Dell XPS 13 9360 with Ultrawide display - Thunderbolt/HDMI/DP?
Hi all, I've seen similar posts to this but still not 100% of the answer so any help appreciated!
I'm looking at connecting an ultra-wide display to my XPS 13 9360 (with Intel HD 620 graphics & Thunderbolt 3 port).
I've narrowed my choice down to 2 models, both Samsung:
49" 5120 X 1440 (120 Hz refresh)
34" 3440 X 1440 (100 Hz refresh) with Thunderbolt 3 connection
Responses to questions similar to mine suggest (I think!) that it's possible for both screens, but methods of connection will result in either a reduction in resolution or refresh rate (or both!).
I won't be using a 2-screen setup.
I understand that my options are:
1. Connect laptop to 34" monitor using a Thunderbolt 3 cable (different to a USB-C cable I appreciate!) from laptop to monitor Thunderbolt ports.
2. Connect laptop to either monitor using a Thunderbolt 3 to DP cable.
3. Connect laptop to either monitor using a Thunderbolt 3 to HDMI cable.
I'm swayed towards the 34" model due to the Thunderbolt support, but the 49" would be nice. I'm assuming here though that a 'pure' thunderbolt connection would be best - perhaps that's not true!
So my question is - what is the best method of connection for each monitor & what resolution/refresh rate would I achieve? Resolution is more important to me than refresh rate as I'm not a gamer.
There's a certain amount of future-proofing here as I may upgrade my laptop in a year or 2, but want the screen to work now with my XPS 13, even if I don't get the full advertised specs as advertised.
So as promised, here's my initial experiences with my XPS 13 9360 & new monitor. I opted for the Samsung 34" 21:9 Ultrawide 3440 X 1440 (100 Hz refresh with Thunderbolt 3 connection, model LC34J791WTUXEN). In summary, it's awesome! I'm glad I went for a Thunderbolt monitor.
Connecting was easy, used included Thunderbolt cable & monitor sprung into life. Initially the monitor displayed the XPS 3200 X 1800 resolution (hence black bars down either side) but changing the XPS display resolution to 3440 X 1440 (which became an option when monitor was connected) allowed full 21:9 display at that resolution. This does of course change the XPS screen display to 3440 X 1440 too which isn't ideal on a 13" screen but since I'm looking at simply duplicating the XPS screen on my monitor it's not an issue.
As it's a Thunderbolt monitor it acts as a USB hub. I was a bit confused at first why the monitor's (type A) USB ports only allowed me to charge things instead of tranfer data but then I found the XPS Thunderbolt software that required me to authorise (or accept) the connection. Once that was done all was well - the 2 USB ports on the monitor behave as if you've connected your peripherals direct to the XPS.
Re: the Thunderbolt connection, there are 2 (type C) connections - one outputs 15W, the other 85W. I used the 85W port & XPS charges fine.
So thanks @jphughan for your help & advice, it was really useful.
If anyone has any questions about the monitor then let me know. Currys (UK) currently have an offer on it for £579 (Samsung price £779!) so a bit of a bargain!
@flyjat Thunderbolt 3 is only better if you actually need the capabilities it provides, otherwise it is not inherently "better" or "purer", so you definitely shouldn't base your decision on that. And actually you might encounter another limitation here that prevents you from fully utilizing its additional bandwidth if you're trying to use it to drive a single display. But let's establish some foundational information here first.
In terms of cable options, these would be your choices worth considering:
Regular USB-C cable, if the display has a USB-C input. In this setup, you'd get either a full DisplayPort interface plus USB 2.0 data, or half of a DisplayPort interface plus USB 3.0 data. And you'd get power either way if the display supports providing it.
USB-C to DisplayPort cable. This gives you a full DisplayPort interface, but no USB data or power at all. You'd typically use this if your display didn't have a USB-C input.
Thunderbolt 3 cable, if you're actually using a native Thunderbolt display. This provides TWO DisplayPort interfaces, plus USB 3.x, plus power. The catch here is that Intel GPUs do not support DisplayPort link aggregation, which is the ability to combine the bandwidth of multiple DisplayPort interfaces in order to drive a single display. They support DisplayPort MST, which is the ability to split a single DisplayPort interface to drive multiple independent displays so long as their total bandwidth requirement falls within what that single interface can provide, but that's the opposite of what you need. The bottom line is that TB3's additional bandwidth won't help you for driving a single display. The only thing you could do with it would be to attach some Thunderbolt 3 peripheral to the display. Since the XPS 13 only has a single TB3 port, that could be handy since if you're using the USB-C/TB3 port with a device that does NOT offer a TB3 daisy chain port, then you'd have no way to attach that device and some other TB3 peripheral -- but do you have that type of TB3 peripheral? Typically that would be either a Thunderbolt SSD or an external GPU enclosure.
