections from a PC. 

  • NewUser737

    1 Message

    972

    0

    Posted October 22nd, 2022 12:00

    Same results here.  Best resolution I've gotten with a Sumsung Q60AA 75" is 1280x1024.  I've had no issues using an older Dell laptop with the same cables at 1920x1080.  There is clearly something wrong and Dell Support has been worthless - all my calls end with "Technical Support is in a meeting - call back later"!!!

  • JMB72

    1 Rookie

    •

    2 Posts

    965

    0

    Posted October 22nd, 2022 22:00

    I'm the tech hired gun for NewUser737 - called in after she had Dell support remote into her machine and try to "fix" it.  I did get her machine to finally manage an HDMI connection to the Q60AA 75" TV that her company uses to display kitchen designs to customers.

    First thing to do is open Device Manager and then Display Adapters - there should be two, one for the Intel adapter built into the processor and one for the 3080Ti.  Initially I found only one and it was for the Basic Windows Video Driver!  I uninstalled that and then reran the P&P which installed the correct Intel Driver.

    Next trick was to make sure that the Intel driver saw the Alienware laptop display, not the Generic PnP.  Try running the Detect function on the Display or reboot to get that.

    Next I installed the NVIDIA universal driver from the NVIDIA website, ignoring their warning that the laptop vendor version is usually better.  Once I could open the  NVIDIA control panel the TV magically appeared as connected in the NVIDIA control panel.  To simplify things, I then made the 3080Ti the display adapter for both the build in monitor and the TV.  

    So just cloned the laptop display to the TV, set the resolution to 1920x1080, and got a blank on the TV.  Finally started fooling around with the display frequency settings and after the obvious ones (30Hz, 60HZ, and 120HZ) all failed, found that the 59.???Hz setting made it work - finally a cloned laptop screen on the big TV, just as the customer wanted!

    I got greedy and tried the 4K settings on both the laptop and TV but no joy.  Customer was fine with just HD for now.  If I have time I'll try fooling with the refresh rates at the 4K setting for the TV and maybe that might work.

    All this was under Windows 11, which I don't yet recommend for my customers, so the steps above may be a bit hard to follow and my terms not official Microsoft vocabulary but it did finally work.  If I can lay my hands on the machine again I'll try to fill out the approach in detail.

  • and0r

    1 Rookie

    •

    10 Posts

    953

    0

    Posted October 23rd, 2022 09:00

    To be even more specific, whoever designs motherboards for Dell, probably someone from India, should maybe consider spending the extra 25 cents for an additional HDMI port which is exclusively dedicated to the Nvidia GPU and nothing else. Really quite ridiculous to allow such a premium laptop to be crippled this way. Like nobody considers it useful to have a laptop which can actually function with an external display. 

  • and0r

    1 Rookie

    •

    10 Posts

    954

    0

    Posted October 23rd, 2022 09:00

    Yes, I was able to do this. But it still doesn't work right. Especially when the external display is set as the only output. It will crash your display whenever the computer reboots. 

    The iGPU seems to do a better job of handling it. The display seems to crash whenever the dGPU is involved. Probably has something to do with how some displays manage connections. Which would again suggest that Intel is using non standard methods which are incompatible with many displays. But I also feel this could be resolved by any vendor such as Dell with the right drivers or firmware 

  • 266

    0

    Posted December 29th, 2022 05:00

    Hello,

    Not sure if this is still an issue for you, but i own an X17 R2 with 3080Ti/12700K, and its normally connected through the mini-display port in the machine to the display port on my monitor.

    hope this works out for you