Blueforester

updated

5 years ago

0

2646

November 3rd, 2021 20:00

m15 R3, Dell docking station or other recommendation?

Used chat support twice and got different recommendations. One Dell, one not. Dell was WD19TBS.

On website under compatibility WD19TBS doesn't list m15 R3. And it has a power through TB3 port to charge laptops.  Specifications on laptop says laptop cannot be charged through the TB3 port. So is it safe to use this docking station?

Either way, what is a good alternative to this Dell docking station?

Need to run two large displays, external drives and USB devices. Using for AutoCad, Architectural software, processing drone imagery, mapping, and ESRI GIS software.

Blue

  • jphughan

    11 Legend

    •

    13985 Posts

    •

    79931 Points

    2109

    1

    Posted November 3rd, 2021 21:00

    @Blueforester  Yes it’s “safe” to use the dock, but it’s also not an accident that your Alienware system isn’t listed on the dock’s compatibility list. One reason is that the WD19TBS can only supply up to 130W of power, which is less than your Alienware system is designed for. So even if it DID support being powered over USB-C/TB3, it wouldn’t be able to draw enough power for optimal performance, so you’d want to keep the system’s power source attached anyway. But I believe you’re correct that it doesn’t support power over USB-C/TB3. But that isn’t a problem. You won’t harm anything by connecting a dock. The way USB PD works is that the power source offers various power levels and then the system is allowed to choose from that list. If the system doesn’t want or can’t draw power, it won’t ask for any, and then the dock won’t provide any.

    Another reason that your system isn’t on the list is that Dell doesn’t list ANY laptops in their consumer-oriented product lines in its dock compatibility lists. They only focus on business-oriented product lines, and those are the only lines that Dell gives support for “specialized” features, such as support for the dock’s Power button, PXE boot, and MAC Address Passthrough. If you don’t care about any of that (loss of the Power button is an annoyance, admittedly), then the dock’s main functionality would still work for you — except for power — but lack of support for those features disqualifies those systems from being listed as supported.

    There isn’t a dock that would solve the power issue. There may be other docks that would provide the level of functionality you need if you wanted to look at them, though. The main question will be the displays. Size is completely irrelevant there, so the fact that they’re large displays doesn’t help understand your requirements. The important factors with displays are their resolutions and refresh rates. A Thunderbolt dock like the WD19TBS would be able to run dual displays up to 4K 60 Hz each.

  • 2024

    0

    Posted November 6th, 2021 11:00

    Thanks jphughan for expedient reply.  Haven't been were I could reply.  Very good information you provided.  And it makes since.

    I canceled the order for the m15 R3.  Although delivery is Monday.  When looking on DELL's website for docking station solution the R3 was not showing up any where.  When inquired reply from DELL was something like the m15 R3 has reached the end of its service life and is no longer supported.  I should have researched further before ordering.

    I turned around and ordered an m15 R6.  The R6 has the Thunderbolt 4 upgrade.  So I'm just starting research for a good T4 docking station.  I do not have 4k displays.  Do not recall resolution but have a pair of HP Dream Color displays used with previous HP ZBook.

    Ordered a custom built performance Z-Book three years ago. Had a three year warranty.  It appears from multiple sources the mother board failed three years and three weeks after purchase.  Thus moving in a new direction with the M15R6.  Which is cheaper than what I paid for Z-book three years ago and a new equivalent Z-book.

    What T4 docking stations are those having success with running dual monitors, external drives etc.?  Guessing that powering/charging through the T4 connection from a docking station is not going meet the power demands of the M15R6?

     

    Blue

  • jphughan

    11 Legend

    •

    13985 Posts

    •

    79931 Points

    2013

    1

    Posted November 6th, 2021 14:00

    @Blueforester  Glad I could help.  There aren't very many Thunderbolt 4 docking stations out yet, but for the most part, Thunderbolt 4 just makes previous optional features of Thunderbolt 3 mandatory, such as dual GPU interfaces and PCIe x4 support.  But all Thunderbolt-capable Dell laptops to my knowledge always had the former, and modern Dell laptops all have the latter as well, although the difference between PCIe x4 and PCIe x2 (TB3's minimum requirement) is unlikely to matter anyway unless you're running an eGPU or possibly a high-end storage array through your dock.  Apart from that, TB4 does have a few new features such as support for Thunderbolt hubs rather than only allowing devices to be daisy chained, but unless you plan to connect multiple actual Thunderbolt devices, that won't matter either.  So I wouldn't ignore Thunderbolt 3 docks just because your system has Thunderbolt 4.  Any Thunderbolt 3 dock that has multiple display outputs should be able to run dual displays up to 4K 60 Hz each, as long as you have displays with inputs that can be fed by those outputs as well as the necessary cables/adapters to make valid connections.

    As for power, the USB PD spec was recently revised to support up to 240W, a major jump over the previous 100W official maximum (which Dell stretched to 130W via proprietary means on certain docks and systems).  The m15 R6 appears to be designed for 180-240W depending on the exact hardware configuration, but I doubt it would support that new spec.  The only device I know of at the moment that does is Apple's new 140W USB-C charger meant for the 2021 16" MacBook Pro, and that adapter can only deliver 140W via MagSafe cable.  My understanding is that the actual USB-C/TB4 ports on the system don't support that spec (possibly because it isn't certified for use on Thunderbolt ports yet) and there also aren't even any USB-C to USB-C cables that support the new spec yet either.  So all of that would of course mean that docking stations that provide those power levels are probably a ways off, even if your system would support it, which again I don't think it would.  And for the record, even though USB PD had a 100W max from the beginning, docks that actually provided that much power are still scarce.  It's more common to see 65-90W output.  So it may be a while before there are products that actually implement the 240W power level defined in the very recently approved spec.