In terms of your system, it's also important to note that it supports DisplayPort 1.2 with HBR2 bandwidth levels. Newer systems support DisplayPort 1.3 or 1.4, which use HBR3 and therefore can provide more bandwidth out of a single interface. This will come into play too.
Ok, so in terms of how that translates to your display. 3440x1440 at 100 Hz should NOT require Thunderbolt 3. It should be possible to run that over a full DisplayPort 1.2 interface, because a full DP 1.2 interface can run 4K 60 Hz, and that requires slightly more bandwidth than 3440x1440 at 100 Hz. If the display has a Thunderbolt 3 port, I suspect it's to support connecting two such displays in a daisy chain, allowing you to drive both from a single cable connection to your PC. Running TWO of those would definitely require TB3 in order to get that second DisplayPort interface out of the system.
As for 5120x1440, that can be driven at 60 Hz using a single DisplayPort 1.2 interface. However, 5120x1440 at 120 Hz can't be. And if you're looking at the Samsung C49RG90, I just looked at the manual for that display last night while working on an answer to another user who asked about that display. Here is a direct link to that post. The option I mentioned there about running DP 1.4 from the XPS 15 would not apply on your system. You'd only have DP 1.2 available, which I'm fairly certain will be fine for running that 5120x1440 display at 60 Hz despite the odd documentation I noted there. In fact come to think of it, I've seen confirmation of the CRG90 working at 5120x1440 60 Hz from HBR2 systems here before. But 5120x1440 120 Hz would be off the table for you with your system.
So in terms of which to get, if you value resolution over refresh rate, I don't know why this is even a question. If you have the budget and desk space, get the 49" version, which offers almost 50% more physical size AND workspace in terms of resolution (since the pixel densities of those two displays are identical). That is significant. The fact that the 3440x1440 display offers TB3 doesn't do anything for you unless you plan to run two of them or you have some other TB3 peripheral you'd also need to connect.
And by the way, if you decide to go 5120x1440, then considering that you wouldn't be able to run 120 Hz anyway, you might want to price shop against the Dell U4919DW, which is also a 49" 5120x1440 display. It only goes to 60 Hz, but again that's all you'll get out of this system anyway.
@jphughan Hi, thanks so much for the comprehensive reply, you're clearly an expert in this area.
I did consider the Dell 49" but from a price standpoint it's identical to the Samsung 49" (it was actually 20% more expensive until recently). The Samsung though does beat the Dell in almost all specs (e.g. refresh rate, brightness, contrast ratio, HDR etc.) & although much of it won't be relevant due to the limitations of my XPS 13, the Samsung would 'future-proof' me should I upgrade my PC.
That said, I am still considering the Dell due to its shallower curve & it doespdoes have a USB-C port, which brings me to another question:
What do you mean by full & half DP interfaces when connecting via USB-C? If I connected my XPS to the Dell screen via a USB-C cable do I "choose" the full vs half DP interface? Would that affect the resolution or refresh rate? Apologies if I've misunderstood that.
Finally, I notice you didn't mention USB-C (or Thunderbolt) to HDMI - is this a lesser option?
@flyjat In terms of how the USB-C interface is set up, I've provided a link below to a detailed post I wrote about the various operating modes of USB-C and TB3, with specific attention paid to the impact on possible display setups, but very briefly, a USB-C link has four high speed lanes. Ignoring TB3 for a moment, the high speed lanes can be allocated to either USB 3.x data or DisplayPort video. USB 2.0 flows over separate pins dedicated to that purpose. If you don't care about USB 3.x, you get four lanes of video, which matches a full DisplayPort interface. If you do want to run USB 3.x, that requires two high speed lanes -- which leaves only two for video, i.e. half of a DisplayPort interface. Yes, that absolutely affects resolution and/or refresh rate, since you now have half the available bandwidth. On an HBR2 system like the XPS 13 9360, four lanes will allow you to run 4K 60 Hz (or dual QHD 60 Hz), but if you only have two lanes, you can only run single QHD 60 Hz or 4K 30 Hz. Here is the link to the explainer post I wrote. Note that the upcoming USB4 standard will be changing this by essentially doing what TB3 is already doing. Instead of allocating entire lanes to a particular traffic type regardless of how much of that traffic is actually flowing across the wire, it will dynamically shift the composition of the data running across the link based on what type of traffic actually needs to cross the link. Combined with DisplayPort DSC, which will mean that the amount of video traffic required for a given display setup will not always be fixed at a constant rate, this would for example allow more USB bandwidth depending on your display setup (and what's happening on them), or more video bandwidth if you don't actually need full USB 3.x rates but want something better than USB 2.0. But that's not what we have today since USB4 hasn't arrived.
In terms of how this is set up, the display sets up the USB-C link, and sometimes this is configurable on the display, and sometimes not. For example, Dell's U4919DW sets up the USB-C link to allocate all four lanes to video, since that's needed to run 5120x1440 60 Hz using HBR2, and therefore it only supports USB 2.0 data rates over USB-C. If you want USB 3.x data, you'd have to run a separate USB 3.0 cable between your display and system in order to create a data path for that. Some newer 27" Dell USB-C displays have a USB-C Prioritization option that you can set between High Resolution (4 video lanes, USB 2.0) or High Data Rate (2 video lanes, USB 3.x). That's because they can take advantage of HBR3 systems. So let's say you have a 4K 60 Hz display that offers this option. If you're connecting it to an HBR2 system, you'd probably want to continue with High Resolution so you can still run 4K 60 Hz, but then you only get USB 2.0 data speeds (or you can use 4K 30 Hz + USB 3.x). But let's say you have an HBR3 system. In that case, you'd be able to run 4K 60 Hz using only two lanes, in which case you might choose High Data Speed to run 4K 60 Hz and USB 3.x over a single USB-C cable, which wouldn't be possible on an HBR2 system. OR you might STILL want to use High Resolution to keep all 4 lanes dedicated to video, because when you do that on an HBR3 system, you could run a daisy chain of DUAL 4K 60 Hz displays from a single USB-C connection, albeit with only USB 2.0 data. It all depends on what type of system you have and whether you might want daisy chaining more than USB 3.x data.
But again, not all displays offer this configuration flexibility. The best way to find out what's possible on a display you're considering is to read its manual.
As for USB-C to HDMI, if you really need the ability to connect to an HDMI display/TV, then it's a perfectly reasonable option, but I tend to prefer USB-C to DisplayPort whenever it would be viable for the display I'm connecting to. The reason is that USB-C ports use DisplayPort for video output in the first place, so USB-C to HDMI cables/adapters need to incorporate an active converter chip to switch that signal to HDMI. That's just one more thing to pay for and one more thing to possibly go wrong. I try to avoid cost and complexity where it doesn't add any value to me. I just recently helped someone here who was having trouble getting a USB-C to HDMI adapter to work with their Dell system even though it worked fine with another laptop. After some troubleshooting, I basically said, "It's either a problem with your motherboard that's preventing video output [he didn't have another way to test USB-C video output available] or it's a bizarre interoperability problem that affects the specific combination of that adapter you have and that system. But since a motherboard replacement would be a huge ordeal, I would consider trying another USB-C to HDMI adapter even though your current one works with another system." He got a different one and it worked with both of his systems.
And then USB-C to HDMI equipment tends to cost a bit more, all else being equal. The reason is that HDMI (the organization) charges manufacturers a royalty for every HDMI port or connector they install on a product, whereas DisplayPort is royalty-free.
@flyjat One thing I forgot to add since you mentioned HDR. The Samsung CRG90 manual says that HDR is available over DisplayPort only in DP 1.4 mode -- which your system won't support -- or in HDMI 2.0 mode. You can get a USB-C to HDMI 2.0 cable/adapter, but since that would still be fed by a DP 1.2 signal from USB-C, you won't be able to use that type of cable/adapter to add HDR that way. Formal HDR support didn't arrive on DisplayPort until DP 1.4, and actually I'm pretty sure 5120x1440 60 Hz with HDR would exceed the bandwidth capability of DP 1.2 anyway. If you want to get an HDR display for futureproofing, then fair enough, but I just wanted to let you know not to count on being able to use that capability from your current system. Or I guess you could connect a modern gaming console to the display, set it to PBP mode, and use HDR on the half of the display allocated to that console.
Hi again @jphughan, more top level info, thanks so much.
The fact about DP being 'built in' to USB-C/TB3 is useful - kinda makes it an obvious choice to use DP instead of HDMI (if USB-C not an option).
As it happens, my new desk arrived yesterday & I spent the day building it, which has helped with my decision. With 1500mm space on the top shelf where I plan to put the screen & my speakers (also called monitors but I'll avoid that term to avoid confusion!), a 49" screen would be a tight fit & would look a bit cramped.
43" displays don't impress me (e.g. 1200 vertical resolution) & the TB3 Samsung seems to be the best for my requirements. As I hinted above, I'm using the setup for music production & having the ability to plug stuff in (& charge) from the screen is very useful so a USB-C &/or TB3 port is desirable. The Samsung has lots of ports.
There's some great offers too on the Samsung at the moment.
When I do get the screen I'll certainly post back with my thoughts & experiences.
Thanks again for all your help & advice, proper tech gold!
The monitor has built in speakers but my XPS doesn't recognise it as a sound output. Only 'Speakers/Headphones (Realtek Audio)' is an option. I've looked at Control Panel, Device Manager etc.
When I connect my wife's MacBook to it, display & audio (i.e. sound from the display) work fine so I know it's not a monitor issue.
A Google search suggests this isn't a unique problem. I'm guessing something's up with the Thunderbolt connection since the Realtek Audio.
Yep using Thunderbolt cable & all authorised - in Thunderbolt Software, it just says Thunderbolt Controller 1 -> Port 1 -> SAMSUNG ELECTRONICS etc. & clicking on that shows 'Connected'.
I just reinstalled the Thunderbolt software too, no change.
Display driver (from Samsung) up to date - just reinstalled that too.
No exclamation marks in device manager.
The monitor itself doesn't really have that many settings so doubt it's that.
@flyjat Ok, so you're still using the native Thunderbolt connection, right? Have you checked Thunderbolt Software or Thunderbolt Control Center to see if there are any attached devices that haven't been "approved"? Thunderbolt on Windows to my knowledge will allow video output without approval but will NOT allow PCIe access (since that poses security risks), and the interface to an audio chipset in the display would have to run over PCIe. So I would think it might be possible for you to still have a video signal but no audio if you didn't "approve" the display as a Thunderbolt device, and Macs don't use the same Thunderbolt device approval mechanism that exists on Windows.
If that's not it, then since you've confirmed audio works from another system, AND you've looked in Control Panel > Sound (make sure you're NOT in Category View on Control Panel) as well as Device Manager, then I'm not sure what to suggest. I would expect that you would see either a) another audio output device under Control Panel > Sound corresponding to your display, in which case for most applications to use it, you'd just have to set that as the default playback device, OR b) some a device that's unknown or displaying an error in Device Manager, in which case installing a driver should resolve that and then you can check Control Panel > Sound. But if you're not seeing either of those, then you might have to do a bit more research or contact the display vendor, since I don't have any experience with that specific display. Sorry!
I found a solution - I uninstalled all audio/sound controllers, restarted PC & device manager now showed a yellow exclamation mark under 'Other Devices' --> Intel High Definition Audio. It said no driver was installed (code 28) & trying to auto update it via Windows search failed as it reported 'no driver could be found'.
I then searched for this new problem (yellow exclamation mark & Intel HD Audio) & came across this thread:
that suggested a re-install of the Intel Graphics HD 620 driver might work.
So I did that, restarted my PC. On looking at device manager, the yellow exclamation mark had gone & now under Audio inputs & outputs' was listed 'C3479Jx Intel(R) Display Audio'.
& sound was now routed through the monitor!
So I got there in the end - I hope this helps someone with a similar problem.
flyjat
15 Posts
8962
0
Posted June 30th, 2020 03:00
So as promised, here's my initial experiences with my XPS 13 9360 & new monitor. I opted for the Samsung 34" 21:9 Ultrawide 3440 X 1440 (100 Hz refresh with Thunderbolt 3 connection, model LC34J791WTUXEN).
In summary, it's awesome! I'm glad I went for a Thunderbolt monitor.
Connecting was easy, used included Thunderbolt cable & monitor sprung into life. Initially the monitor displayed the XPS 3200 X 1800 resolution (hence black bars down either side) but changing the XPS display resolution to 3440 X 1440 (which became an option when monitor was connected) allowed full 21:9 display at that resolution. This does of course change the XPS screen display to 3440 X 1440 too which isn't ideal on a 13" screen but since I'm looking at simply duplicating the XPS screen on my monitor it's not an issue.
As it's a Thunderbolt monitor it acts as a USB hub. I was a bit confused at first why the monitor's (type A) USB ports only allowed me to charge things instead of tranfer data but then I found the XPS Thunderbolt software that required me to authorise (or accept) the connection. Once that was done all was well - the 2 USB ports on the monitor behave as if you've connected your peripherals direct to the XPS.
Re: the Thunderbolt connection, there are 2 (type C) connections - one outputs 15W, the other 85W. I used the 85W port & XPS charges fine.
So thanks @jphughan for your help & advice, it was really useful.
If anyone has any questions about the monitor then let me know. Currys (UK) currently have an offer on it for £579 (Samsung price £779!) so a bit of a bargain!